Humphreys Half Moon Inn

San Diego 32.71781100, -117.22373400 , 2303 Shelter Island Drive (Show on Map)
8.6
Very Good


Please select your travel dates to see rates and availability
Check In
Check Out
1 room2 guests 1 room, 2 guests
Info
Summary of reviewsHumphreys Half Moon Inn on Shelter Island offers a prime location that balances the lively city of San Diego with a serene, resort-like atmosphere. Guests frequently commend its beautiful waterfront setting with picturesque views of the marina, bay and cityscape, enhanced by tropical landscaping. Its central position provides easy access to downtown, beaches, Liberty Station and other popular attractions, making it ideal for both families and couples.

While breakfast received mixed reviews with some guests enjoying delicious meals and scenic views, others were disappointed by the lack of complimentary options and occasional quality issues. Dinner, however, is highly praised for its delicious, well-prepared dishes and the wonderful ambiance provided by live music and fantastic views, despite some high costs and a few service inconsistencies.

Rooms are generally well-received with many guests appreciating their cleanliness, spaciousness and comfort, along with scenic views and modern amenities like microwaves and refrigerators. However, some rooms appear dated with minor maintenance issues and could use renovation. The overall feedback on cleanliness is positive, noting immaculate upkeep of both rooms and public areas, though occasional lapses in housekeeping were reported.

The staff at Humphreys Half Moon Inn generally receive high praise for their friendliness, helpfulness and efficiency. Despite sporadic reports of less pleasant interactions, the majority of guests highlight their positive experiences with the hotel staff. The free wifi service is also a highlight for many guests, though its reliability varies across different rooms.

The gym, while functional, is small and lacks some equipment, leading to mixed reviews. Guests consistently enjoy the well-maintained pool area with its relaxed temperature, heated pool and pleasant ambiance created by tropical gardens and tiki torches. The jacuzzi and hot tub also add to the overall poolside appeal, though some guests wished for more seating and extended food and drink service.

Parking provokes mixed reactions due to fees and occasional inconvenience, although it is generally considered satisfactory once understood. The inn stands out as a family-friendly destination, providing spacious rooms, a child-friendly pool and various nearby activities that make it ideal for memorable family vacations.

Overall, the positive aspects of Humphreys Half Moon Inn, particularly its excellent location, beautiful setting, friendly staff, comfortable rooms and enjoyable dining and pool experiences, outweigh the occasional drawbacks, making it a solid choice for travelers seeking both relaxation and convenience in San Diego.
Show more
Categories
Family Friendly Hotel
Located on Shelter Island, this Polynesian-themed hotel features lush gardens, a pool, and live music. Its relaxed atmosphere and spacious rooms make it suitable for families.

Hotel with Swimming Pool
This hotel provides a relaxing pool experience with a tropical atmosphere. The pool area is surrounded by lush greenery, creating a tranquil environment.

  Outdoor Pool  


3-Star Hotel
This hotel is known for its Polynesian theme and waterfront location on Shelter Island. It provides a unique and comfortable experience, with amenities like a pool and live music, offering good value for its price.

Hotel with Outdoor Pool
Humphreys Half Moon Inn provides a sparkling outdoor heated pool and a hot tub, set amidst lush tropical greenery. The pool area offers a secluded island oasis feel with an Oasis Pool Bar and waterfront and marina views.

Hotel for Honeymoon

Business Hotel

Hotel with Parking

Hotel with Gym

Room Types
Junior Suite This suite features furnished patio or balcony with water views in the distance.

Oversized Garden View Suite This spacious suite features a flat-screen TV.

Standard King Non View Room King room offers a cable TV, a microwave, a fridge and tea/coffee-making facilities.

Tropical View King Room Featuring free Wi-Fi, this room includes a flat-screen TV, a microwave, a fridge and tea and coffee-making facilities.

Tropical View Queen Room Featuring free Wi-Fi, this room includes a flat-screen TV, a microwave, a fridge and tea and coffee-making facilities.

Standard Queen Non View Room Featuring free Wi-Fi, this room includes a flat-screen TV, a microwave, a fridge and tea and coffee-making facilities.

Standard Queen Non View Accessible Room This air-conditioned quadruple room includes a flat-screen TV with cable channels and a private bathroom. The unit offers 2 beds.

Standard Queen Non View Accessible Room with Roll-in Shower Providing free toiletries, this quadruple room includes a private bathroom with a walk-in shower, a bath and a hairdryer. The quadruple room provides air conditioning, a coffee machine, a wardrobe, a safe deposit box and a flat-screen TV with cable channels. The unit offers 2 beds.

Water View Two Standard Queen Beds Providing free toiletries, this quadruple room includes a private bathroom with a bath and a hairdryer. The quadruple room features carpeted floors, a seating area with a flat-screen TV with cable channels, air conditioning, a coffee machine, as well as a wardrobe. The unit offers 2 beds.

Guest Reviews
8.6
Very Good
Location
Located on Shelter Island, Humphreys Half Moon Inn boasts a prime spot that combines the best of both worlds—convenient proximity to the bustling city of San Diego and a tranquil, resort-like atmosphere. Guests rave about the hotel's beautiful waterfront setting, offering picturesque views of the marina, the bay and the cityscape. The tropical, Hawaiian-style landscaping and well-maintained grounds enhance the relaxing ambiance, making visitors feel like they are on an island retreat.

The location is frequently described as perfect or amazing with many appreciating its central position between downtown San Diego and various beaches. The hotel also offers easy access to popular spots such as Liberty Station, the San Diego Zoo and Old Town. Restaurants, bars and entertainment venues are within walking distance, adding to the convenience.

Families appreciate the quiet and safe environment, while couples find it ideal for a romantic getaway. Some guests mention the slight drawback of aircraft noise due to proximity to the airport, yet they still commend the overall setting and atmosphere. Whether for a relaxing staycation or a base for exploring San Diego's attractions, the location of Humphreys Half Moon Inn consistently leaves a positive impression.

Breakfast
Humphreys Half Moon Inn presents a mixed experience when it comes to breakfast offerings. On the positive side, guests appreciated the scenic views during breakfast in the restaurant with mentions of enjoying delicious meals like omelets. The option for a discount on breakfast and dinner was also noted by some as a plus. However, several guests expressed disappointment with the absence of a complimentary breakfast and the lack of lobby coffee in the mornings. Some found the breakfast food cold and not meeting their expectations, while others mentioned it was expensive. For those seeking alternatives, there are good breakfast spots nearby that came recommended. Overall, while some found the breakfast experience enjoyable and satisfying, others felt it left room for improvement.

Dinner
Humphreys Half Moon Inn offers a notable dining experience praised for its delicious and well-prepared food. Guests rave about the delightful dishes such as Halibut, scallops, clam chowder, ribs and truffle pasta, all receiving high marks for taste. The restaurant's fantastic views complement its wonderful food, making it a highlight for many visitors. The lounge area adds to the experience, providing nice food along with live music, enhancing the ambiance.

Despite the high costs and a few operational inconsistencies, many guests found that the quality of food justified the price. The poolside food and drink service received commendations, though some wished it remained available longer. Dining by the pool area was a treat, albeit with limited options and occasional crowding.

The on-site restaurant's performance varied among guests with some noting it needed improvement or found it below expectations. However, overall, the feedback leans towards praise for the fine dining experience, excellent quality meals and great service.

While the immediate vicinity lacks other restaurant options, several good alternatives are available within a short drive, providing a convenient solution for diverse dining needs.

Overall, the dining experience at Humphreys Half Moon Inn generally leaves a positive impression, thanks to the combination of great food, views and live entertainment.

Rooms
Humphreys Half Moon Inn receives generally positive feedback for its rooms, which are frequently described as clean, spacious and comfortable. Many guests appreciate the beautiful views from their rooms, whether of the marina, gardens or the bay. The rooms often feature modern amenities such as microwaves, refrigerators and well-furnished interiors, enhancing the overall comfort. Bed quality is another strong point with several guests noting their comfort.

However, some reviews indicate that the rooms are dated and in need of renovation. Issues such as musty smells, peeling wallpaper and old carpets are mentioned. There are also occasional reports of less-than-perfect cleanliness, small room sizes and outdated decor. Despite these drawbacks, the size of many rooms is praised, ranging from ample junior suites to large apartments with full kitchens.

The hotel’s surroundings also add to the positive experience with many cafes and restaurants nearby and plenty of activities to enjoy in the immediate vicinity. Rooms with balconies and large bathrooms are highlights for some guests, though views and room conditions can vary. Overall, while there are areas for improvement, the spaciousness, comfortable beds and scenic views make Humphreys Half Moon Inn a solid choice for many travelers.

Beds
The beds at Humphreys Half Moon Inn have garnered a mix of reactions from guests, though the majority of reviewers found the beds to be comfortable or even extremely comfortable. Phrases such as comfortable beds, beds were very comfortable and beds were so comfortable suggest that most guests enjoyed a good night’s sleep. Several visitors also appreciated the softness of the mattresses and the availability of extra pillows, including both soft and hard options to cater to different preferences. Some described the bedding as great, poetic and nice, contributing to the overall positive experience.

However, not all reviews were entirely favorable. A number of guests noted issues like tired or saggy mattresses, beds that were a bit too soft or firm and occasional discomfort. Some guests explicitly mentioned that the beds need replacing and pointed out lumpy pillows, thin and old bedding or beds that hurt their backs. A few even experienced broken beds, which significantly detracted from their stay.

Despite these mixed reviews, it’s clear that the hotel has put effort into ensuring a level of comfort that many guests have appreciated. Still, there is room for improvement, particularly in terms of mattress quality and consistency in bed comfort.

Cleanliness
Humphreys Half Moon Inn has generally received positive feedback regarding its cleanliness. Guests frequently praise the hotel for its clean rooms, well-maintained property and spotless public areas, including the pool and jacuzzi, which are often described as very clean and inviting. The gardens and grounds are also noted for their immaculate upkeep, contributing to a clean and beautiful environment around the inn. Bedding and blankets receive commendations for being fresh and clean and many guests highlight that their rooms were super clean and comfortable.

However, some reviews do indicate inconsistencies. A few guests encountered issues such as stains on sheets, hairs in bathrooms and an occasional bad smell in the rooms. There were mentions of dated decor and old carpets that sometimes contributed to a less pristine feeling, as well as reports of rust in various parts of the bathrooms. Issues with housekeeping were noted with some guests feeling that their rooms were not serviced adequately during their stay.

Overall, while the majority of the feedback celebrates the inn's cleanliness and well-maintained facilities, there are areas highlighted for improvement to ensure a consistently flawless experience.

Staff
The staff at Humphreys Half Moon Inn generally receive high praise from guests, highlighting their friendliness and helpfulness. Descriptions such as wonderful, accommodating and attentive frequently appear in reviews, portraying a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Guests often commend the front desk and reception staff for their efficiency and courteous demeanor. The service is noted to be especially good with staff members being both prompt and hospitable.

Many reviews emphasize the amazing and super friendly nature of the staff, often mentioning their responsiveness and willingness to accommodate various requests. Guests appreciated specific staff members who went above and beyond, contributing to their pleasant stay.

However, there are occasional remarks about less positive experiences with some guests describing the service as poor or noting that certain staff members were unfriendly, unhelpful or in need of more training. Despite these less frequent criticisms, the overall sentiment regarding the staff at Humphreys Half Moon Inn leans significantly positive, creating a generally delightful experience for most visitors.

Wi-Fi
Humphreys Half Moon Inn offers complimentary wifi, which many guests appreciated as a bonus. Several guests found the internet to be fast with no issues in connecting. However, opinions varied with some encountering inconsistent service and poor signals, particularly in specific rooms. While some enjoyed a strong and reliable connection, others experienced bad wifi and were dissatisfied with the performance. Additionally, a few guests mentioned that they had to pay extra for the internet. Overall, while many had a positive experience with the wifi, it seems there can be variability in service quality.

Gym
The gym at Humphreys Half Moon Inn has elicited mixed feedback from guests. Positively, some guests referred to it as a nice gym, noting it includes cardio machines, a weight bench and a Cybex. However, the fitness center is very small and lacks free weights. There have been comments about some machines not working and a need for equipment improvement. Additionally, the gym space is described as a small, ventless room, which may affect the workout experience for some. At times, the fitness facility was even reported as closed, which could be inconvenient for guests looking to maintain their fitness routines.

Pool
Humphreys Half Moon Inn consistently impresses guests with its inviting pool and associated amenities. The pool area receives high praise for its cleanliness, ample size and enjoyable temperature, contributing to a relaxing experience. Guests appreciate the heated pool, which extends use into the evening, along with the convenient pool bar and generous opening hours until 11 pm, allowing for extended relaxation.

The pool's atmosphere stands out with beautiful landscaping, including tropical gardens, koi ponds and occasional parrot sightings, creating a resort-like feel. The presence of tiki torches and fire pits around the pool adds to the ambiance, offering a pleasant space even after sunset. The jacuzzi and hot tub are also popular features, both for their warmth and their accessibility.

One notable aspect is the close proximity of the pool to other amenities, making it easy for guests to move between different areas. However, a few reviews mention the desire for more poolside seating and enhanced poolside service for food and drinks to elevate the experience further.

Despite these minor suggestions, the overwhelmingly positive feedback reflects a much-loved pool environment described as fantastic, enjoyable and well-maintained. Overall, the pool area at Humphreys Half Moon Inn provides a delightful and relaxing retreat that enhances the overall stay for the guests.

Parking
Humphreys Half Moon Inn receives mixed feedback regarding its parking situation. Guests appreciate the convenience and ease of the parking area once they figure it out. Many find the parking to be satisfactory and even describe it as great and good. However, there are notable concerns about the fees associated with parking. The standard fee is around $20-$25 daily, which some guests find to be high and an additional burden. This is particularly an issue for those who believe parking should be included in the room rate, noting that such fees are uncommon in other places they've stayed.

There are specific complaints about the need for more ADA parking and overall issues with tight and small parking spaces. Some guests also mention the inconvenience caused by barriers blocking access, limited availability during busy times like concerts and the parking lot not being close to rooms. Additionally, the parking experience can be confusing and potentially annoying, especially with the extra charge perceived by some as unnecessary for hotel guests. Despite these criticisms, others still view the paid parking as worth it due to the overall amenities provided by the hotel.

Family
Humphreys Half Moon Inn stands out as an exceptional destination for families seeking a fun and relaxing getaway. The spacious rooms, some reminiscent of a summer camp, offer plenty of room for kids to run and play. Families will appreciate the child-friendly pool, the availability of children’s TV channels and the inviting fire pit area that’s perfect for family gatherings. The hotel’s layout is well-suited for families, featuring plenty of grass areas where kids can wander safely and a playground and small beach nearby add to the charm.

With ADA accommodation available, it ensures comfort for all guests. The hotel’s ideal location near family-friendly attractions and its relaxed atmosphere make it perfect for a short getaway or an extended vacation. Guests have enjoyed memorable family moments, from anniversary celebrations to birthday parties by the pool. While some noted occasional issues with noise from other families, the overall experience is very positive.

The facility also offers options for families on a budget, including comfortable family suites with big balconies overlooking the marina. Kids will find joy in the koi pond and the family of ducks, adding a touch of nature to the stay. In short, Humphreys Half Moon Inn provides an idyllic setting for a fantastic family vacation, combining comfort, entertainment and a welcoming atmosphere for all.

3 Star
Humphreys Half Moon Inn is widely regarded as a reasonable choice for a three-star hotel. Guests frequently note that the facility provides good value for money with some even describing it as very good value. The hotel's services align well with its three-star rating, offering a comfortable and moderate experience.

Pricing is considered reasonable by many visitors; however, some have expressed concerns about additional fees such as resort and parking fees being poorly explained. Although the room quality is deemed average for the price and the hotel is seen as outdated with dated decor and old carpets, the overall consensus is that it meets the expectations for its rating.

While not a luxury destination, Humphreys Half Moon Inn serves as a pleasant resort hotel. Despite needing some refurbishment and facelifts to modernize its appearance, it remains a decent and approved option for travelers seeking a three-star accommodation.

Business
Humphreys Half Moon Inn offers a comprehensive array of facilities and amenities that cater particularly well to business travelers. The hotel boasts good conference rooms and an easily accessible business center, making it ideal for hosting meetings and corporate events. Guests will find appropriate business amenities and a designated business area to fulfill their work needs, including convenient work desks. Furthermore, its location near key business districts and good connectivity make it a great choice for business trips.

Guests highlight the exceptional ambiance and the value for money that the hotel provides. Moreover, it's often highly recommended for business purposes with many noting that it's perfect for conferences and a generally great venue for business.

While the hotel offers many positive features, some guests have noted areas for improvement. The conference room could use some updates, the dining area might benefit from a refresh and there have been mentions of high meal prices and thin sound walls. Additionally, the beds being too high and a need for better cleaning in certain areas like closets were pointed out. Despite these minor drawbacks, the overall feedback suggests that Humphreys Half Moon Inn is a reliable and well-equipped choice for business travelers.

Outdoor Pool
Humphreys Half Moon Inn boasts an outdoor pool area that guests frequently describe with enthusiasm. The beautifully designed space offers comfortable seating options and tropical, gorgeous scenery, creating a relaxing ambiance perfect for vacationers. The pool itself is consistently clean, large and warmly heated, providing a refreshing experience. Guests love the additional features like a pool bar, hot tub and inviting fire pits that add thoughtful touches to their stay. The pool remains open until 11 pm, allowing for extended hours of enjoyment under palm trees and near the beach. Patrons often highlight the excellent temperature and clear water of the pool, as well as the convenience of its location. Despite occasional concert noise, the overall sentiment about the pool area is overwhelmingly positive, making it a key highlight of the hotel.

Honeymoon
Humphreys Half Moon Inn emerges as an idyllic haven for honeymooners, earning a reputation as a favorite destination for couples. The property is frequently highlighted for its romantic and tranquil ambiance, making it an ideal spot for honeymoon trips, anniversary celebrations and romantic getaways. Many guests have celebrated significant milestones here, from their wedding night to 24th and 15th wedding anniversaries, often commenting on the beautiful, tropical surroundings that lend a calming and intimate feel to the entire experience. The hotel's proximity to local honeymoon attractions further enhances its appeal. Couples consistently find joy in the romantic setting, remarking on it as a great choice for that special trip. The overwhelming consensus points to a beautifully serene and romantic atmosphere, perfect for those looking to celebrate their love.


Yes, Humphreys Half Moon Inn has pool(s) that belong to one or more of the following categories: Outdoor Pool.

No, a spa isn't available at Humphreys Half Moon Inn.

No, Humphreys Half Moon Inn doesn't allow dogs.

Yes, parking facilities are available at Humphreys Half Moon Inn.

Yes, Humphreys Half Moon Inn has a gym.

Location Show Map
More Options
  • Hotel in San Diego

  • 8.9 Excellent

  • From $271

  • Hotel in San Diego

  • 8.8 Excellent

  • From $170

  • Hotel in San Diego

  • 8.1 Very Good

  • From $260

  • Hotel in San Diego

  • 8.5 Very Good

  • From $206



6,746,021

Hotels

60

Categories

49,805

Regions

209,065

Cities


×
×
Checkin
× Home About Press Categories Blog Hotel Awards Travelmyth GPT Contact Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Cookies Policy FAQ