4-Star Hotels, Vacation Homes, B&Bs, Apartments in Shelter Island NY

The Pridwin Hotel

Hotel in Shelter Island NY

9.0

Excellent

From $262

$

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool

Luxury Hotel

Sunset Beach

Hotel in Shelter Island NY

From $334

$

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Boutique-style Hotel

Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island

Bed & Breakfast in Shelter Island NY

9.9

Excellent

From $373

$

Info Categories

4-Star Bed & Breakfast

Bed & Breakfast for Yoga

Boutique-style Bed & Breakfast

151 more hotels nearby!

Shelter Island House 0.6 km from Shelter Island

Hotel in Shelter Island Heights NY

4.0

Rated

From $225

$

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Luxury Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

House on Chase Creek 1.3 km from Shelter Island

Bed & Breakfast in Shelter Island Heights NY

8.3

Very Good

From $140

$

Info Categories

4-Star Bed & Breakfast

Luxury Bed & Breakfast

Bed & Breakfast with Parking

The Chequit 1.4 km from Shelter Island

Inn in Shelter Island Heights NY

9.0

Excellent

From $427

$

Info Categories

4-Star Inn

Inn with Parking

Small Inn

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows 2.0 km from Shelter Island

Hotel in Greenport NY

9.5

Excellent

$

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Hotel Taking Steps Towards Sustainability

Dog Friendly Hotel

Vineyard Beach House 2.0 km from Shelter Island

Vacation Home in Southold NY

$

Info Categories

4-Star Vacation Home

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Vacation Home with Parking

The Shoals Suites & Slips 2.0 km from Shelter Island

Hotel in Southold NY

9.1

Excellent

$

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

Romantic Hotel

Greenport village cottage w/ 4 bedrooms 2.3 km from Shelter Island

Vacation Home in Greenport NY

$

Info Categories

4-Star Vacation Home

Family Friendly Vacation Home

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

The Menhaden Hotel 2.4 km from Shelter Island

Hotel in Greenport NY

9.3

Excellent

From $371

$

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Hotel near Golf Courses

Hotel Taking Steps Towards Sustainability

Amazing Greenport Village Apartment in CENTER! 2.5 km from Shelter Island

Apartment in Greenport NY

$

Info Categories

4-Star Apartment

Dog Friendly Apartment

Apartment with Free Wi-Fi

Beachside Waterview 2Br Condo w/ Pool in Greenport 2.6 km from Shelter Island

Apartment in Greenport NY

9.0

Excellent

$

Info Categories

4-Star Apartment

Apartment with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool

Apartment with Free Wi-Fi

American Beech Hotel 2.6 km from Shelter Island

Hotel in Greenport NY

8.7

Very Good

From $395

$

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Luxury Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

ZEY HOTEL 2.7 km from Shelter Island

Bed & Breakfast in Greenport NY

8.7

Very Good

$

Info Categories

4-Star Bed & Breakfast

Family Friendly Bed & Breakfast

Bed & Breakfast with Free Wi-Fi

The Stirling House Waterfront Inn Greenport 2.7 km from Shelter Island

Bed & Breakfast in Greenport NY

9.6

Excellent

From $341

$

Info Categories

4-Star Bed & Breakfast

Bed & Breakfast Taking Steps Towards Sustainability

Bed & Breakfast with Parking

Goose Creek Getaway: Modern Home with Beach Access 2.8 km from Shelter Island

Vacation Home in Southold NY

$

Info Categories

4-Star Vacation Home

Vacation Home near Golf Courses

Private Waterfront Home: Dock, Kayaks 2.9 km from Shelter Island

Vacation Home in Southold NY

$

Info Categories

4-Star Vacation Home

Vacation Home near Golf Courses

Greenport Getaway 3.1 km from Shelter Island

Vacation Home in Greenport NY

$

Info Categories

4-Star Vacation Home

Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Sandy Bay Getaway: Close to Beach & Family Friendly 3.1 km from Shelter Island

Vacation Home in Southold NY

$

Info Categories

4-Star Vacation Home

4-Star Hotels in Shelter Island NY