Blue Creek Inn

Waretown 39.80111100, -74.19947000 , 535 Route 9 (Show on Map)
7.8
Good


Please select your travel dates to see rates and availability
Check In
Check Out
1 room2 guests 1 room, 2 guests
Info
Summary of reviewsBlue Creek Inn receives widespread praise for its excellent location and exceptional service, making it a favored choice for visitors seeking a serene retreat. Its strategic positioning near the harbor, restaurants, shops, and Garden State Parkway ensures convenience and accessibility, while guests appreciate the quiet atmosphere away from busier Long Beach Island beaches. The staff, often commended for their friendliness and accommodating nature, add significantly to the overall experience, enhancing the inn's welcoming environment.

Despite the lack of a formal breakfast service, guests enjoy complimentary coffee and snacks in the morning, complemented by nearby dining options that include a local diner and bakery, as well as chain options like Dunkin Donuts. The rooms at Blue Creek Inn are consistently described as clean, cozy, and modern, featuring updated furnishings and amenities like fridges and microwaves. While minor issues such as room size and mild odors are noted, these do not detract from the overall positive impressions. The inn's commitment to cleanliness and upkeep is evident, with guests appreciating well-maintained areas and recently updated bathrooms.

The pool is highlighted as a standout feature, offering a picturesque and private setting with crystal-clear water and comfortable lounge chairs. The saltwater element enhances the swimming experience, and nearby amenities cater to family needs. While the beds receive mixed reviews, with many praising the memory foam mattresses and quality linens, some guests find them too firm, along with occasional discomfort with pillows.

Overall, Blue Creek Inn is celebrated for its clean accommodations, tranquil atmosphere, and dedicated staff, creating a delightful stay for travelers. Returning guests affirm its reputation as a reliable and pleasant choice for a peaceful and affordable visit to the area.
Show more
Categories
Small Hotel
The Blue Creek Inn provides a comfortable and relaxing stay with its well-maintained rooms. Its quiet location and personalized service make it a charming and intimate option.

Hotel for Honeymoon

Hotel with Swimming Pool

  Outdoor Pool  


Hotel with Outdoor Pool

Room Types
Queen Room - Non-Smoking The triple room features air conditioning, a tea and coffee maker, a balcony with pool views as well as a private bathroom boasting a bath. The unit has 1 bed.

Queen Room with Two Queen Beds - Non-Smoking The family room features air conditioning, a tea and coffee maker, as well as a private bathroom boasting a bath and a shower. The unit has 2 beds.

Deluxe Queen Suite - Non-Smoking The air-conditioned suite features 1 bedroom and 1 bathroom with a bath and a shower. A seating area, a desk, a balcony and a tea and coffee maker are featured in this suite. The unit offers 2 beds.

Guest Reviews
7.8
Good
Location
Blue Creek Inn boasts a truly excellent location, drawing praise for being perfectly situated for various needs. Guests consistently highlight its convenience, with the inn being close to the harbor, restaurants, shops, and the Garden State Parkway. Its proximity to both Barnegat and Long Beach Island (LBI) offers a serene retreat away from the busier LBI beaches, ensuring a peaceful and quiet stay. The staff contribute positively to the experience, often described as helpful and accommodating. Although it is situated behind a shopping center and lacks scenic views, the location is considered both practical and ideal for visitors' plans. Cleanliness, an outdoor pool, and the general tranquility of the area add to the appeal, making Blue Creek Inn a solid choice for those visiting the region.

Breakfast
At Blue Creek Inn, guests seeking a traditional hotel breakfast might be disappointed, as there is no formal breakfast service provided. However, guests can enjoy complimentary coffee and snacks in the morning, which many appreciate as a nice touch. The hotel compensates for the lack of a full breakfast by offering a cozy breakfast area where guests can enjoy these offerings. Additionally, the helpful staff point guests towards local breakfast options, including a nearby diner that receives positive mentions and a fantastic bakery just down the road. For those preferring well-known chains, Dunkin Donuts is also conveniently located nearby. Overall, while breakfast isn't served on-site, guests do have a variety of nearby alternatives to start their day.

Rooms
Blue Creek Inn consistently impresses guests with its well-maintained rooms, combining a clean, cozy, and comfortable atmosphere that leaves a lasting impression. Visitors frequently praise the spotless and modernized accommodations, highlighting features such as comfy beds, updated furnishings, and the inclusion of modern amenities like fridges, microwaves, and TVs. The inn ensures quiet surroundings, perfect for a restful night’s sleep. Balconies or small outdoor seating areas in some rooms add a touch of charm to the stay.

While some mention rooms as slightly small and occasional mild odors, these minor issues are largely overshadowed by the overall positive experience. The bathrooms have been recently updated, and the staff is noted for their courteousness and efficiency. The inn is strategically located, providing convenient access for those looking to explore the area. Overall, the Blue Creek Inn proves to be a reliable choice for visitors seeking a clean, comfortable, and modern place to rest.

Beds
Blue Creek Inn offers a mixed experience when it comes to their beds. Many guests have praised the comfort of the beds, often describing them as comfortable, with some even likening the firm memory foam mattresses to a high-end tempurpedic. This firmness seems to be appreciated by those who prefer a solid sleeping surface, especially individuals with specific back needs. The quality linens and clean beds further enhance the positive sleeping experience. However, not all guests share the same comfort level, with some finding the beds a bit too firm for their liking. A few visitors also mentioned issues with the pillows, describing them as flat or uncomfortable. Overall, while the beds at Blue Creek Inn seem to meet the preferences of many, there are some variances in the individual guests' comfort levels.

Cleanliness
Nestled conveniently in proximity to Long Beach Island and local eateries, Blue Creek Inn shines as a beacon of cleanliness and comfort. The hotel consistently boasts spotless accommodations, impressing guests with its commitment to cleanliness and upkeep. Visitors often highlight the inn's immaculate rooms, which are not only clean but also well-decorated and recently updated. The property's quiet ambiance and well-maintained grounds offer an additional layer of tranquility, making it an ideal retreat.

Staff members are frequently mentioned for their friendly demeanor and willingness to go above and beyond for visitors, adding to the overall pleasant atmosphere. The hotel offers much more than just a clean space; it promises an enjoyable stay with helpful service and attention to detail.

Although some bathrooms may be on the smaller side and the property shows signs of aging, these minor drawbacks do not overshadow the overwhelmingly positive experience. Blue Creek Inn is a delightful, clean accommodation choice, particularly for travelers seeking a quiet and affordable stay. The regular praise from returning guests underscores the inn's reputation as a true gem for a pleasant and restful stay.

Staff
The reviews for Blue Creek Inn highlight an overwhelmingly positive experience with the hotel's staff. Guests consistently describe the staff as exceptionally friendly, helpful, and accommodating. The front desk team, including standout individuals like Scott, Tina, and Geraldine, receive frequent praise for their professionalism and willingness to go above and beyond to meet guest needs, such as facilitating early check-ins and assisting with luggage. The staff is noted for their kindness, compassion, and amiable nature, ensuring that guests feel welcomed and well cared for during their stay. The team’s efforts extend across the entire facility, from housekeeping to management, all contributing to a clean and hospitable environment. The service is characterized by politeness and a genuine desire to enhance the guest experience, establishing Blue Creek Inn as a place where visitors feel supported and valued.

Pool
The Blue Creek Inn offers an inviting and picturesque swimming pool experience that guests frequently praise. The outdoor pool stands out for its size, cleanliness, and the crystal-clear water that perfectly complements the well-manicured landscaping, creating a peaceful and private atmosphere. Guests admire the comfortable lounge chairs and the convenience of provided towels, making relaxation by the poolside effortless. The saltwater element is highlighted as an enjoyable feature, providing a more pleasant swimming experience. Although some visitors encountered issues with pool access during their stay, the overall opinion remains positive, with the pool being a standout feature of the property. The pool area is also noted for having nearby amenities like a seating area and playground, which are ideal for families traveling with children. Certain rooms offer convenient access directly to the pool, enhancing the appeal for those keen on enjoying poolside leisure.


Yes, Blue Creek Inn has pool(s) that belong to one or more of the following categories: Outdoor Pool.

No, a spa isn't available at Blue Creek Inn.

No, Blue Creek Inn doesn't allow dogs.

No, parking facilities aren't available at Blue Creek Inn.

No, Blue Creek Inn doesn't have a gym.

Location Show Map
More Options
  • Hotel in Manchester Township

  • 7.4 Good

  • From $134

  • Inn in Bay Head

  • 8.6 Very Good

  • From $133

  • Hotel in Toms River

  • 5.6 Rated

  • From $103

  • Motel in Seaside Heights

  • 7.9 Good

  • From $100



6,893,169

Hotels

60

Categories

49,805

Regions

209,065

Cities


×
×
Checkin
× Home About Press Categories Blog Hotel Awards Travelmyth GPT Contact Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Cookies Policy FAQ