Open Hearth Lodge
➔
➔
Please select your travel dates to see rates and availability
Info
Summary of reviewsOpen Hearth Lodge in Sister Bay, Door County, is highly praised for its outstanding location and peaceful atmosphere. Its proximity to popular destinations like Sister Bay, Ephraim, and Fish Creek, combined with a serene setting away from bustling crowds, makes it a preferred choice for exploring the peninsula. The lodge’s charming outdoor amenities, such as fire pits and a fenced-in dog area, enhance the cozy and inviting environment, complemented by friendly and accommodating staff.
Guests appreciate the complimentary breakfast for its variety and quality, including fresh pastries, homemade donuts, and locally sourced produce. The breakfast setting, highlighted by a glass pavilion and inviting fireplace, adds to the delightful morning experience. The rooms are celebrated for their cleanliness and spaciousness, offering modern amenities like electric fireplaces and jacuzzi tubs, which contribute to a homely retreat. Families find the accommodations especially inviting, with dog-friendly rooms and kitchen facilities that cater to all members, including pets.
Immaculate cleanliness across the lodge is a standout feature, with the property described as one of the cleanest experiences by many visitors. Attention to detail in room amenities, such as soft towels and toiletries, enhances the welcoming atmosphere. The staff receives consistent praise for their warm, helpful, and accommodating service, exemplifying hospitality at its finest. The gym, pool, and hot tub facilities are also well-maintained, providing guests with opportunities for exercise and relaxation.
The lodge's family-friendly atmosphere is enriched by numerous activities and thoughtful touches, creating an ideal setting for a memorable getaway. The beds receive positive feedback for their comfort and quality, although occasional remarks about firmness suggest personal preference may vary. Overall, Open Hearth Lodge offers a cozy, welcoming atmosphere, perfect for leisure travelers, with strong recommendations for local attractions and dining options enhancing the visitor experience.
For dog owners, Open Hearth Lodge is a premier destination, offering exceptional pet-friendly amenities and services. The fenced-in dog play area and dedicated pet-friendly rooms ensure a comfortable stay for both pets and their owners. Staff attentiveness further enhances the experience, making Open Hearth Lodge an ideal choice for those seeking a welcoming and well-equipped accommodation option in Door County.
Categories
Guests appreciate the complimentary breakfast for its variety and quality, including fresh pastries, homemade donuts, and locally sourced produce. The breakfast setting, highlighted by a glass pavilion and inviting fireplace, adds to the delightful morning experience. The rooms are celebrated for their cleanliness and spaciousness, offering modern amenities like electric fireplaces and jacuzzi tubs, which contribute to a homely retreat. Families find the accommodations especially inviting, with dog-friendly rooms and kitchen facilities that cater to all members, including pets.
Immaculate cleanliness across the lodge is a standout feature, with the property described as one of the cleanest experiences by many visitors. Attention to detail in room amenities, such as soft towels and toiletries, enhances the welcoming atmosphere. The staff receives consistent praise for their warm, helpful, and accommodating service, exemplifying hospitality at its finest. The gym, pool, and hot tub facilities are also well-maintained, providing guests with opportunities for exercise and relaxation.
The lodge's family-friendly atmosphere is enriched by numerous activities and thoughtful touches, creating an ideal setting for a memorable getaway. The beds receive positive feedback for their comfort and quality, although occasional remarks about firmness suggest personal preference may vary. Overall, Open Hearth Lodge offers a cozy, welcoming atmosphere, perfect for leisure travelers, with strong recommendations for local attractions and dining options enhancing the visitor experience.
For dog owners, Open Hearth Lodge is a premier destination, offering exceptional pet-friendly amenities and services. The fenced-in dog play area and dedicated pet-friendly rooms ensure a comfortable stay for both pets and their owners. Staff attentiveness further enhances the experience, making Open Hearth Lodge an ideal choice for those seeking a welcoming and well-equipped accommodation option in Door County.
Hotel near Golf Courses
This lodge is located in Sister Bay and offers proximity to golf courses in the area, providing a base for golf enthusiasts.
Family Friendly Hotel
The lodge offers a cozy and welcoming environment. It is suitable for families looking for a relaxed vacation setting.
Dog Friendly Hotel
This lodge offers dedicated dog-friendly rooms with amenities designed for comfort and durability for dogs. It features a large yard, nearby walking trails, and waste stations for easy cleanup. There is a $15/night charge for each pet. It is considered the best all-around pet-friendly hotel in Door County.
Hotel with Parking
Open Hearth Lodge is known to offer free parking. Guests appreciate the cleanliness, complimentary breakfast, and hot tub, making parking a stress-free part of the stay.
Hotel with Gym
This lodge features a large and well-equipped gym that caters to every aspect of your fitness needs. It offers an assortment of high-quality cardio machines, weights, balls, foam blocks and rollers, and more. TVs are available for entertainment and an Infrared Sauna assists in recovery after an intense workout.
Hotel with Indoor Pool
This hotel features a refreshing indoor pool, providing a comfortable swimming option for guests.
Hotel with Heated Pool
Open Hearth Lodge in Door County provides a heated indoor pool available year-round, with large windows and an adjacent jacuzzi hot tub, perfect for family swimming and relaxation.
Hotel for Honeymoon
Hotel with Swimming Pool
Heated Pool Indoor Pool
Business Hotel
Accessible Hotel
Guest Reviews
Open Hearth Lodge in Sister Bay, Door County, is praised for its exceptional location, making it an ideal base for exploring the entire peninsula. Nestled within picturesque and serene surroundings, it provides easy access to various shops, restaurants, and attractions. Guests appreciate its proximity to popular destinations like Sister Bay, Ephraim, Fish Creek, Egg Harbor, and Bailey's Harbor, while still enjoying a peaceful atmosphere away from the main tourist activity. The property itself offers a cozy and inviting setting, enhanced by beautiful outdoor spaces, including fire pits and a fenced-in dog area. The lodge is conveniently located for travelers aiming to visit nearby state parks, a drive-in movie theater, and local shops and eateries. Guests often highlight the friendly and accommodating staff, quiet environment, and charming outdoor amenities, making it a favored choice for those looking to explore Door County’s offerings without staying in the midst of bustling crowds.
Open Hearth Lodge offers a complimentary breakfast that generally garners positive feedback for its variety and inclusivity. Guests appreciated the assortment of offerings, which often included options such as fresh pastries, homemade donuts, pancakes from a convenient machine, and a selection of fruits. Many reviews commend the use of real plates and cutlery, enhancing the breakfast experience beyond typical hotel standards. The breakfast is described as diverse, with many choices available, served in a cozy, bright, and pleasant setting. There were mentions of the delightful ambiance, particularly highlighting the breakfast area with its glass pavilion and inviting fireplace.
While the breakfast received praise for its variety and quality, some guests noted a potential for improvement in the availability of healthier options and additional protein choices. Despite a few suggestions for menu enhancements to break the monotony, the offerings were generally well-received as ample and satisfying. The inclusion of locally sourced produce and high-quality coffee was noted as a highlight by visitors. Overall, the breakfast at Open Hearth Lodge is recognized as a convenient and enjoyable start to the day, with most guests finding it to be one of the pleasant aspects of their stay.
Open Hearth Lodge boasts an inviting and comfortable atmosphere, perfect for both families and solo travelers seeking a peaceful retreat. Guests consistently praise the spaciousness and cleanliness of the rooms, noting that they are among the cleanest they've ever stayed in. The rooms offer cozy decor and modern amenities, including electric fireplaces, full kitchens, and jacuzzi tubs, which enhance the overall homey experience.
The lodge caters well to families, with features such as large suites and rooms equipped with kitchen facilities, which prove particularly useful for those traveling with young children. Dog-friendly rooms are also available, ensuring that all members of the family, including pets, are well accommodated. Comfortable beds provide a restful night's sleep, with many guests highlighting the fine quality mattresses and effective room-darkening shades that contribute to a relaxing stay.
The property itself is beautifully maintained, with a scenic landscape adding to its charm. Guests appreciate the friendly and helpful staff who contribute to the welcoming environment, making visitors feel right at home. Despite some reviews mentioning minor maintenance issues such as bathroom doors not closing fully, the lodge quickly addresses any concerns, demonstrating a commitment to guest satisfaction. Overall, Open Hearth Lodge is celebrated for its clean, spacious, and well-equipped rooms, offering a pleasant stay in a picturesque setting.
Open Hearth Lodge seems to have garnered quite a positive reception for the quality of its beds. Guests repeatedly describe the beds as very comfortable, often highlighting the ample supply of pillows that contribute to a restful night. Many have noted that the bedding is attractive and that Verlo mattresses add a particular touch of luxury to the sleep experience. The rooms also feature king beds, which have been appreciated for their spaciousness and comfort.
However, a couple of guests have remarked on beds being too firm or stiff, indicating that personal preference for mattress firmness may vary. Despite these outliers, the prevailing sentiment is that the beds at Open Hearth Lodge are generally comfortable, inviting guests to settle in for a good night's rest. The positive remarks about the beds are a strong testament to the Lodge's commitment to providing a cozy and pleasant room experience.
Nestled in a charming harbor town, Open Hearth Lodge delights visitors with its exceptional cleanliness and well-kept facilities. Guests repeatedly praise the hotel for its immaculate condition, from spotless rooms to inviting common areas. Many find the establishment to be one of the cleanest they have ever experienced, describing the environment as both modern and cozy. The property is not only beautifully maintained but also offers clean, well-furnished rooms that provide a home-like comfort. Visitors particularly appreciate the attention to detail, noting how room amenities, including soft towels and great toiletries, contribute to a welcoming stay.
Beyond individual rooms, the entire facility—from the swimming pool to the breakfast area—upholds a high standard of cleanliness, earning the praise of those who seek a relaxing yet pristine environment. The accommodating and friendly staff further enhance the experience by ensuring that all areas, including dog-friendly spaces, remain in top condition.
While some minor issues are occasionally mentioned, such as a slow-draining sink, these do not overshadow the overwhelmingly positive reception which highlights a super clean and delightful retreat for travelers.
Open Hearth Lodge is frequently praised for its exceptional staff, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere that makes guests feel right at home. The team at Open Hearth Lodge, including the friendly owner John, are incredibly kind, going above and beyond to ensure all visitor needs are met. The welcoming nature of the staff is a recurrent theme in guest reviews, highlighting their professionalism, helpfulness, and accommodating service. Whether providing insightful suggestions for local dining and attractions or resolving booking errors with a smile, the staff demonstrates a commitment to excellence. The lodge's hosts, including standout figures like Jack and Laney, are celebrated for their genuine care and dedication to making every guest’s stay memorable. This positive environment extends from the front desk to the entire hotel, contributing to a comfortable stay enhanced by thoughtful details and homey touches. The consistently friendly and knowledgeable staff exemplifies hospitality at its finest, leaving a lasting impression on all who visit.
Open Hearth Lodge offers a pleasant gym experience, highlighted by a variety of weights and an infrared sauna that guests appreciated. The fitness center is consistently mentioned as clean and well-maintained, ensuring a positive environment for workouts. Additionally, the presence of a pool and hot tub complements the gym facilities, providing guests with opportunities for both exercise and relaxation. Overall, these amenities contribute to a satisfying stay for those looking to maintain their fitness routine while on vacation.
Open Hearth Lodge boasts a consistently praised pool and hot tub, noted by guests for their cleanliness and inviting atmosphere. Visitors appreciated the well-maintained indoor pool and whirlpool, which are available year-round, providing a warm and pleasant escape even during chilly weather. Many found the addition of fire pits to be an excellent feature, offering cozy spots for evening conversation under the stars. The amenities, including a fitness center and outdoor grilling areas, received favorable mentions, though there were minor issues with the grilling equipment. Overall, the lodge's pool area emerges as a highlight for families and vacationers, making it a fun and enjoyable aspect of their stay.
