Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In

Small Hotels in Islamorada

36 HOTELS IN AND AROUND ISLAMORADARanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
Casa Morada main photo
Casa Morada
Resort in Islamorada FLUS flag
9.2
Excellent
From $304
$
+12
Info
Summary of reviews
Summarized by AI
Casa Morada is a perfect hotel for a getaway with exceptional staff who are friendly, nice and lovely. Guests have only positive things to say about the staff, who are always willing to make guests feel at home and offer their help promptly. Terri and Sarah are standout members of the team, but all staff members are exceptional. Checking in and checking out is effortless due to the helpful and attentive receptionists. From reception until departure, guests can expect an amazing experience with every person they meet. The staff at Casa Morada deserves special commendation for their exceptional service.
Categories
Small
Dog Friendly
Dog Play Area
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Drop Anchor Resort and Marina main photo
Drop Anchor Resort and Marina
Resort in Islamorada FLUS flag
8.0
Very Good
From $135
$
+8
Info
Categories
Small
Honeymoon
Family
Drop Anchor Resort & Marina main photo
Drop Anchor Resort & Marina
Resort in Islamorada FLUS flag
8.1
Very Good
From $135
$
+9
Info
Summary of reviews
Summarized by AI
Drop Anchor Resort & Marina is highly praised for its breathtaking seaside location, offering stunning ocean views and a tranquil atmosphere. Guests appreciate its proximity to water-based activities like snorkeling and nearby attractions, as well as its closeness to excellent dining options. The well-maintained grounds, quaint beach area, and inviting pool contribute to the serene setting, creating a quintessential Keys experience perfect for relaxation and leisure.

Many visitors commend the resort for its range of spacious and clean room options, often highlighting the cleanliness as a standout feature. While some rooms offer large kitchens and a cozy ambiance, there is variability in room conditions, with some guests noting outdated appearances and uncomfortable furnishings. Not all rooms have waterfront views, and issues like mold and inconsistent hot water have been pointed out, suggesting room for improvement to match expectations and promotional images.

The resort consistently impresses guests with its commitment to cleanliness and comfort, maintaining well-maintained accommodations and a welcoming atmosphere. The staff is frequently noted for their friendliness and efficiency, providing excellent service and making check-ins seamless. Although a few management practices received minor criticism, overall, the staff's attentiveness and hospitality contribute greatly to the resort's positive reputation.

The delightful swimming pool is a standout feature, offering warmth and relaxation alongside stunning sunset views. Complemented by loungers and hammocks, the pool area provides a charming setting that adds to guests' satisfaction. The availability of kayaks enhances the appeal, enabling guests to explore the waterfront.

Regarding comfort, the beds at
Drop Anchor Resort & Marina present a mixed experience, with some guests enjoying restful sleep while others find certain mattresses and sofa beds uncomfortable. This suggests variability in sleeping arrangements, indicating potential improvements in some rooms to enhance guest comfort.

Overall,
Drop Anchor Resort & Marina delivers a beautiful and inviting getaway, with picturesque surroundings, attentive staff, and various amenities that guests appreciate, despite occasional areas for enhancement.
Categories
Small
Pool
Heated Pool
Outdoor Pool
Tennis
The Ocean View Inn main photo
The Ocean View Inn
Hotel in Islamorada FLUS flag
8.3
Very Good
$
+6
Info
Summary of reviews
Summarized by AI
The Ocean View Inn, located in the heart of Isla Morada, is a favored destination for travelers exploring the Florida Keys due to its convenient proximity to local attractions and the added bonus of a private dock for boaters. The hotel's atmosphere is elevated by friendly and professional staff, with particular praise for the manager, Cindy, and the bartenders, all of whom contribute to the welcoming and enjoyable environment.

Guests consistently laud the inn for its comfortable and well-appointed rooms, highlighting their cleanliness, spaciousness, and island-inspired decor. Many rooms offer private patios that connect to the inviting pool and bar area, providing a seamless blend of relaxation and local charm. The overall ambiance is one that promotes tranquility, making it an excellent choice for both short and extended stays.

