World > North America > United States > Pennsylvania > Allegheny > Hotels in Pittsburgh > Mansions on Fifth

Mansions on Fifth

Pittsburgh , 5105 Fifth Ave (Show on Map)

8.6

Very Good

➔

Please select your travel dates to see rates and availability

Check In

Check Out

1 room2 guests 1 room, 2 guests

We couldn't find available deals from this provider.

Double-check for availability on our partners' websites:

Alternatively, you can change dates or view all Hotels in Pittsburgh

Info

Summary of reviewsMansions on Fifth is a beautiful and historic hotel located in the charming neighborhood of Shadyside, making it an ideal location for guests. The vintage-style property has plenty of charm with its old homes turned into hotels. Guests can enjoy the convenience of the nearby retail area on Walnut St and the free off-street parking is a bonus. The hotel's helpful and charming staff make up for any minor issues and the location is perfect for those looking to walk to restaurants or explore the beautiful neighborhood on foot. The hotel offers spacious and comfortable rooms with unique decor and paintings and the beds are exceptional, providing for a great night's rest. The hotel is dedicated to covid cleanliness and the property is very clean and quiet. The hotel's restaurant may have been affected by COVID, but the helpful staff at the cocktail bar provided fantastic suggestions for nearby dinner options. The hotel is a must-see at a minimum, even if staying is not possible, as it offers a unique and beautiful stay with an amazing historical background. Overall, Mansions on Fifth is considered a fabulous place that is not to be missed, as it is a truly gorgeous historical building.
Show more

Categories

Boutique-style Hotel

Luxury Hotel

Historic Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

Family Friendly Hotel

Romantic Hotel

Business Hotel

Hotel with Parking

Accessible Hotel

Hotel with Gym

4-Star Hotel

Room Types

About Mansions on Fifth

Show Map

Guest Reviews

8.6

Very Good

Location

Mansions on Fifth is located in the beautiful, historic neighborhood of Shadyside, making it an ideal location for guests. The hotel is situated within walking distance of shops, restaurants and some of the city's most prestigious universities like CMU and Pitt. The vintage-style property has plenty of charm with its old homes turned into hotels. Guests can enjoy the convenience of the nearby retail area on Walnut St and the free off-street parking is a bonus. The location is perfect for those looking to walk to restaurants or explore the beautiful neighborhood on foot. The area is surrounded by gorgeous mansions and has great proximity to the Carnegie museums. Although parking could be challenging, the hotel's helpful and charming staff make up for it. Whether you're looking for a romantic getaway, a family vacation or just a beautiful neighborhood to stay in, Mansions on Fifth is the perfect location to enjoy all that Pittsburgh has to offer.

Breakfast

The breakfast at Mansions on Fifth has a mixed reputation with some guests praising it and others feeling let down. Some guests found the breakfast to be "so good" and "amazing," while others were disappointed by the limited selection, describing it as "nothing but fruit and a muffin" or wanting "more variety." Some guests found that the breakfast kept to Covid-19 regulations, being "grab and go," while others missed the option for a "hot breakfast" and found that the "grab and go breakfasts were meh." However, there were some criticisms, including poor coffee quality and a lack of mini fridges in the rooms to keep leftovers cold. In general, it seems that guests had mixed expectations for the breakfast and that the hotel's current offerings may not be to everyone's taste.

Dinner

In the charming 'Mansions on Fifth', guests can expect a delightful stay with an amazing dinner experience. Although the hotel's restaurant was affected by COVID, the helpful staff at the cocktail bar provided fantastic suggestions for nearby dinner options, complete with a map. The only downside was that the Valentine's dinner was not communicated to guests. However, despite the temporary closures, guests can still enjoy delivery options. Besides, the cocktail bar remains a great spot for pre-dinner drinks. While breakfast was average, the wait was worth it as the food warmed up to perfection. All in all, a great stay awaits at Mansions on Fifth.

Rooms

Mansions on Fifth is a beautiful hotel that offers a unique atmosphere with historical old world charm. The architecture inside the building is amazing with gorgeous stained glass windows and other beautiful architectural details. The property is big with large, spacious rooms that are clean and comfortable. The bathroom is a dream come true and the bed is very comfortable. The property is very clean and quiet, making it a great place for a relaxing stay. Each room is different, but all are spacious and comfortable with some even featuring fireplaces and claw foot tubs. While some rooms needed a bit of restoration and lacked modern amenities, the old vintage style of the hotel itself is charming. The hotel also offers coffee makers in-room and towels were exchanged and bed made regularly. There were some minor issues reported, such as garbage cans not being emptied and coffee not being restocked, along with occasional maintenance issues such as shower water pressure being weak or showers only being lukewarm. Some guests also reported quirks such as needing to slam the door shut for the lock to catch or no 'do not disturb' signs in the rooms. However, overall the hotel is beautiful and clean with impeccable rooms and a friendly staff. The hotel is a must-see at a minimum, even if staying is not possible. If stairs are an issue, guests should ask for the location of their room. There are different options for rooms with some being in the main mansion and others in a separate annex building.

Beds

Mansions on Fifth is the perfect place for those who prioritize a good night's sleep. The beds here are exceptional - very comfortable with super comfy pillows. Although a few guests found the mattress to be too firm or too old, most reviews rave about the comfort of the beds. The only downside noted was a urine-stained comforter or an uncomfortable plastic mattress cover. Guests enjoyed spacious and comfortable rooms with large beds and comfortable pillows. Some rooms even had sofa beds, although a few guests found them to be terrible or too small for four people. Overall, guests agree that the beds are incredibly comfortable and provide for a great night's rest.

Cleanliness

Mansions on Fifth is a beautiful and clean hotel that is dedicated to covid cleanliness. The property is very clean and quiet with friendly staff who provide great housekeeping services. Most of the guests were impressed with how clean the hotel was with rooms being described as beautiful, clean and lovely. Although some guests were less impressed, mentioning issues such as dirty towels, minor repairs needed and cobwebs in the bathroom corner, overall the cleanliness was rated positively. Rooms were described as clean, comfortable and some even had stained glass windows. Despite some minor issues, Mansions on Fifth is a great choice for a clean and comfortable stay.

Staff

The staff at Mansions on Fifth hotel in Pittsburgh were described as phenomenal, friendly, helpful, accommodating, knowledgeable and exceptional. The bar tender was complimented for making amazing drinks and staff like Rose and Christopher were singled out for their lovely and fantastic service. However, a few guests complained about a single unfriendly front desk woman and some untrained or disorganized staff. Overall, the staff at Mansions on Fifth were welcoming and made guests feel at home in the beautiful and historic hotel.

Wi-Fi

Mansions on Fifth may be a beautiful and luxurious hotel, but some guests have remarked that their internet connection could use some improvement. Some guests found it challenging to access the internet, despite being given passwords. The wifi was slow in some areas and the guest wifi did not work in some rooms. However, others were able to access the private hotel wifi and some found it worked well in the hallways. Overall, some guests found the internet connection to be horrible, but some were able to get access to the wifi. It seems that the hotel may need to upgrade their capabilities in this area, but it's worth mentioning that the beauty and luxury of Mansions on Fifth make up for any wifi issues.

Parking

The Mansions on Fifth hotel offers easy parking for guests with many indicating that the parking was free, which is a huge bonus in the city. While some guests noted that parking was limited or a little small, others found there to be plenty of parking available. The valet out front was praised for being helpful and nice. Though there were some issues with parking during events, overall, guests found the parking to be easy and adequate for the area. The added perk of free off-street parking was also appreciated by guests.

4 Star

Mansions on Fifth is a beautiful historic mansion situated in a great location with a quaint neighborhood. The staff was helpful and accommodating, making the stay memorable. The rooms and bathrooms were spacious and comfortable with unique decor and paintings. However, some guests experienced issues such as a lack of breakfast options, delayed check-in and non-functional thermostat control. Despite these minor setbacks, the hotel was listed as a luxury accommodation and provided a great value for the four star rating. The mansion grounds were well-maintained with beautiful flowers and impressive stained glass features. Overall, Mansions on Fifth provided a wonderful experience that left guests wanting to return soon.

Business

Mansions on Fifth offers a luxury and convenient stay in a great location for business travelers visiting Pittsburgh. The informative staff provides excellent service and the rooms are smart, clean and comfortable. In-room coffee makers and complimentary water bottles are just some of the amenities provided. Guests appreciate the comfort and safety during their stay, especially during COVID times. The property is located adjacent to Pitt and CMU, making it a convenient location for business trips. The only improvement that could be made is the addition of more charging stations next to the bed. Overall, Mansions on Fifth provides a great experience for business travelers on short trips to Pittsburgh.

Accessible

Mansions on Fifth offers cozy and clean rooms with comfortable amenities. The hotel is conveniently located close to the hospital and offers off-street parking. However, guests with mobility issues may struggle to navigate their way around certain parts of the hotel due to the lack of an elevator in some areas and the presence of difficult steps. Some rooms also have a large step in the shower stall, which may pose a challenge. Despite these limitations, the hotel staff is friendly and accommodating and will make every effort to ensure a comfortable stay for all guests. Due to COVID-19 restrictions, guests can expect a more limited hotel experience with fewer guests in common areas such as the lobby and dining room. It is worth noting that the hotel does not provide in-room microwaves or mini-fridges.

Historic

Experience a unique and beautiful stay at 'Mansions on Fifth', a hotel with a rich historical background. This beautiful historic mansion is located in the historic Shadyside neighborhood with an amazing architecture that reflects the Italian influence of the building. The lobby and public spaces are fully restored and beautiful with plenty of character and old-world charm. The building is absolutely gorgeous with stain glass windows and original woodwork that adds to the fascinating backstory of the hotel. The hotel is located in a great location in Pittsburgh, offering a taste of the history of Pittsburgh. The rooms may not be as great as the beautiful common areas, but the ambience and feel of being in a historic mansion are worth the price. This well restored historic home is truly one of a kind with the Donald Deskey paintings on the 3rd floor especially impressive. Step back in time and immerse yourself in the beautiful architecture and history of this unique and historic hotel.

Luxury

Mansions on Fifth is a unique and charming hotel with beautiful property and stunning architecture filled with history. The lovely mansion boasts historic elegance and an ambiance that oozes old-world charm for a stately hotel experience. Every detail is luxurious and convenient, making it definitely worth the money. Despite some negative experiences mentioned in a few reviews, overall, Mansions on Fifth is considered a fabulous place that is not to be missed, as it is a truly gorgeous historical building.

No, Mansions on Fifth doesn't have any pool.

No, a spa isn't available at Mansions on Fifth.

No, Mansions on Fifth doesn't allow dogs.

Yes, parking facilities are available at Mansions on Fifth.

Yes, Mansions on Fifth has a gym.

More Options