Open Hearth Lodge in Door County presents an ideal getaway for families, offering a welcoming atmosphere with plenty of activities for kids to enjoy. The family-owned and operated lodge is praised for its friendly and attentive staff who go the extra mile to ensure guests have a memorable stay. The property is equipped with a playground, a swimming pool, and a swing-set, providing ample opportunities for children to play and burn off energy.
Guests appreciate the thoughtful touches throughout the lodge, including areas to sit by fireplaces, a fire pit for evening relaxation, and spacious grounds for families to explore. The presence of a walking trail enhances the experience for those looking to connect with nature. The accommodations are described as clean and comfortable, with rooms featuring kitchens that are especially handy for families with young children.
The lodge offers a wonderful family atmosphere and a range of activities that allow guests to enjoy quality time without needing to leave the property. From the beautifully crafted woodwork accents to the visible pride in ownership, Open Hearth Lodge embodies a sense of community and personal care. Whether visiting with children or as a couple, guests find the setting perfect for a relaxing weekend retreat, echoing sentiments of an amazing experience in a family-friendly environment.
Open Hearth Lodge is ideal for leisure travelers seeking a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. Amidst feedback on business amenities being somewhat limited compared to other hotels, guests have highlighted the property's excellent service and clean surroundings. The owners and staff receive particular praise for their warm hospitality and their willingness to go above and beyond, such as accommodating early check-ins and promptly resolving any issues like connectivity troubles.
The lodge offers a range of amenities that are deemed very reasonable when considering the cost and are perfectly suited for road trips, as evidenced by positive mentions of the enjoyment brought by the new shuttle service in Sister Bay. It's situated in a location where staff can provide helpful recommendations on local attractions and dining options, enriching the experience of vacationers visiting the area.
The indoor pool at Open Hearth Lodge is a highlight, frequently praised by guests for its cleanliness and beauty. It's noted as a fantastic facility, offering a wonderful retreat, especially on cooler days in Door County. Families and individuals alike have thoroughly enjoyed the pool and the adjoining hot tub, which adds an additional layer of relaxation. Available year-round, this indoor recreational area is often seen as a significant benefit, providing a delightful and comforting experience regardless of the season. The presence of cozy indoor features like a fireplace and lounge area further enhances the guest experience, making it a pleasant place to unwind. Overall, the pool's consistent maintenance and inviting atmosphere are greatly appreciated by those who visit.
Open Hearth Lodge stands out as a premier destination for travelers with canine companions, earning praise for its exceptional dog-friendly amenities and services. The lodge is celebrated for its thoughtful consideration of pet needs, offering dog bowls, beds, towels, sheets, blankets, and a selection of dog toys and treats, including tennis balls and milk bones, right in the rooms. Guests appreciate the fenced-in dog play area, which allows pets to roam freely and safely in an off-leash environment. Additionally, the presence of a grooming room provides an extra convenience for those wishing to clean their dogs after outdoor activities such as hiking or swimming.
The dog-friendly rooms are designed with pet comfort in mind, featuring spacious layouts, durable non-carpeted floors, and delightful decor, including electric fireplaces. The new wing of rooms dedicated to pet-friendly accommodations further enhances the experience, ensuring a comfortable stay for both pets and their owners.
The hotel staff receives commendations for their friendly and accommodating service, making sure all guests feel welcome and comfortable. Whether families are looking to enjoy a cozy evening by the warming fire in the lobby or need assistance like borrowing a snow scraper for their car, the service at Open Hearth Lodge impresses with its attention to detail.
Overall, Open Hearth Lodge provides a remarkable pet-friendly atmosphere, making it an ideal choice for dog owners seeking a welcoming and well-equipped accommodation option.
Location Show Map
Location
Breakfast
While the breakfast received praise for its variety and quality, some guests noted a potential for improvement in the availability of healthier options and additional protein choices. Despite a few suggestions for menu enhancements to break the monotony, the offerings were generally well-received as ample and satisfying. The inclusion of locally sourced produce and high-quality coffee was noted as a highlight by visitors. Overall, the breakfast at Open Hearth Lodge is recognized as a convenient and enjoyable start to the day, with most guests finding it to be one of the pleasant aspects of their stay.
Rooms
The lodge caters well to families, with features such as large suites and rooms equipped with kitchen facilities, which prove particularly useful for those traveling with young children. Dog-friendly rooms are also available, ensuring that all members of the family, including pets, are well accommodated. Comfortable beds provide a restful night's sleep, with many guests highlighting the fine quality mattresses and effective room-darkening shades that contribute to a relaxing stay.
The property itself is beautifully maintained, with a scenic landscape adding to its charm. Guests appreciate the friendly and helpful staff who contribute to the welcoming environment, making visitors feel right at home. Despite some reviews mentioning minor maintenance issues such as bathroom doors not closing fully, the lodge quickly addresses any concerns, demonstrating a commitment to guest satisfaction. Overall, Open Hearth Lodge is celebrated for its clean, spacious, and well-equipped rooms, offering a pleasant stay in a picturesque setting.
Beds
However, a couple of guests have remarked on beds being too firm or stiff, indicating that personal preference for mattress firmness may vary. Despite these outliers, the prevailing sentiment is that the beds at Open Hearth Lodge are generally comfortable, inviting guests to settle in for a good night's rest. The positive remarks about the beds are a strong testament to the Lodge's commitment to providing a cozy and pleasant room experience.
Cleanliness
Beyond individual rooms, the entire facility—from the swimming pool to the breakfast area—upholds a high standard of cleanliness, earning the praise of those who seek a relaxing yet pristine environment. The accommodating and friendly staff further enhance the experience by ensuring that all areas, including dog-friendly spaces, remain in top condition.
While some minor issues are occasionally mentioned, such as a slow-draining sink, these do not overshadow the overwhelmingly positive reception which highlights a super clean and delightful retreat for travelers.
Staff
Gym
Pool
Family
Guests appreciate the thoughtful touches throughout the lodge, including areas to sit by fireplaces, a fire pit for evening relaxation, and spacious grounds for families to explore. The presence of a walking trail enhances the experience for those looking to connect with nature. The accommodations are described as clean and comfortable, with rooms featuring kitchens that are especially handy for families with young children.
The lodge offers a wonderful family atmosphere and a range of activities that allow guests to enjoy quality time without needing to leave the property. From the beautifully crafted woodwork accents to the visible pride in ownership, Open Hearth Lodge embodies a sense of community and personal care. Whether visiting with children or as a couple, guests find the setting perfect for a relaxing weekend retreat, echoing sentiments of an amazing experience in a family-friendly environment.
Business
The lodge offers a range of amenities that are deemed very reasonable when considering the cost and are perfectly suited for road trips, as evidenced by positive mentions of the enjoyment brought by the new shuttle service in Sister Bay. It's situated in a location where staff can provide helpful recommendations on local attractions and dining options, enriching the experience of vacationers visiting the area.
Indoor Pool
Dog Friendly
The dog-friendly rooms are designed with pet comfort in mind, featuring spacious layouts, durable non-carpeted floors, and delightful decor, including electric fireplaces. The new wing of rooms dedicated to pet-friendly accommodations further enhances the experience, ensuring a comfortable stay for both pets and their owners.
The hotel staff receives commendations for their friendly and accommodating service, making sure all guests feel welcome and comfortable. Whether families are looking to enjoy a cozy evening by the warming fire in the lobby or need assistance like borrowing a snow scraper for their car, the service at Open Hearth Lodge impresses with its attention to detail.
Overall, Open Hearth Lodge provides a remarkable pet-friendly atmosphere, making it an ideal choice for dog owners seeking a welcoming and well-equipped accommodation option.
Yes, Open Hearth Lodge has pool(s) that belong to one or more of the following categories: Heated Pool, Indoor Pool.
No, a spa isn't available at Open Hearth Lodge.
Yes, Open Hearth Lodge welcomes dogs.
Yes, parking facilities are available at Open Hearth Lodge.
Yes, Open Hearth Lodge has a gym.
Location Show Map
More Options