The Inn's standout feature is its beautifully maintained pool, which guests often describe as a refreshing oasis. The pool area is thoughtfully equipped with lounge chairs, tables, and umbrellas, providing a perfect setting for relaxation. An outdoor shower adds convenience for beachgoers. Families especially appreciate the charming pool setting and the friendly service that enhances their stay.

While the cleanliness of the bar area could see improvement, the Inn consistently receives high marks for overall room cleanliness and maintenance.
The Ocean View Inn continues to be a popular choice for its inviting accommodations and warm hospitality, offering a delightful blend of natural beauty and attentive service to ensure a memorable visit.
Categories
Small
Beach
Pool
Heated Pool
Outdoor Pool
The Caribbean Resort main photo
The Caribbean Resort
Resort in Islamorada FLUS flag
0.0
From $272
$
+8
Info
Categories
Small
Beach
Family
Ragged Edge Resort & Marina main photo
Ragged Edge Resort & Marina
Resort in Islamorada FLUS flag
9.2
Excellent
From $191
$
+4
Info
Categories
Small
Pool
Heated Pool
Outdoor Pool
Parking
Sands of Islamorada main photo
Sands of Islamorada
Inn in Islamorada FLUS flag
8.5
Very Good
From $119
$
+4
Info
Summary of reviews
Summarized by AI
Sands of Islamorada enjoys a premier location in the Florida Keys, making it an ideal destination for travelers seeking relaxation and adventure. Nestled along the oceanfront, it offers breathtaking views and easy access to local attractions, enhancing the overall experience with a serene and tranquil ambiance. Guests appreciate the property's proximity to restaurants, shopping venues, and other attractions, which are ideal for leisurely exploration or culinary adventures. The swimming pool with vibrant oceanfront seating and gorgeously lit pool area further adds to the appeal, providing a modern and refreshing setting.

The accommodations at
Sands of Islamorada are often praised for their cleanliness and comfort, with many rooms featuring stunning ocean views. Newly remodeled spaces offer stylish and functional designs, complete with exceptionally comfortable beds. While some inconsistency in bed quality and pillow comfort has been noted, the rooms generally provide a peaceful retreat, embodying a combination of convenience and serene lodging.

The hotel's commitment to cleanliness is evident across the entire property, from well-kept rooms to meticulously maintained grounds, offering a picturesque setting perfect for relaxation. Guests also appreciate the inclusion of amenities like a functional kitchen, enhancing the practicality and convenience of their stay.

The warmth and attentiveness of the hotel staff consistently contribute to a welcoming atmosphere. Despite occasional challenges, the staff's commitment to guest satisfaction is prominent, ensuring a hospitable environment with courteous service.

In summary,
Sands of Islamorada is a favored choice for travelers due to its prime location, comfortable accommodations, and attentive service, creating a balanced and enjoyable experience for those visiting the Florida Keys.
Categories
Small
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Parking
La Jolla Resort main photo
La Jolla Resort
Inn in Islamorada FLUS flag
8.8
Excellent
From $154
$
+1
Info
Summary of reviews
Summarized by AI
La Jolla Resort in Islamorada is praised highly by guests for its remarkable location, serene atmosphere and captivating waterfront views. Directly by the sea, the resort offers breathtaking sunsets and a charming landscape, making it an ideal destination for relaxation. The close proximity to various dining spots, bars and local attractions such as a rum distillery, adds to the convenience, ensuring guests have access to everything they need.

The resort's spacious, clean and recently renovated rooms come equipped with comfortable beds, kitchenettes and other modern amenities. Guests particularly appreciate the stunning ocean views provided by the water-view rooms and benefit from the extra space and well-furnished kitchens present in some suites. The cleanliness and maintenance of the rooms are often highlighted, contributing to a fresh and welcoming environment.

The staff at
La Jolla Resort consistently receive accolades for their exceptional friendliness and helpfulness. Their proactive approach, from check-in to departure, leaves a positive impression, making guests feel valued and well cared for. Noteworthy mentions of staff members like Shona and Brittany emphasize their dedication to providing outstanding service.

While the Wi-Fi connectivity presents some inconsistencies, the comprehensive room amenities manage to compensate for this shortcoming effectively. The resort also features a well-kept, albeit small, outdoor pool surrounded by lush grounds filled with palm trees and tropical plants. The pool, though not large, is adequate for children and offers a pleasant place to cool off.

La Jolla Resort's private beach is a standout feature, offering guests a peaceful and authentic beachfront experience. The area is well-maintained and equipped with barbecues, hammocks, paddleboards and kayaks, adding to the overall relaxing environment. Minor issues like seaweed and gravel instead of sand do not outweigh the majority of positive feedback regarding the beach's tranquility and charm.

Parking at
La Jolla Resort is generally convenient and secure with ample complimentary spaces, although some guests experience occasional tightness or the need to park across the lot. Free parking enhances the value of the stay, particularly for those with boats or personal watercraft.

Overall,
La Jolla Resort is highly recommended for its unbeatable location, excellent customer service, clean and comfortable accommodations and beautiful, well-maintained grounds, offering guests a relaxing and picturesque retreat in the heart of Islamorada.
Categories
Small
Beach
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Treasure Harbor main photo
Treasure Harbor
Hotel in Islamorada FLUS flag
8.4
Very Good
$
+4
Info
Categories
Small
Parking
3 Star
Casa Morada main photo
Casa Morada
Hotel in Islamorada FLUS flag
0.0
$
+6
Info
Categories
Small
Parking
Dog Friendly
PRIVATE BEACH Pickleball Court and Tiki Bar Heated Pool Designated Paradise Key main photo
$
+5
Info
Categories
Small
Dog Friendly
Pool
Casa Morada main photo
Casa Morada
Hotel in Islamorada FLUS flag
8.3
Very Good
$
+9
Info
Categories
Small
Pool
Outdoor Pool
5 Star
8 more hotels nearby!
Topsider Resort main photo
Topsider Resort
6.1 mi from Islamorada
Hotel in Lower Matecumbe Beach FLUS flag
7.6
Good
From $357
$
+9
Info
Categories
Small
Beachfront
Tennis
Brand new private 3 bedroom 2 bath apartment with kitchen,keyLargo Tavernier main photo
Brand new private 3 bedroom 2 bath apartment with kitchen,keyLargo Tavernier
9.9 mi from Islamorada
Hostel in Tavernier FLUS flag
4.5
Rated
$
+4
Info
Categories
Small
Dog Friendly
Free Wi-Fi
Atlantic Bay Resort main photo
Atlantic Bay Resort
10.3 mi from Islamorada
Motel in Key Largo FLUS flag
9.1
Excellent
From $210
$
+3
Info
Summary of reviews
Summarized by AI
Atlantic Bay Resort offers a serene and picturesque escape by the sea, often praised for its stunning seaside location and breathtaking sunsets. The resort's idyllic setting provides guests with direct access to a peaceful private beach, complementing the beautifully maintained accommodations, which range from charming cottages to spacious suites. Visitors frequently commend the resort's cleanliness, with rooms described as meticulously maintained and comfortably furnished in a nautical theme that blends seamlessly with the Caribbean vibe.

The staff at
Atlantic Bay Resort consistently earns accolades for their friendliness and exceptional service. Guests appreciate the team's attentiveness and helpfulness, which contribute to a welcoming atmosphere and enhanced vacation experience. Though the resort does not have on-site dining options, the staff provides excellent recommendations for nearby restaurants. The breakfast offerings, while basic, are enjoyed in a delightful setting overlooking the sea from a vintage Airstream camper.

Guests can fully embrace the waterfront lifestyle with complimentary amenities such as kayaks, paddleboards, and bicycles. The pool is another highlight, offering a clean and well-maintained environment with stunning views, particularly at sunset. Despite occasional Wi-Fi connectivity issues in rooms, the outdoor areas provide sufficient performance for light activities.

The resort's convenient parking, well-kept grounds, and accessibility to attractions both north and south of Key Largo make it an ideal base for exploration while maintaining a secluded and peaceful retreat. While some guests note minor issues with the comfort of the beds and limited Wi-Fi coverage in rooms, these concerns are often overshadowed by the overall positive experiences.

Atlantic Bay Resort emerges as a hidden gem, offering outstanding value and a tranquil retreat that draws guests back time and again. With its perfect mix of beautiful surroundings, genuine staff, and a focus on relaxation and natural beauty, it is highly recommended for travelers seeking a memorable waterfront getaway.
Categories
Small
Beachfront
Beach
Island Bay Resort main photo
Island Bay Resort
10.4 mi from Islamorada
Hotel in Key Largo FLUS flag
9.4
Excellent
From $320
$
+5
Small
AI-generatedThis resort offers an intimate and cozy experience with its waterfront location and personalized service. The laid-back atmosphere and natural beauty create a charming and relaxing getaway.
Ocean Pointe Resorts - 1214 Sea View main photo
Ocean Pointe Resorts - 1214 Sea View
10.9 mi from Islamorada
Aparthotel in Tavernier FLUS flag
8.9
Excellent
$
+3
Info
Categories
Small
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Parking
Ocean Pointe Resorts - Serenity 2308 main photo
Ocean Pointe Resorts - Serenity 2308
11.0 mi from Islamorada
Aparthotel in Tavernier FLUS flag
9.8
Excellent
$
+5
Info
Categories
Small
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Parking
Ocean Pointe Resorts 3410 Boho main photo
Ocean Pointe Resorts 3410 Boho
11.1 mi from Islamorada
Aparthotel in Tavernier FLUS flag
9.8
Excellent
$
+6
Info
Categories
Small
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Free Wi-Fi
Snappers Key Largo main photo
Snappers Key Largo
12.4 mi from Islamorada
Inn in Key Largo FLUS flag
8.0
Very Good
From $141
$
+1
Info
Summary of reviews
Summarized by AI
Snappers Key Largo is celebrated for its prime location and overall guest experience. Nestled by the water, the setting is idyllic, offering stunning waterfront views that charm visitors seeking a tranquil escape in the Florida Keys. Guests enjoy the vibrant atmosphere generated by the attached bar and restaurant, which offers picturesque views of the sea and lively energy, courtesy of its Tiki bar and terrace. The spacious, clean rooms, many with private terraces providing incredible bay or ocean views, enhance the serenity of this location.

Dining at
Snappers Key Largo is a standout feature. The on-site restaurant praised for its excellent seafood and vibrant ambiance, complemented by live music, makes evening dining a delight. Staff are typically friendly and attentive, further enhancing the dining experience. Despite the minor inconvenience of the restaurant opening only at 4 PM and the absence of breakfast options, the quality of dinner service is superb and highly recommended by visitors.

Rooms at
Snappers Key Largo strike a good balance between comfort and charm. Many reviews highlight the cozy, clean and well-sized accommodations, decorated with a beach vibe that perks up the stay. While some rooms need updates and show signs of aging, the private decks and ocean views often make up for these minor concerns. The rooms ensure a quiet night's sleep, away from road noise, contributing to a restful stay.

The cleanliness of
Snappers Key Largo is another frequently commended aspect with guests often noting the spotless conditions of both rooms and shared spaces. This, combined with comfortable beds, even if opinions on firmness vary, adds to the overall positive impressions of the stay.

The staff at
Snappers Key Largo are celebrated for their friendliness and helpfulness. Excellent service at check-in and during meals contributes to the relaxing and enjoyable atmosphere. Some critiques on staff availability and experience are noted, but they do not overshadow the general high praise.

Amenities like free parking, although sufficient, could be improved with designated spots for hotel guests to alleviate carrying luggage across the street. Additionally, the Wi-Fi service generally receives negative feedback due to its unreliability in guest rooms, requiring guests to search for a signal near the restaurant.

In sum,
Snappers Key Largo offers a memorable stay with its scenic location, vibrant dining options, comfortable accommodations and friendly staff, making it a solid choice for visitors seeking a blend of peace, beauty and fun in the Florida Keys.
Categories
Small
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-20 out of 36 hotels in and around Islamorada
Save more on the App
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities