The Pridwin Hotel
Hotel in Shelter Island NY
9.0
Excellent
From $359
From $359
Hotel with Swimming Pool
Outdoor Pool  
Show more
Questionnaire
Location of the pool: Outdoor pool
Show more
 
Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island
Bed & Breakfast in Shelter Island NY
9.9
Excellent
From $430
From $430
Info Categories
Bed & Breakfast with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Bed & Breakfast for Yoga

Boutique-style Bed & Breakfast

Show more
 
Shelter Island Retreat with Outdoor Pool!
Vacation Home in Shelter Island NY
10
Excellent
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Vacation Home with Parking

Show more
 
Romantic Shelter Island Cottage with 2 Pools & Pond
Vacation Home in Shelter Island NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Dog Friendly Vacation Home

Vacation Home with Parking

Show more
 
Luxurious Shelter Island Hideaway with Pool!
Vacation Home in Shelter Island NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Vacation Home with Parking

Show more
 
454 more hotels nearby!
Shelter Island House 0.6 km from Shelter Island
Hotel in Shelter Island Heights NY
4.0
Rated
From $225
From $225
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Luxury Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

Show more
 
Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast 2.2 km from Shelter Island
Bed & Breakfast in Greenport NY
8.8
Excellent
From $368
From $368
Info Categories
Bed & Breakfast with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Luxury Bed & Breakfast

Bed & Breakfast with Free Wi-Fi

Show more
 
Greenporter Hotel 2.4 km from Shelter Island
Hotel in Greenport NY
7.9
Good
From $123
From $123
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Parking

EV charging stations  

Hotel near Golf Courses

Show more
 
The Harbor Front Inn 2.4 km from Shelter Island
Hotel in Greenport NY
8.4
Very Good
From $182
From $182
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Hotel for Honeymoon

Family Friendly Hotel

Show more
 
Cozy Greenport Cottage 2.5 km from Shelter Island
Vacation Home in Greenport NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Vacation Home with Parking

Show more
 
Beachside Waterview 2Br Condo w/ Pool in Greenport 2.6 km from Shelter Island
Apartment in Greenport NY
9.0
Excellent
Info Categories
Apartment with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Apartment with Free Wi-Fi

Apartment with Parking

Show more
 
The Cliffside Resort Condominiums 2.6 km from Shelter Island
Apartments in Greenport NY
8.6
Very Good
From $245
From $245
Info Categories
Apartment with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Apartment with Parking

Accessible Apartment

Show more
 
Southold Serenity 2.6 km from Shelter Island
Vacation Home in Southold NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Show more
 
Hotel Moraine 2.7 km from Shelter Island
Hotel in Greenport NY
9.7
Excellent
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Hotel near Golf Courses

Dog Friendly Hotel

Show more
 
4BR NOFO Home in Heart of Wine Country (w/ Pool) 2.9 km from Shelter Island
Vacation Home in Southold NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Vacation Home with Parking

Show more
 
Townsend Manor Inn 2.9 km from Shelter Island
Inn in Greenport NY
7.8
Good
From $162
From $162
Info Categories
Inn with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Show more
 
North Fork Waterfront 2.9 km from Shelter Island
Vacation Home in Southold NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Dog Friendly Vacation Home

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Show more
 
Greenport Getaway 3.1 km from Shelter Island
Vacation Home in Greenport NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Vacation Home with Parking

Show more
 
North Fork Contemporary 3.1 km from Shelter Island
Vacation Home in Greenport NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Vacation Home with Parking

Show more
 
The Jewel of Greenport 3.3 km from Shelter Island
Vacation Home in Greenport NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Vacation Home with Parking

Show more
 
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.
View all hotels in Shelter Island.
Categories:
  •     Pool (459)
  •     Outdoor Pool (401)
  •     Heated Pool (68)
  •     Private Pool (50)
  •     Indoor Pool (28)
  •     Pool Lap Lanes (2)
  •     Children's Pool (1)
  •     Parking (357)
  •     Free Wi-Fi (266)
  •     Dog Friendly (161)
  •     4 Star (90)
  •     Family (69)
  •     3 Star (52)
  •     Beach (45)
  •     Golf (44)
  •     Accessible (39)
  •     Honeymoon (37)
  •     Gym (30)
  •     Small (28)
  •     Luxury (23)
  •     Business (22)
  •     Tennis (18)
  •     Spa (13)
  •     EV charging stations (13)
  •     Sustainability Journey (13)
  •     Beachfront (12)
  •     Yoga (10)
  •     Romantic (8)
  •     Adult Only (5)
  •     5 Star (5)
  •     Rooms with Fireplace (4)
  •     Boutique-Style (4)
  •     Vineyard (3)
  •     Historic (1)
  •     Health & Safety (1)
×
Checkin
×
Categories
1
Map
× Home About Press Categories Blog Hotel Awards Travelmyth GPT Contact Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Cookies Policy FAQ