Judge's Lodging
➔
➔
Please select your travel dates to see rates and availability
Info
Summary of reviewsJudge's Lodging, nestled in the historic heart of York, is widely praised for its exceptional location, making it an ideal choice for visitors eager to explore the city's attractions on foot. With its Georgian architecture lending charm and tranquility, the hotel provides a comfortable sanctuary despite its central position. Proximity to key attractions and easy access from the train station further enhance its appeal.
The breakfast experience is a standout feature, with guests frequently commending the diverse options and the quality of freshly cooked dishes. The full English breakfast receives high marks for its flavor, while the friendly and prompt breakfast service adds to the morning's enjoyment. Similarly, the dining experience is celebrated, with consistently excellent food across various options and a lively dining atmosphere supported by great service and competitive pricing.
Guests appreciate the rooms for their spaciousness and unique décor, blending historic elegance with modern comfort. This blends well with the hotel's cleanliness standards, praised for spotlessly clean rooms and well-maintained accommodations. Despite minor issues such as room sizes and noise, the hotel's character and central location compensate considerably.
A major accolade goes to the dedicated staff, described as friendly, attentive, and helpful, contributing to the hotel's welcoming atmosphere. While wifi service presents mixed experiences, the majority of guests find their stay enjoyable, aided by comfortable beds known for their plush and cozy quality.
While some guests feel Judge's Lodging may not fully align with five-star expectations, the charming boutique-style ambiance and reasonable pricing make it a recommendable option for many. The hotel's rich historical allure, combined with modern conveniences and an accessible environment, ensures a memorable stay, with guests often eager to return.
Categories
The breakfast experience is a standout feature, with guests frequently commending the diverse options and the quality of freshly cooked dishes. The full English breakfast receives high marks for its flavor, while the friendly and prompt breakfast service adds to the morning's enjoyment. Similarly, the dining experience is celebrated, with consistently excellent food across various options and a lively dining atmosphere supported by great service and competitive pricing.
Guests appreciate the rooms for their spaciousness and unique décor, blending historic elegance with modern comfort. This blends well with the hotel's cleanliness standards, praised for spotlessly clean rooms and well-maintained accommodations. Despite minor issues such as room sizes and noise, the hotel's character and central location compensate considerably.
A major accolade goes to the dedicated staff, described as friendly, attentive, and helpful, contributing to the hotel's welcoming atmosphere. While wifi service presents mixed experiences, the majority of guests find their stay enjoyable, aided by comfortable beds known for their plush and cozy quality.
While some guests feel Judge's Lodging may not fully align with five-star expectations, the charming boutique-style ambiance and reasonable pricing make it a recommendable option for many. The hotel's rich historical allure, combined with modern conveniences and an accessible environment, ensures a memorable stay, with guests often eager to return.
Boutique-style Hotel
This hotel is known for its excellent location and historical charm. The individually decorated rooms and the hotel's restaurant provide a unique and personalized experience, making it a memorable stay.
Luxury Hotel
This elegant Grade I listed Georgian townhouse overlooks York Minster and offers a luxurious stay. It features stylish rooms, two bars, and an à la carte restaurant serving international specialities. The rooms are equipped with modern amenities while retaining the building's historic charm.
Hotel for Honeymoon
This city-center hotel offers a unique and historic setting with beautifully decorated rooms. Its charming atmosphere and central location make it a romantic choice for a honeymoon.
Romantic Hotel
Located in the city center, this hotel offers a unique and charming experience. Its elegant rooms and central location make it perfect for exploring York. The hotel exudes character and sophistication.
Hotel near Nightlife Spots
Located in the City Centre on Lendal, Judge's Lodging is within easy reach of several bars and pubs. Lendal offers a mix of traditional and modern venues, providing a variety of options for a night out. Near Nola Restaurant with live Jazz.
5-Star Hotel
Judge's Lodging offers a historic and luxurious experience with its elegant rooms, charming atmosphere, and central York location. Its blend of history and modern amenities makes it a unique and memorable choice.
Family Friendly Hotel
Business Hotel
Accessible Hotel
Guest Reviews
Nestled in the historic heart of York, Judge's Lodging has garnered acclaim for its exceptional location, making it a prime choice for visitors keen to explore the city on foot. Within a short stroll from the York Minster, Shambles, and other key attractions, this hotel offers guests the perfect launching pad for their adventures. The building's Georgian architecture adds to the charm, reflecting the rich history and character of York itself. Despite its central position amidst the bustling city, the hotel retains an oasis-like tranquility, providing a comfortable sanctuary for its guests. Proximity to the train station ensures easy access for travelers, while a myriad of coffee shops, bars, and restaurants lie just a few steps away. From its welcoming ambience to its commendable staff, Judge's Lodging stands out not only for its unbeatable location but also for its dedication to providing a delightful stay in one of England’s most enchanting cities.
The breakfast experience at Judge's Lodging has received overwhelming praise from guests, positioning it as a standout feature of their stay. Guests repeatedly describe the breakfast as excellent, fabulous, and amazing, with a wide variety of choices available to suit diverse tastes, including vegetarian options. The full English breakfast is highlighted frequently, often described as perfectly cooked and one of the best guests have had in a long time. The breakfast menu offers generous portions, and the freshly cooked dishes to order are particularly appreciated for their quality and flavor.
While there are some concerns regarding the buffet quality, the option to order from the menu receives favorable comments, with guests advised to opt for this for a better experience. The atmosphere in the restaurant itself is also positively noted, with lovely settings such as the conservatory in the courtyard enhancing the dining experience. Service during breakfast is often mentioned with admiration, as staff are noted for their friendliness and prompt service, contributing to a welcoming and pleasant start to the day.
Overall, Judge's Lodging seems to provide a breakfast experience that not only satisfies but exceeds many guests' expectations, offering ample choice, excellent quality, and a delightful dining atmosphere.
Judge's Lodging offers a culinary experience that delights its guests with consistently excellent food across various dining options. Whether enjoying a cosy dinner in the Cellar Bar or dining in the upper dining room, guests frequently praise the delicious meals, particularly highlighting the superb quality of dishes such as fish and chips. Breakfasts also receive high marks for their taste and quality.
Many guests mention the freshness of ingredients and commend the hotel's ability to serve up high-quality meals, sometimes better than pricier alternatives nearby. The restaurant is popular, with guests frequently commenting on its lively atmosphere and great service from friendly staff. Those dining in the hotel often find meals competitively priced, adding to the value of the overall dining experience.
While there are occasional mentions of limited menus or minor service hiccups, the overall impression remains positive, with dishes frequently described as amazing, delicious, and even exceptional. The restaurant continues to attract diners with its diverse and well-executed offerings, making Judge's Lodging a noteworthy destination for satisfying culinary cravings.
Nestled in a historic Georgian house, Judge's Lodging offers a unique blend of character and modern comfort. Many guests appreciate the spacious and beautifully decorated rooms, often highlighting their luxury and uniqueness. The rooms are well-equipped, boasting amenities such as comfortable beds, modern bathrooms, and refreshing decor. Many reviewers found the rooms to be very clean and cozy, often noting the stylish and tasteful furnishings.
The property's location is excellent, with some rooms offering charming views, such as the York Minster. The mix of old-world charm and contemporary touches appeals strongly to those who stay there. The staff receives positive mentions for their friendliness and helpfulness, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere. Guests also enjoy the lovely little details, such as fresh milk in the mornings and quality tea in rooms.
Despite the largely positive feedback, there are mentions of small room sizes, especially for those expecting more space, as well as occasional noise issues. Some guests also experienced temperature control difficulties. However, the central location and the building's character seem to largely compensate for these minor inconveniences.
Overall, Judge's Lodging excels in providing a comfortable stay with a historic flair, making it an appealing choice for those looking to explore York while enjoying a cozy retreat with a personal touch.
At Judge's Lodging, guests repeatedly praise the comfort of the beds, painting a picture of restful sleep on plush and cozy mattresses. The beds are described as big and roomy, providing ample space to stretch out and unwind. Many guests highlight the luxurious quality of the bed and pillows, contributing to an all-around comfortable experience. The rooms themselves complement the bedding with a clean, tidy, and welcoming atmosphere, featuring nice showers and excellent quality ingredients, indicating attention to detail in the overall accommodation.
However, there are occasional remarks about the beds' comfort levels, with some finding them either too soft or too hard, suggesting a variance in mattress firmness that might not suit every preference. Although a few reviews note discomfort, the dominant sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, celebrating the beds for their outstanding comfort, which enables guests to sleep soundly and enjoy their stay fully. Overall, Judge's Lodging seems to offer a mostly relaxing and comfortable retreat, especially appreciated by those valuing a good night's sleep.
The Judge's Lodging is consistently praised for its outstanding cleanliness, with many guests highlighting the spotlessly clean rooms and immaculate bathrooms. Visitors appreciate the well-maintained and stylishly decorated accommodations, often noting that the rooms are spacious and well-equipped, providing everything needed for a comfortable stay. The cleaning staff are frequently commended for their helpfulness, ensuring that rooms are tidy and fully stocked with essentials such as tea, coffee, and sugar.
Guests describe a clean and welcoming atmosphere throughout the establishment, including the inviting pub downstairs and immaculate grounds. The hotel’s cleanliness contributes to the overall comfort, with many reviewers applauding the delightful character of the rooms, enhanced by personal touches and modern amenities. Breakfast at the hotel receives high praise for its cleanliness, variety, and excellent service.
Despite the overwhelmingly positive feedback on cleanliness, some guests mention minor issues, such as cramped bathrooms and occasional dust in certain areas, but these seem to be exceptions rather than the norm. Overall, Judge's Lodging is characterized as a clean, comfortable, well-maintained hotel situated in a prime and accessible location, offering superb service and an inviting atmosphere.
Judge's Lodging has garnered plenty of praise for its impressive staff, frequently highlighted in guest reviews for their exceptional service. Visitors repeatedly mention the friendliness and welcoming nature of the employees, who contribute significantly to the overall experience of the hotel. Many reviewers describe the staff as attentive, polite, and consistently helpful, ensuring that guests feel accommodated throughout their stay.
The helpfulness of the reception team is especially noted, with guests appreciating their efficiency in handling check-ins and check-outs. The staff's willingness to assist with luggage and provide directions or insights into the local area further underline their commitment to guest satisfaction.
The positive reviews extend across all departments, including the breakfast team and bar staff, who are often commended for their proactive approach and customer service. Guests find the staff to be professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely eager to assist, creating a comfortable and inviting atmosphere. Despite one review mentioning rude behavior from the bar staff, the overwhelming consensus is that the majority of the team are pleasant and courteous.
Overall, the staff at Judge's Lodging contribute greatly to the hotel's warm and welcoming environment, with many guests expressing gratitude for their hard work and dedication. This dedication to service ensures guests have a memorable experience, leaving many eager to return for another stay.
The Judge's Lodging provides internet access as part of its amenities, and the experiences seem to vary among guests. While some visitors reported well-functioning wireless, others found the connectivity disappointing, noting slow speeds and occasional drops in signal. Despite this inconsistency, there were no major issues consistently highlighted, suggesting that the wifi service might suffice for basic browsing needs but could be improved for those seeking a more robust connection. Overall, the wifi experience appears to be a mixed bag, meeting expectations for some while leaving others wanting more.
The Judge's Lodging in York seems to offer a charming and historical atmosphere, perfect for families looking for a comfortable stay. The hotel is ideally situated within a short walking distance to York's key attractions, making it a convenient choice for those traveling with children. Reviews highlight the accommodating and helpful staff, suggesting a welcoming environment for families and children. Guests appreciated the spacious rooms and thoughtful gestures, such as surprise upgrades for special occasions, which enhance the overall experience. The breakfast selection receives positive remarks, contributing to the excellent family-friendly setting. With repeated recommendations from guests to friends and family, it's clear that Judge's Lodging provides a memorable stay for families visiting York.
Judge's Lodging in York presents itself as a five-star establishment but has received mixed reviews regarding its alignment with that prestigious classification. Guests generally appreciate the hotel’s great location, acknowledging its convenience despite some noise at night. However, there are several points of contention: many visitors feel the hotel falls short of five-star expectations, with some pointing out it seems more like a three-star experience. Concerns include the lack of a proper fridge in the rooms, inconsistent hygiene standards, and room images not matching those advertised online.
Despite these criticisms, numerous guests still express satisfaction and recommend the hotel to others, highlighting exceptional and wonderful experiences and valuing it as an excellent option for staying in York. While the property is old and there are challenges such as the absence of a lift or concierge service, the overall impression remains positive for many who have stayed. Although the luxury may be lacking for those expecting top-tier standards, the reasonable pricing compared to other five-star hotels and the charming experience outweigh the shortcomings for many guests. Ultimately, for its price range, Judge's Lodging is a place that guests have frequently recommended and shown willingness to return to.
Judge's Lodging offers a blend of historical charm and modern convenience, situated in an ideal location for exploring nearby attractions like the Minster Tower and Clifford's Tower. Guests appreciate well-designed rooms that cater to those with mobility issues, ensuring a comfortable stay on a single level. While the building does lack a lift, the staff makes a commendable effort to accommodate guests with impaired mobility by providing suitable rooms, minimizing the need for stairs. However, not all rooms are equipped with air conditioning, which may be worth considering when booking. Despite the absence of a lift, the hotel offers an inviting environment for those looking for accessible accommodations.
Nestled within a Grade 1 listed building, Judge's Lodging boasts a delightful blend of character, charm, and history. This boutique-style hotel captivates guests with its beautifully designed rooms, which are not only spacious and impeccably clean but also exude a unique quirkiness that is both high-quality and comfortable. The building's historic roots add to its allure, offering an atmosphere full of character and a great ambience that guests find captivating. The hotel's excellent location provides easy access to numerous points of interest, making it an ideal lodging choice for those who wish to explore the surrounding area while enjoying the hotel's rich heritage. Complementing the charming rooms is a great bar area, enhancing the overall guest experience with a spot to unwind in the midst of such a fabulous setting. Judge's Lodging stands as a testament to a perfect blend of history and modern boutique style, ensuring a memorable stay for its visitors.
Judge's Lodging offers a luxurious experience marked by its well-appointed amenities and attention to detail reminiscent of a 5-star hotel. Guests relish the beautifully decorated rooms, which boast an elegant blend of historical architecture and themed interior design, providing a charming atmosphere that oozes quality and class. The locality and ambiance of the hotel, complemented by its excellent service from happy staff, contribute to a comfortable and clean environment. Guests enjoy delightful extras such as a coffee machine in the room and luxurious toiletries in the bathrooms.
The high-level facilities include rooms with ensuite whirlpool baths and rainfall showers, enhancing the luxury experience. Despite a few claims about pricing versus value, many guests appreciate the upmarket feel without it being excessively posh. An upgraded room option adds extra allure, perfect for those seeking a touch of indulgence. The property stands out with its unique and individual furnishings, leaving a lasting impression of charm and luxury. While some rooms could benefit from additional cooling in warmer months, overall, the superb location and amazing breakfast further contribute to the overall advantageous experience at Judge's Lodging.
Judge's Lodging seems to be an ideal destination for romantics seeking a charming and intimate atmosphere. Many guests have celebrated special occasions such as weddings and milestone birthdays, finding the experience deeply fulfilling and memorable. Couples consistently praise the special touches that accompany their stay, such as celebratory prosecco and handwritten cards that add a delightful personal touch, making anniversaries and birthdays feel exceptionally special.
The hotel's winter tipee exudes coziness, offering a snug spot to unwind and watch the world go by—perfect for romantic evenings. The on-site bar and dining options enhance the experience, providing great food and drinks that complement the serene and intimate setting. Guests find the venue perfectly suited for romantic dinners and cozy nights out, with staff who go out of their way to ensure these special moments are as cherished as the relationships being celebrated.
Furthermore, thoughtful gestures like upgrading accommodations or providing fresh milk for tea only add to the appeal, making every stay at Judge's Lodging an intimate adventure for two. It's no wonder this hotel is seen as a perfect venue for a romantic getaway amidst heartfelt celebrations.
Location Show Map
Location
Breakfast
While there are some concerns regarding the buffet quality, the option to order from the menu receives favorable comments, with guests advised to opt for this for a better experience. The atmosphere in the restaurant itself is also positively noted, with lovely settings such as the conservatory in the courtyard enhancing the dining experience. Service during breakfast is often mentioned with admiration, as staff are noted for their friendliness and prompt service, contributing to a welcoming and pleasant start to the day.
Overall, Judge's Lodging seems to provide a breakfast experience that not only satisfies but exceeds many guests' expectations, offering ample choice, excellent quality, and a delightful dining atmosphere.
Dinner
Many guests mention the freshness of ingredients and commend the hotel's ability to serve up high-quality meals, sometimes better than pricier alternatives nearby. The restaurant is popular, with guests frequently commenting on its lively atmosphere and great service from friendly staff. Those dining in the hotel often find meals competitively priced, adding to the value of the overall dining experience.
While there are occasional mentions of limited menus or minor service hiccups, the overall impression remains positive, with dishes frequently described as amazing, delicious, and even exceptional. The restaurant continues to attract diners with its diverse and well-executed offerings, making Judge's Lodging a noteworthy destination for satisfying culinary cravings.
Rooms
The property's location is excellent, with some rooms offering charming views, such as the York Minster. The mix of old-world charm and contemporary touches appeals strongly to those who stay there. The staff receives positive mentions for their friendliness and helpfulness, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere. Guests also enjoy the lovely little details, such as fresh milk in the mornings and quality tea in rooms.
Despite the largely positive feedback, there are mentions of small room sizes, especially for those expecting more space, as well as occasional noise issues. Some guests also experienced temperature control difficulties. However, the central location and the building's character seem to largely compensate for these minor inconveniences.
Overall, Judge's Lodging excels in providing a comfortable stay with a historic flair, making it an appealing choice for those looking to explore York while enjoying a cozy retreat with a personal touch.
Beds
However, there are occasional remarks about the beds' comfort levels, with some finding them either too soft or too hard, suggesting a variance in mattress firmness that might not suit every preference. Although a few reviews note discomfort, the dominant sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, celebrating the beds for their outstanding comfort, which enables guests to sleep soundly and enjoy their stay fully. Overall, Judge's Lodging seems to offer a mostly relaxing and comfortable retreat, especially appreciated by those valuing a good night's sleep.
Cleanliness
Guests describe a clean and welcoming atmosphere throughout the establishment, including the inviting pub downstairs and immaculate grounds. The hotel’s cleanliness contributes to the overall comfort, with many reviewers applauding the delightful character of the rooms, enhanced by personal touches and modern amenities. Breakfast at the hotel receives high praise for its cleanliness, variety, and excellent service.
Despite the overwhelmingly positive feedback on cleanliness, some guests mention minor issues, such as cramped bathrooms and occasional dust in certain areas, but these seem to be exceptions rather than the norm. Overall, Judge's Lodging is characterized as a clean, comfortable, well-maintained hotel situated in a prime and accessible location, offering superb service and an inviting atmosphere.
Staff
The helpfulness of the reception team is especially noted, with guests appreciating their efficiency in handling check-ins and check-outs. The staff's willingness to assist with luggage and provide directions or insights into the local area further underline their commitment to guest satisfaction.
The positive reviews extend across all departments, including the breakfast team and bar staff, who are often commended for their proactive approach and customer service. Guests find the staff to be professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely eager to assist, creating a comfortable and inviting atmosphere. Despite one review mentioning rude behavior from the bar staff, the overwhelming consensus is that the majority of the team are pleasant and courteous.
Overall, the staff at Judge's Lodging contribute greatly to the hotel's warm and welcoming environment, with many guests expressing gratitude for their hard work and dedication. This dedication to service ensures guests have a memorable experience, leaving many eager to return for another stay.
Wi-Fi
Family
5 Star
Despite these criticisms, numerous guests still express satisfaction and recommend the hotel to others, highlighting exceptional and wonderful experiences and valuing it as an excellent option for staying in York. While the property is old and there are challenges such as the absence of a lift or concierge service, the overall impression remains positive for many who have stayed. Although the luxury may be lacking for those expecting top-tier standards, the reasonable pricing compared to other five-star hotels and the charming experience outweigh the shortcomings for many guests. Ultimately, for its price range, Judge's Lodging is a place that guests have frequently recommended and shown willingness to return to.
Accessible
Boutique-Style
Luxury
The high-level facilities include rooms with ensuite whirlpool baths and rainfall showers, enhancing the luxury experience. Despite a few claims about pricing versus value, many guests appreciate the upmarket feel without it being excessively posh. An upgraded room option adds extra allure, perfect for those seeking a touch of indulgence. The property stands out with its unique and individual furnishings, leaving a lasting impression of charm and luxury. While some rooms could benefit from additional cooling in warmer months, overall, the superb location and amazing breakfast further contribute to the overall advantageous experience at Judge's Lodging.
Romantic
The hotel's winter tipee exudes coziness, offering a snug spot to unwind and watch the world go by—perfect for romantic evenings. The on-site bar and dining options enhance the experience, providing great food and drinks that complement the serene and intimate setting. Guests find the venue perfectly suited for romantic dinners and cozy nights out, with staff who go out of their way to ensure these special moments are as cherished as the relationships being celebrated.
Furthermore, thoughtful gestures like upgrading accommodations or providing fresh milk for tea only add to the appeal, making every stay at Judge's Lodging an intimate adventure for two. It's no wonder this hotel is seen as a perfect venue for a romantic getaway amidst heartfelt celebrations.
No, Judge's Lodging doesn't have any pool.
No, a spa isn't available at Judge's Lodging.
No, Judge's Lodging doesn't allow dogs.
No, parking facilities aren't available at Judge's Lodging.
No, Judge's Lodging doesn't have a gym.
Location Show Map
More Options
