5-Star Hotels in East Rutherford NJ

The Wallace Hotel 5.9 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

9.3

Excellent

$

5-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryThe Wallace Hotel is widely praised for its commendable five-star service, earning accolades for being one of the finest and nicest hotels in New York. Guests frequently remark on the exceptionally friendly and helpful staff with special mention of Joseph at reception, who contributed significantly to their experience. The atmosphere and overall luxurious feel of the hotel are consistent with what one would expect from a five-star establishment and the cleanliness is noted as impeccable.

Despite these positive aspects, some visitors feel the level of facilities did not entirely meet five-star expectations, such as the presence of paper cups which seemed out of place in a luxury setting. While the reception area and some inconsistencies were noted as unusual for a five-star hotel, the impeccable service, robust gym and excellent Wi-Fi are comparable to top-tier standards. Overall, the hotel offers a premium experience, but with a few aspects that could be improved to completely align with the five-star rating.
Show more

Equinox Hotel New York 6.2 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

9.1

Excellent

From $888

$

5-Star Hotel

Located in Hudson Yards, the Equinox Hotel offers a unique focus on wellness and fitness. It features luxurious rooms, a state-of-the-art fitness center, and healthy dining options, catering to health-conscious travelers.

Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryThe Equinox Hotel Hudson Yards in New York City has received high praise from its guests with many describing their experience as exceptional and one of the best they've ever had. The hotel boasts a modern 5-star city experience, filled with good energy and stylish decor. The location is perfect for those wanting to explore the city. Despite a few critiques such as no sun chairs available on the deck and no own restaurant, guests still highly recommend the hotel and emphasize their unforgettable, amazing and superb stays. Overall, the Equinox Hotel Hudson Yards is definitely worth considering for a luxurious city-break in New York.
Show more

Mandarin Oriental, New York 6.3 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

9.1

Excellent

From $1,066

$

5-Star Hotel

The Mandarin Oriental boasts breathtaking views of Central Park and the Manhattan skyline. Its luxurious rooms, exceptional spa, and world-class dining options provide a sophisticated and serene experience for discerning guests.

Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryIf you're looking for pure luxury and an oasis in the heart of New York City, look no further than the Mandarin Oriental, New York. The view, rooms and 5-star service are all exceptional and just amazing. It's no wonder guests describe their stay as magical and phenomenal! Plus, the location is great - especially if you're running the NYC Marathon. Everything from the facilities to the services provided are top-notch, making this hotel one of the very best in the city. Don't let the few negative reviews deter you - the Mandarin Oriental, New York is an exceptional property and the perfect choice for a stay in NYC.
Show more

Trump International New York 6.4 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.8

Excellent

From $768

$

5-Star Hotel

Trump International boasts a privileged location in the heart of New York and it offers an array of 5-star amenities to its guests, including a 2 Michelin star restaurant, elegant and spacious accommodation in rooms and suites, a health club with a pool with lap lanes, as well as various facilities for families, business travelers and honeymooners alike.

Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryTrump International New York is a breathtakingly beautiful hotel that made our stay nothing less than exceptional. The staff were incredibly welcoming, providing a service fit for 5 stars. The hotel facilities and location were both stunning with a metro station and supermarket conveniently located nearby. We had a fabulous 4-night stay, feeling every bit like we'd earned our rightfully deserved 5-star luxury. The hotel offers perfect in every way amenities, fitting for a grand family vacation or romantic getaway. The only slight let-down was the high price tag, understandably setting high standards that some guests felt weren't quite met. However, these minor issues didn't detract from the overall grandeur of the hotel. All in all, it was a once-in-a-lifetime experience that we loved and would do again in a heartbeat.
Show more

Pendry Manhattan West 6.4 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.9

Excellent

$

Info Categories

5-Star Hotel

Hotel with Parking

Hotel with Gym

Kimpton Theta New York - Times Square by IHG 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.1

Very Good

From $261

$

Info Categories

5-Star Hotel

Dog Friendly Hotel

Hotel with Free Wi-Fi

The Westin New York at Times Square 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.0

Very Good

From $332

$

5-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryThe Westin New York at Times Square enjoys praise for its prime location, described as one of the best in Times Square. However, when it comes to the hotel's star rating, guest opinions diverge. Many suggest it falls short of a 5-star standard, indicating more of a 3 to 4-star experience. There are mentions of a lack of amenities and some guests stating it did not feel like a 5-star hotel. Despite these mixed reviews on luxury and facilities, the unbeatable location remains a consistent highlight among visitors.
Show more

Faena New York 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

9.0

Excellent

$

Info Categories

5-Star Hotel

Hotel with Parking

EV charging stations

Hotel near Golf Courses

Two Bedroom Luxury Hotel 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

1.0

Rated

$

Info Categories

5-Star Hotel

Luxury Hotel

Small Hotel

WestHouse Hotel New York 6.6 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

7.9

Good

From $381

$

5-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryWestHouse Hotel New York appears to fall short of the five-star expectations set by its rating. Many guests pointed out that the hotel does not meet the standards and quality typically associated with a five-star establishment. Criticisms were particularly aimed at the rooms and overall service, which were frequently described as not up to par for a hotel with a five-star designation.

While some reviews did mention excellent location and five-star service, these positives were overshadowed by issues of cleanliness, service inconsistency and the lack of amenities expected at this level. Guests noted that the hotel could be more accurately described as a four-star establishment with several reviewers emphasizing that it does not deserve its five-star label.

Additionally, some guests highlighted the disparity between the hotel's online presentation and the actual experience, indicating that the pictures found online were overrated. Issues such as overcharging for late arrivals despite prior notice and below-par breakfast offerings also contributed to the sentiment that the hotel lacked true five-star qualities.

Overall, while WestHouse Hotel New York does have some commendable aspects, many guests feel disappointed with the discrepancy between its advertised high standards and the actual experience, suggesting that it’s more of a four-star hotel.
Show more

JW Marriott Essex House New York 6.6 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

7.9

Good

From $643

$

Info Categories

5-Star Hotel

Historic Hotel

Hotel with Spa

Park Hyatt New York 6.6 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.9

Excellent

From $919

$

5-Star Hotel

Park Hyatt New York offers contemporary luxury and sophisticated design in Midtown. Its spacious rooms, exceptional spa, and prime location near Central Park and Fifth Avenue make it a top choice for discerning travelers.

The Luxury Collection Hotel Manhattan Midtown 6.6 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.0

Very Good

From $558

$

5-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryThe Luxury Collection Hotel Manhattan Midtown has garnered enthusiastic praise from its guests for its exceptional quality and luxurious accommodations. Visitors have been particularly impressed by the spacious rooms, elegant furnishings, and the sense of opulence that enhances their stay. The hotel staff are frequently lauded for their friendliness and promptness, contributing to a level of service that many describe as worthy of a five-star rating. Numerous guests express satisfaction with their decision to stay at the hotel, noting that their experience surpasses their expectations. Despite some comments suggesting a mid-tier service experience, the overall consensus remains highly positive, with the hotel being considered one of the best options in New York City for those seeking a luxurious retreat.
Show more

New York Marriott Marquis 6.6 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.3

Very Good

From $444

$

5-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryThe New York Marriott Marquis is an exceptional five-star hotel with superb facilities and services. The location is excellent and the hotel has been nicely renovated with friendly staff that make for a wonderful experience. Rooms are clean and spacious with fantastic amenities that are sure to please guests. Although some guests had minor complaints, overall the hotel is highly recommended and guests loved every second of their stay. The hotel is located in a fantastic location, making it a convenient base for exploring the city. Many guests would stay there again and highly recommend the hotel to others. Despite some minor issues, the hotel is definitely worth visiting – a superb choice for anyone looking for a luxurious stay in the heart of the city.
Show more

The Times Square EDITION New York 6.6 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.6

Very Good

From $371

$

5-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryThe Times Square EDITION New York offers a modern, minimalist aesthetic with beautiful and clean rooms that provide a five-star standard in terms of design and comfort. Guests can expect a very good stay, feeling assured of safety throughout their visit. However, the service falls short of the five-star experience expected with numerous mentions of poor service from the staff. While the hotel excels in room quality and its overall design, the facilities and service levels do not consistently match up to the expectations of a five-star hotel.
Show more

Le Meridien New York, Central Park 6.7 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

7.0

Good

From $371

$

5-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryLe Meridien New York, Central Park, presents a mixed bag of experiences for its guests. The hotel's standout feature is undoubtedly its prime location, just a block from Central Park and conveniently close to a subway station, making it ideal for shopping and exploring the city. Guests appreciate the nice rooms and the restaurant, which receives praise for its excellent food and impeccable five-star service.

However, the hotel falls short of delivering a consistent five-star experience. Several guests mention that the service and facilities need improvement, suggesting that it does not meet the expected standards of even a four-star hotel. While the staff and overall service receive high marks for excellence, the absence of amenities like a pool and the sense of the hotel requiring a facelift contribute to a perception that it does not live up to its advertised star rating.
Show more

Thompson Central Park New York, by Hyatt 6.7 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.1

Very Good

$

Info

Just few blocks away from Central Park, MOMA, Carnegie Hall, Broadway theaters and Fifth Avenue’s famous shops, this hotel is the perfect place if you want to experience everything New York has to offer. All rooms are over 300 sq.ft, whereas the suites offer a variety of options to suit your needs, such as separate living room with queen-size sofa bed, dining area and kitchenettes.

Categories

5-Star Hotel

Luxury Hotel

Family Friendly Hotel

1 Hotel Central Park 6.7 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.2

Very Good

From $481

$

5-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category1 Hotel Central Park offers a distinctive blend of eco-friendly luxury and exceptional service, creating a memorable stay in the heart of New York City. The spacious and calming rooms serve as a tranquil oasis amidst the city's bustle, providing guests with a feeling of relaxation and comfort. Many visitors describe their time here as one of the best stays they've had in New York, with everything about the hotel delivering an exceptional experience. Guests commend the property for its excellent service, noting the staff's attention to detail and unbeatable treatment. The on-site restaurant and bar, coupled with the hotel's commitment to sustainability, further enhance the overall experience, making it a worthwhile choice for visitors seeking both luxury and environmental consciousness. Despite some contrasting opinions regarding its five-star status, numerous guests vow to return, indicating that a stay here is certainly worth considering.
Show more

The Knickerbocker 6.7 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.4

Very Good

From $364

$

5-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryThe Knickerbocker Hotel in New York City presents a mixed experience for its guests. While some visitors praised their stay as amazing, befitting of a five-star experience, and highly recommend the hotel, others found it lacking in certain areas. Cleanliness, safety, and the hotel's location have been highlighted positively, contributing to a satisfactory experience for some. A select few guests found their stay at The Knickerbocker to exceed typical luxury standards, with some even claiming it was more than five stars and a good value proposition without the excess expense often associated with high-end accommodation.

However, several reviews indicate that the hotel's overall service and atmosphere do not consistently deliver the luxury expected of a five-star establishment. The absence of a welcoming lobby and insufficiently attentive staff were among the criticisms, suggesting a lack of five-star hospitality. Expectations for opulence, including luxuriously furnished rooms and amenities like a fully stocked minibar and coffee machines, were not entirely met for some guests. The noise levels, stark hallways, and basic room setups were also mentioned, casting doubt on the hotel's five-star status. Despite these points, the hotel remains a choice for those looking for a central location and a relatively comfortable stay, with some patrons expressing a desire to return in the future.
Show more

The Ritz-Carlton New York, Central Park 6.7 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

7.9

Good

From $866

$

5-Star Hotel

Overlooking Central Park, this hotel offers luxurious accommodations and unparalleled service. Its prime location provides easy access to the park's attractions, and the hotel itself is synonymous with elegance and sophistication.