Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In
SmallParkingFree Wi-FiDog FriendlyAdult OnlyPool3 StarOutdoor PoolFamilyHoneymoon4 StarAccessibleLuxuryTennisVineyardRooms with Jacuzzi / Hot-TubGymBeachHeated PoolHistoricGolf5 StarRooms with FireplaceEV charging stationsSustainability JourneyCheapRomanticBusinessSpaBoutique-StyleBeachfrontYoga
  1. World
  2. >North America
  3. >United States
  4. >New York
  5. >Suffolk
  6. >Middle Island

Small Hotels in Middle Island

55 HOTELS IN AND AROUND MIDDLE ISLANDRanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
20 hotels nearby!
Aj & TJ BnB main photo
Aj & TJ BnB
4.3 km from Middle Island
Bed & Breakfast in Sound Beach NYUS flag
9.8
Excellent
$
Info
Categories
Small
Dog Friendly
Parking
Cozy unit main photo
Cozy unit
5.5 km from Middle Island
Guest House in Centereach NYUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Small
112 Motel main photo
112 Motel
5.9 km from Middle Island
Hotel in Medford NYUS flag
7.5
Good
From $140
$
Info
Categories
Small
Parking
Rooms with Jacuzzi / Hot-Tub
The Fox and Owl Inn main photo
The Fox and Owl Inn
6.1 km from Middle Island
Bed & Breakfast in Port Jefferson NYUS flag
8.9
Excellent
From $178
$
Info
Categories
Small
Sustainability Journey
Parking
JD COZYNEST LLC main photo
JD COZYNEST LLC
6.2 km from Middle Island
Guest House in Shirley NYUS flag
9.1
Excellent
$
Info
Categories
Small
Honeymoon
Parking
67 Lake House main photo
67 Lake House
8.7 km from Middle Island
Hostel in Brookhaven NYUS flag
8.3
Very Good
$
Info
Categories
Small
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
Three Village Inn main photo
Three Village Inn
9.7 km from Middle Island
Inn in Stony Brook NYUS flag
7.6
Good
From $181
$
Info
Categories
Small
Free Wi-Fi
Historic
Brushwood House by Smith Point Beach main photo
Brushwood House by Smith Point Beach
10.3 km from Middle Island
Country House in Shirley NYUS flag
7.3
Good
From $4,501
$
Info
Categories
Small
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Parking
The SkyBreeze Inn main photo
The SkyBreeze Inn
10.4 km from Middle Island
Hotel in Bohemia NYUS flag
5.9
Rated
$
Info
Categories
Small
Family
Smithpoint motel main photo
Smithpoint motel
10.7 km from Middle Island
Motel in Shirley NYUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Small
Dog Friendly
Free Wi-Fi
Come As You Are Inn LLC main photo
Come As You Are Inn LLC
12.0 km from Middle Island
Bed & Breakfast in Sayville NYUS flag
9.5
Excellent
$
Info
Categories
Small
Adult Only
Parking
A Victorian on the Bay Bed and Breakfast main photo
A Victorian on the Bay Bed and Breakfast
13.6 km from Middle Island
Bed & Breakfast in Eastport NYUS flag
9.3
Excellent
From $209
$
Info
Categories
Small
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Free Wi-Fi
The Madison Fire Island Pines main photo
The Madison Fire Island Pines
16.3 km from Middle Island
Guest House in Fire Island Pines NYUS flag
9.3
Excellent
$
Info
Categories
Small
Adult Only
Honeymoon
Westhampton Seabreeze Motel main photo
Westhampton Seabreeze Motel
16.4 km from Middle Island
Motel in Westhampton NYUS flag
8.0
Very Good
From $233
$
Info
Categories
Small
Parking
Three Ducks main photo
Three Ducks
16.4 km from Middle Island
Hotel in Westhampton NYUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Small
Family
Free Wi-Fi
Commack Inn main photo
Commack Inn
17.2 km from Middle Island
Hotel in Commack NYUS flag
5.7
Rated
$
Info
Categories
Small
4 Star
Seven Beach Lane main photo
Seven Beach Lane
18.0 km from Middle Island
Hotel in Westhampton Beach NYUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Small
Dog Friendly
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Hampton Getaway main photo
Hampton Getaway
18.2 km from Middle Island
Bed & Breakfast in Westhampton Beach NYUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Small
Pool
Free Wi-Fi
A sweet suite main photo
A sweet suite
18.2 km from Middle Island
Guest House in Westhampton Beach NYUS flag
8.0
Very Good
$
Info
Categories
Small
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Free Wi-Fi
The Surfcomber Unit 3 main photo
The Surfcomber Unit 3
18.7 km from Middle Island
Motel in Ocean Bay Park NYUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Small
Dog Friendly
Accessible
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-20 out of 55 hotels in and around Middle Island
Save more on the App
View all hotels in Middle Island
Categories
1
Map
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities