Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In
Free Wi-FiParkingDog FriendlyPoolAccessibleOutdoor PoolBusiness3 StarHoneymoonGymFamilyAdult OnlyIndoor PoolSmallSustainability JourneyHeated PoolEV charging stationsGolf4 StarPrivate PoolCheapTennisLuxuryRomanticHistoricRooms with Jacuzzi / Hot-TubSpa5 StarChildren's PoolCastleCasinoVineyard
  1. World
  2. >North America
  3. >United States
  4. >New York
  5. >Suffolk
  6. >Fire Island Pines

Hotels in Fire Island Pines

200+ HOTELS IN AND AROUND FIRE ISLAND PINESRanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
The Madison Fire Island Pines main photo
The Madison Fire Island Pines
Guest House in Fire Island Pines NYUS flag
9.5
Excellent
Currently inactive on our platform.
$
+6
Info
Categories
Adult Only
Honeymoon
Pool
Heated Pool
Outdoor Pool
The Pines Men-Only Stay main photo
The Pines Men-Only Stay
Homestay in Fire Island Pines NYUS flag
9.7
Excellent
From $239
$
+6
Info
Categories
Pool
Heated Pool
Private Pool
Outdoor Pool
Free Wi-Fi
Adult Only
Davis Park Fire Island Retreat main photo
Davis Park Fire Island Retreat
Vacation Home in Fire Island Pines NYUS flag
0.0
$
+1
Info
Categories
Free Wi-Fi
LoveFINS main photo
LoveFINS
Campground in Fire Island Pines NYUS flag
3.7
Rated
$
+1
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
16 more hotels nearby!
Luxury 3-bedroom Pines house with 360-degree views main photo
Luxury 3-bedroom Pines house with 360-degree views
0.6 mi from Fire Island Pines
Vacation Home in Sayville NYUS flag
0.0
$
+4
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Free Wi-Fi
Grove Hotel main photo
Grove Hotel
1.4 mi from Fire Island Pines
Hotel in Cherry Grove NYUS flag
8.9
Excellent
From $144
$
+6
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Free Wi-Fi
10 Cayuga main photo
10 Cayuga
3.9 mi from Fire Island Pines
Vacation Home in Ocean Bay Park NYUS flag
9.0
Excellent
From $953
$
+2
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
Free Wi-Fi
Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat main photo
Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat
3.9 mi from Fire Island Pines
Vacation Home in Ocean Bay Park NYUS flag
9.5
Excellent
From $1,185
$
+2
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
Free Wi-Fi
15 Seneca main photo
15 Seneca
3.9 mi from Fire Island Pines
Vacation Home in Ocean Bay Park NYUS flag
9.3
Excellent
From $2,744
$
+2
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
Pool
Private Pool
Pura Vida main photo
Pura Vida
4.0 mi from Fire Island Pines
Vacation Home in Ocean Bay Park NYUS flag
7.0
Good
Currently inactive on our platform.
$
Info
The Pelican's Nest main photo
The Pelican's Nest
4.0 mi from Fire Island Pines
Vacation Home in Ocean Bay Park NYUS flag
0.0
Currently inactive on our platform.
$
Info
Poolside Chic by the Sea main photo
Poolside Chic by the Sea
4.0 mi from Fire Island Pines
Vacation Home in Ocean Bay Park NYUS flag
5.0
Rated
From $1,809
$
+3
Info
Categories
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Heated Pool
Private Pool
The Surfcomber Multi-Residence Home main photo
The Surfcomber Multi-Residence Home
4.0 mi from Fire Island Pines
Apartment in Ocean Bay Park NYUS flag
0.0
From $1,361
$
+1
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
The Surfcomber Unit 3 main photo
The Surfcomber Unit 3
4.0 mi from Fire Island Pines
Apartment in Ocean Bay Park NYUS flag
3.0
Rated
$
+1
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
The Surfcomber Unit 1 main photo
The Surfcomber Unit 1
4.0 mi from Fire Island Pines
Vacation Home in Ocean Bay Park NYUS flag
9.7
Excellent
From $560
$
+1
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
The Surfcomber Unit 2 main photo
The Surfcomber Unit 2
4.0 mi from Fire Island Pines
Vacation Home in Ocean Bay Park NYUS flag
0.0
$
+1
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
37 Ocean Bay Blvd main photo
37 Ocean Bay Blvd
4.0 mi from Fire Island Pines
Vacation Home in Ocean Bay Park NYUS flag
4.0
Rated
Currently inactive on our platform.
$
+1
Info
Categories
Accessible
Coastal Cove Cottage main photo
Coastal Cove Cottage
4.1 mi from Fire Island Pines
Hotel in Ocean Bay Park NYUS flag
0.0
Currently inactive on our platform.
$
+1
Info
Categories
Small
Tranquil Tides main photo
Tranquil Tides
4.2 mi from Fire Island Pines
Vacation Home in Ocean Bay Park NYUS flag
0.0
Currently inactive on our platform.
$
+1
Info
Categories
Adult Only
Fire Island Gem main photo
Fire Island Gem
4.2 mi from Fire Island Pines
Apartment in Ocean Bay Park NYUS flag
9.0
Excellent
Currently inactive on our platform.
$
+1
Info
Categories
Accessible
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-20 out of 200+ hotels in and around Fire Island Pines
Save more on the App
Categories
Map
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities