The Scholar
➔
➔
Please select your travel dates to see rates and availability
Info
Summary of reviews**The Scholar** at the University of Edinburgh offers a serene and comfortable lodging experience, celebrated for its blend of tranquility and convenience. Nestled within the lush, green campus, it serves as an ideal retreat for nature lovers and those attending university events. Guests appreciate its proximity to iconic landmarks like Arthur's Seat and Holyrood Park, as well as the ease of accessing Edinburgh's city center through a pleasant walk or efficient public transport options. The hotel grounds, surrounded by well-maintained gardens and ample parking facilities, are noted as immaculate, further enhancing its appeal.
The breakfast experience at The Scholar earns high praise for its variety, quality and service. Guests delight in the comprehensive buffet and à la carte options with particular appreciation for the Scottish breakfast. The fresh selection of fruits, pastries, cheeses and hot dishes caters to diverse dietary preferences, making breakfast a highlight of many stays. Despite occasional minor delays with coffee service, the overall ambiance and value for money contribute to a highly recommended breakfast experience.
Dinner at The Scholar also receives generally positive feedback. Dishes are noted for their delicious taste and beautiful presentation, particularly steaks and sea bass. While the dog-friendly environment and friendly staff add to a positive dining experience, some guests mention slower service and limited menu options as areas for improvement. Nevertheless, the bistro atmosphere and the overall quality of the food make it a delightful experience.
The rooms at The Scholar are another strong point, frequently described as spacious, clean and comfortable. Guests appreciate the modern amenities, including large smart TVs and luxurious teas. The cleanliness and thoughtful room design contribute to a pleasant and luxurious stay, despite occasional mentions of smaller rooms. The general consensus highlights the rooms' comfort and modernity, ensuring a satisfying experience.
Cleanliness is a standout feature at The Scholar with guests consistently praising the spotless and well-maintained environment. This attention to cleanliness is evident throughout the hotel, reinforcing its reputation as a top choice for travelers prioritizing hygiene.
The staff receives glowing reviews for their friendliness, professionalism and willingness to assist. Guests often highlight the super-friendly and efficient staff, who go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant stay. The positive interactions with the staff, from the reception to the dining areas, contribute significantly to the hotel's warm and welcoming atmosphere.
WiFi experiences at The Scholar vary with many guests enjoying fast and reliable connections, though some encounter issues with connectivity and setup. The hotel's prompt resolution of problems is appreciated, but there remains room for improvement to ensure consistent service across all areas.
Parking at The Scholar is generally hassle-free and seen as a significant advantage, especially given Edinburgh's usual challenges with parking spaces. The availability of free on-site and nearby parking, along with features like electric vehicle charging stations, adds to the hotel's appeal.
For families, The Scholar offers a welcoming environment with amenities that cater to both children and pets. Despite some mentions of smaller room sizes, the overall family-friendly atmosphere and thoughtful services make it a highly recommended option for family stays.
In summary, The Scholar is celebrated for its serene location, excellent breakfast offerings, comfortable rooms and attentive staff. The minor criticisms are overshadowed by the overwhelmingly positive feedback, making it a standout choice for those visiting Edinburgh whether for leisure, academic or family travel.
Categories
The breakfast experience at The Scholar earns high praise for its variety, quality and service. Guests delight in the comprehensive buffet and à la carte options with particular appreciation for the Scottish breakfast. The fresh selection of fruits, pastries, cheeses and hot dishes caters to diverse dietary preferences, making breakfast a highlight of many stays. Despite occasional minor delays with coffee service, the overall ambiance and value for money contribute to a highly recommended breakfast experience.
Dinner at The Scholar also receives generally positive feedback. Dishes are noted for their delicious taste and beautiful presentation, particularly steaks and sea bass. While the dog-friendly environment and friendly staff add to a positive dining experience, some guests mention slower service and limited menu options as areas for improvement. Nevertheless, the bistro atmosphere and the overall quality of the food make it a delightful experience.
The rooms at The Scholar are another strong point, frequently described as spacious, clean and comfortable. Guests appreciate the modern amenities, including large smart TVs and luxurious teas. The cleanliness and thoughtful room design contribute to a pleasant and luxurious stay, despite occasional mentions of smaller rooms. The general consensus highlights the rooms' comfort and modernity, ensuring a satisfying experience.
Cleanliness is a standout feature at The Scholar with guests consistently praising the spotless and well-maintained environment. This attention to cleanliness is evident throughout the hotel, reinforcing its reputation as a top choice for travelers prioritizing hygiene.
The staff receives glowing reviews for their friendliness, professionalism and willingness to assist. Guests often highlight the super-friendly and efficient staff, who go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant stay. The positive interactions with the staff, from the reception to the dining areas, contribute significantly to the hotel's warm and welcoming atmosphere.
WiFi experiences at The Scholar vary with many guests enjoying fast and reliable connections, though some encounter issues with connectivity and setup. The hotel's prompt resolution of problems is appreciated, but there remains room for improvement to ensure consistent service across all areas.
Parking at The Scholar is generally hassle-free and seen as a significant advantage, especially given Edinburgh's usual challenges with parking spaces. The availability of free on-site and nearby parking, along with features like electric vehicle charging stations, adds to the hotel's appeal.
For families, The Scholar offers a welcoming environment with amenities that cater to both children and pets. Despite some mentions of smaller room sizes, the overall family-friendly atmosphere and thoughtful services make it a highly recommended option for family stays.
In summary, The Scholar is celebrated for its serene location, excellent breakfast offerings, comfortable rooms and attentive staff. The minor criticisms are overshadowed by the overwhelmingly positive feedback, making it a standout choice for those visiting Edinburgh whether for leisure, academic or family travel.
Hotel near Golf Courses
Located in the EH16 postcode area, this hotel is in a part of Edinburgh with multiple golf courses easily accessible, such as Craigmillar Park Golf Club and Liberton Golf Club.
Hotel with Free Wi-Fi
Located in Edinburgh, this hotel provides free Wi-Fi. Its proximity to Holyrood Park and modern amenities make it a convenient choice.
Hotel with EV Charging Stations
This hotel offers a large number of electric car charging points on-site, with 18 ChargePlace Scotland points available for guests.
Luxury Hotel
Hotel for Honeymoon
Family Friendly Hotel
Dog Friendly Hotel
Romantic Hotel
Hotel with Parking
EV charging stations
4-Star Hotel
Guest Reviews
Nestled within the serene campus of the University of Edinburgh, 'The Scholar' offers a unique lodging experience that combines tranquility with convenience. The hotel is surrounded by lush greenery and parks, making it an ideal retreat for nature lovers and those seeking a peaceful environment. Guests often praise its proximity to iconic landmarks such as Arthur’s Seat and Holyrood Park, perfect for hiking and leisurely walks. Although it sits slightly outside the bustling city center, the vibrant heart of Edinburgh remains easily accessible through numerous bus routes or a pleasant 20-30 minute walk.
The hotel's location is particularly beneficial for those visiting the university or attending conferences at the John McIntyre Conference Centre. Additionally, the peaceful campus grounds provide a welcome respite from the city's hustle and bustle, offering a quiet ambiance conducive to rest and relaxation. Despite its somewhat remote setting, guests appreciate the excellent connectivity to downtown Edinburgh and various tourist attractions via public transport.
Visitors also commend 'The Scholar' for its immaculate surroundings, including well-maintained gardens and ample parking facilities. The friendly and helpful staff further enhance the overall experience, making it a great choice for both leisure and academic visits. Whether exploring nearby sites or enjoying the serene campus, 'The Scholar' presents an excellent base to discover the best that Edinburgh has to offer.
The breakfast at "The Scholar" has received consistently high praise from guests, being described as very good to excellent and even exceptional by some. Guests particularly appreciate the variety and quality of options available with a delightful combination of both buffet and à la carte choices. The Scottish breakfast, including vegetarian versions, has been highlighted as tasty and authentic. Many reviews mention the abundance and freshness of the selection, such as fresh fruit, pastries, cheeses, cold meats and well-prepared hot dishes.
The breakfast buffet is often described as comprehensive and plentiful with everything from cereals and juices to freshly prepared hot items. Frequent mentions of the generous and varied breakfasts underline the appeal for guests with different dietary preferences, including gluten-free and vegan options. This variety and quality are matched by excellent service with staff being described as attentive and friendly, creating a pleasant breakfast experience.
The ambiance of the breakfast venue receives positive feedback, often described as airy and inviting. Guests also remark on the great value for money, making breakfast at "The Scholar" a highly recommended experience. Some criticisms were noted regarding slow coffee service and occasional waits at the coffee machine, but overall, these did not significantly detract from the overwhelmingly positive reviews of the breakfast offerings.
In summary, the breakfast at "The Scholar" stands out for its exceptional variety, quality and service, making it a highlight of any guest's stay.
The dining experience at 'The Scholar' hotel receives generally high praise from guests, particularly for its dog-friendly environment and excellent quality of food. Many guests commend the on-site restaurant and bistro for their delicious and nicely presented dishes. Breakfast, lunch and dinner at the hotel are often described as tasty with sandwiches being notably large and satisfying.
Guests have frequently mentioned the high quality of evening meals with steaks and sea bass being particularly enjoyed. Some reviews highlight the great value for money the food offers and the bistro's appealing atmosphere and beautifully presented dishes. The restaurant is noted for its good quality and friendly, accommodating staff, contributing to an overall positive dining experience.
However, reviews are somewhat mixed regarding the dinner service. While many found the food delicious and the portions adequate, others noted slow service and limited menu options. Some guests felt that portion sizes could have been more generous and mentioned specific dishes, like the veggie risotto, as lacking in flavor. Additionally, the restaurant's closing hours and the need for reservations may limit accessibility for some guests. Despite these few shortcomings, the general consensus is that dining at 'The Scholar' is a delightful experience enhanced by excellent food and courteous service.
The Scholar consistently receives positive feedback for its spacious, clean and comfortable rooms, making it a favored choice for travelers. Most guests highlight the surprising room sizes with many rooms larger than expected, featuring comfortable beds and large, modern bathrooms.
The rooms are well-appointed and equipped with essential amenities like tea and coffee facilities, luxurious teas, modern décor and thoughtful touches such as a coffee machine and French press. The hotel itself maintains a modern and clean style with amenities that include large smart TVs and well-designed interiors.
Cleanliness is a standout feature with numerous guests praising the spotless and fresh room conditions. Spaciousness, combined with tasteful decoration and modern facilities, creates a pleasant and luxurious stay. The bathrooms are often described as large and well-designed, featuring generous showers with multiple showerheads.
The location is also appreciated for its quiet and peaceful surroundings, yet convenient proximity to the city center. Overall, guests report a comfortable and satisfying experience with beautifully furnished rooms and helpful, friendly staff contributing to a welcome and pleasant stay. While some rooms are noted to be small or cramped, the majority of reviews reflect highly on the size, comfort and modernity of the accommodations.
The Scholar consistently impresses with its remarkably comfortable beds that draw extensive praise from guests. Beds are often described as huge, king-sized and incredibly spacious, ensuring a relaxing and restful experience. The quality of the mattresses and pillows is notably high, providing excellent support and comfort. Crisp white linens add a touch of luxury, complemented by rooms that are described as clean, cozy and spacious. Guests frequently highlight the softness and comfort of the bedding with many stating they didn’t want to get out of bed. Overall, the sleeping experience at The Scholar is characterized by exceptional comfort and cleanliness, setting a high standard for a good night's rest.
'The Scholar' has garnered widespread praise for its outstanding cleanliness. Guests frequently highlight that the hotel and its rooms are immaculately clean with many using terms such as spotless, super clean and immaculate cleanliness to describe their experience. The bathrooms are also noted for their cleanliness, often described as spotless and well-maintained. This high level of hygiene is consistent throughout all areas of the hotel, making it a top choice for those prioritizing cleanliness.
The rooms at 'The Scholar' are not only clean but also spacious and comfortable, contributing to a pleasant stay. The modern, stylish decor and fresh appearance of the hotel further emphasize its well-kept environment. The communal areas and facilities are equally well-maintained, reinforcing the hotel's commitment to cleanliness and hygiene.
Despite the overwhelming positive feedback, a few guests pointed out minor issues such as occasional hair left by the decorator and areas that seemed to have been missed by the vacuum. However, these instances are rare and do not overshadow the overall cleanliness standards of the hotel.
In summary, 'The Scholar' excels in providing a clean and comfortable stay for its guests. The meticulous attention to cleanliness and maintenance makes it a reliable and appealing option for travelers.
At "The Scholar," the consensus from guest reviews paints a glowing picture of the staff's efforts and demeanor. Guests frequently highlighted the friendly and welcoming nature of the staff, often describing them as super friendly, extremely accommodating and consistently professional. The staff at The Scholar are not only courteous and polite but also very efficient, ensuring that guests feel well-taken-care-of throughout their stay.
Remarkably, the staff's helpfulness was a recurring theme with many reviews mentioning that they were always willing to assist with anything needed, going above and beyond to cater to guests' needs. Their attentiveness didn't go unnoticed, as guests appreciated how the staff paid attention to every detail, ensuring that each interaction was pleasant and engaging.
In dining areas, the restaurant and breakfast staff were singled out for their flexibility and willingness to accommodate special requests. The reception team also received accolades for their friendliness, prompt service and genuine efforts to make guests feel at home, often remembered by name and greeted cheerfully. The overall service was described as superb and the hospitality excellent.
The Scholar’s team was recognized for their remarkable professionalism and their impressive knowledge of the local area, aiding guests in navigating the city effortlessly. The consistently positive reviews underscore the exceptional experience provided by the attentive, upbeat and proficient staff, making "The Scholar" a standout choice for travelers seeking not just a stay, but a warm and memorable experience.
The WiFi experience at 'The Scholar' has varied greatly among guests with some highlighting its strengths while others encountered significant issues. Many reviewers praised the hotel for its fast, reliable and secure WiFi, often noting that the connection was excellent throughout the hotel and provided a strong and stable performance. Several guests even emphasized the hotel's ability to address any WiFi issues quickly and efficiently.
On the other hand, a number of guests faced challenges with the WiFi, reporting instances of limited internet connectivity, frequent interruptions and a weak signal, particularly in the rooms. Some were not satisfied with having to pay for WiFi or dealing with the complexity of the WiFi setup, describing the process as ridiculous and inconvenient. This led to mixed feelings, as initial problems were sometimes resolved with patience and intervention from the reception staff.
In summary, 'The Scholar' offers a generally positive WiFi experience for many guests, though some have encountered notable difficulties. The hotel's prompt resolution of issues has made a difference, but there remains room for improvement in ensuring consistent internet service across all areas.
The Scholar, located in Edinburgh, receives favorable comments regarding its parking facilities from many guests. One of the standout features is the availability of free parking, including options on-site and nearby. While the parking spaces are generally described as ample and hassle-free, some reviewers note limited space, especially during peak times. Nevertheless, guests often highlight the safety and convenience of the parking with additional features like electric vehicle charging stations and motorcycle parking adding to the appeal.
A few travelers mention minor difficulties in finding a spot, indicating that it can be a bit tricky at times, but alternative parking solutions are available nearby. The presence of free parking on the university campus adjacent to the hotel also receives positive mention. Overall, the parking situation at The Scholar is seen as a significant advantage, especially given Edinburgh's usual challenges with parking spaces.
The Scholar offers excellent facilities for electric vehicle users with numerous charging stations available on-site. Guests have noted there are plenty of charging points, making it convenient for those traveling with electric cars. The charging spots are well-placed and readily accessible, ensuring ease of use for all visitors. Additionally, complimentary charging is available, adding further value. Overall, the hotel provides ample support for electric vehicles, ensuring guests can charge their cars efficiently during their stay.
The Scholar provides a family-friendly setting that seems to draw in many families who are looking for a comfortable stay. Guests consistently mention that all family members enjoyed their time at the hotel, highlighting it as an excellent option for family vacations. The atmosphere is perfect for families with children, offering a child-friendly environment and family-oriented amenities. Many guests appreciated the thoughtful gestures, such as providing a doggy pack for those traveling with pets and sandwich packages for journeys.
Despite some concerns about room sizes being a bit cramped for larger families, the hotel makes up for it with its great service and attention to family needs. The family rooms, although sometimes described as tight on space, were appreciated for their comfort and ability to accommodate family stays. Though the lighting and room size could be improved, the overall experience remains positive for family travelers.
The hotel’s location is praised for being quiet and convenient, which contributes to a safe and pleasant family environment. It’s noted for being particularly good value for money and many families recommend it to others. The option for children under 12 to stay free is a significant plus for larger families. While the absence of swimming pools or slides was a minor letdown for some, other features and the warm hospitality more than compensated.
Overall, The Scholar is highly recommended for a family stay in Scotland. Families appreciate the friendly service, the variety of amenities and the comfortable, welcoming atmosphere for both children and pets.
The Scholar is in close proximity to excellent golf courses, making it an appealing choice for golf enthusiasts. The nearby university golf courses are particularly highlighted for their putting greens, which are in decent condition. Overall, the hotel's location near these well-regarded golfing options is a notable advantage.
The Scholar Hotel has established itself with an upmarket standard that aligns with the expectations of a four-star hotel. Guests appreciate its excellent, beautiful and luxurious accommodations, often highlighting that it deserves its four-star rating and is better than many three-star hotels. The hotel provides an ambiance that meets or even exceeds four-star standards, featuring consistent amenities and an overall four-star experience.
Service is a standout feature, often described as impeccable, exceptional and fantastic, contributing to an absolutely top-notch experience. The newly renovated interior is modern and functional, adding to the luxury feel despite the less attractive exterior. While some guests mention that it’s not cheap, they consider it good value for the price, underscoring that the accommodations and services are worth the cost.
Overall, The Scholar delivers a four-star level of comfort with facilities like comfortable beds, large bathrooms and clean rooms, making it a very good choice for visitors seeking quality and reliability from their stay.
The Scholar emerges as an ideal haven for honeymoon couples, set amidst a serene environment that offers the perfect backdrop for a romantic getaway. Guests consistently highlight the hotel's quiet, peaceful and serene atmosphere, making it an excellent choice for those seeking a private and intimate experience. The hotel is frequently described as honeymoon-worthy with specific mentions of its suitability as a honeymoon retreat and romantic getaway destination.
Those celebrating their honeymoon will find the surroundings calm and conducive to relaxation, reinforcing the sense of peace and tranquility. The establishment goes the extra mile with its beautiful honeymoon suites and thoughtful honeymoon packages that add a special touch to the experience. Overall, The Scholar stands out as a perfect choice for staying in Edinburgh, particularly for couples and honeymooners looking for a quiet and romantic stay.
The Scholar offers an experience steeped in luxury ambiance and high-end amenities. Guests have repeatedly mentioned the comfort, style and premium quality of the accommodations, praising the cozy and modern atmosphere. This hotel perfectly melds luxurious, large spaces with high-quality facilities, ensuring a stay that exceeds expectations. The attention to detail extends to the deluxe decor and luxurious dining experience with a breakfast noted for its quality.
The bedrooms invite with clean, spacious and luxury bedding, complemented by modern, contemporary design elements. The high standard of the hotel is further elevated by the excellent staff who cater to guests’ needs without being intrusive. This higher budget, four-star hotel offers luxurious views and the best in premium and brand-new amenities. Though it may be considered a luxurious university residence, The Scholar stands out with its modern charms and high-end features, making it a recommended choice for those willing to indulge in comfortable, stylish luxury.
The Scholar in Scotland emerges as an ideal romantic retreat for couples seeking an intimate getaway. The hotel's ambiance is distinctly romantic, featuring decor that enhances a cozy and serene atmosphere, making it perfect for honeymoons and special romantic vacations. Guests frequently praise the picturesque views, particularly of Arthur's Seat, which contributes to the overall romantic setting. The staff's wonderfully accommodating nature adds to the appeal, ensuring a comfortable and delightful stay. Whether looking for a beautiful spot for a romantic evening or a serene environment for a romantic getaway, The Scholar presents itself as an exceptional choice.
Location Show Map
Location
The hotel's location is particularly beneficial for those visiting the university or attending conferences at the John McIntyre Conference Centre. Additionally, the peaceful campus grounds provide a welcome respite from the city's hustle and bustle, offering a quiet ambiance conducive to rest and relaxation. Despite its somewhat remote setting, guests appreciate the excellent connectivity to downtown Edinburgh and various tourist attractions via public transport.
Visitors also commend 'The Scholar' for its immaculate surroundings, including well-maintained gardens and ample parking facilities. The friendly and helpful staff further enhance the overall experience, making it a great choice for both leisure and academic visits. Whether exploring nearby sites or enjoying the serene campus, 'The Scholar' presents an excellent base to discover the best that Edinburgh has to offer.
Breakfast
The breakfast buffet is often described as comprehensive and plentiful with everything from cereals and juices to freshly prepared hot items. Frequent mentions of the generous and varied breakfasts underline the appeal for guests with different dietary preferences, including gluten-free and vegan options. This variety and quality are matched by excellent service with staff being described as attentive and friendly, creating a pleasant breakfast experience.
The ambiance of the breakfast venue receives positive feedback, often described as airy and inviting. Guests also remark on the great value for money, making breakfast at "The Scholar" a highly recommended experience. Some criticisms were noted regarding slow coffee service and occasional waits at the coffee machine, but overall, these did not significantly detract from the overwhelmingly positive reviews of the breakfast offerings.
In summary, the breakfast at "The Scholar" stands out for its exceptional variety, quality and service, making it a highlight of any guest's stay.
Dinner
Guests have frequently mentioned the high quality of evening meals with steaks and sea bass being particularly enjoyed. Some reviews highlight the great value for money the food offers and the bistro's appealing atmosphere and beautifully presented dishes. The restaurant is noted for its good quality and friendly, accommodating staff, contributing to an overall positive dining experience.
However, reviews are somewhat mixed regarding the dinner service. While many found the food delicious and the portions adequate, others noted slow service and limited menu options. Some guests felt that portion sizes could have been more generous and mentioned specific dishes, like the veggie risotto, as lacking in flavor. Additionally, the restaurant's closing hours and the need for reservations may limit accessibility for some guests. Despite these few shortcomings, the general consensus is that dining at 'The Scholar' is a delightful experience enhanced by excellent food and courteous service.
Rooms
The rooms are well-appointed and equipped with essential amenities like tea and coffee facilities, luxurious teas, modern décor and thoughtful touches such as a coffee machine and French press. The hotel itself maintains a modern and clean style with amenities that include large smart TVs and well-designed interiors.
Cleanliness is a standout feature with numerous guests praising the spotless and fresh room conditions. Spaciousness, combined with tasteful decoration and modern facilities, creates a pleasant and luxurious stay. The bathrooms are often described as large and well-designed, featuring generous showers with multiple showerheads.
The location is also appreciated for its quiet and peaceful surroundings, yet convenient proximity to the city center. Overall, guests report a comfortable and satisfying experience with beautifully furnished rooms and helpful, friendly staff contributing to a welcome and pleasant stay. While some rooms are noted to be small or cramped, the majority of reviews reflect highly on the size, comfort and modernity of the accommodations.
Beds
Cleanliness
The rooms at 'The Scholar' are not only clean but also spacious and comfortable, contributing to a pleasant stay. The modern, stylish decor and fresh appearance of the hotel further emphasize its well-kept environment. The communal areas and facilities are equally well-maintained, reinforcing the hotel's commitment to cleanliness and hygiene.
Despite the overwhelming positive feedback, a few guests pointed out minor issues such as occasional hair left by the decorator and areas that seemed to have been missed by the vacuum. However, these instances are rare and do not overshadow the overall cleanliness standards of the hotel.
In summary, 'The Scholar' excels in providing a clean and comfortable stay for its guests. The meticulous attention to cleanliness and maintenance makes it a reliable and appealing option for travelers.
Staff
Remarkably, the staff's helpfulness was a recurring theme with many reviews mentioning that they were always willing to assist with anything needed, going above and beyond to cater to guests' needs. Their attentiveness didn't go unnoticed, as guests appreciated how the staff paid attention to every detail, ensuring that each interaction was pleasant and engaging.
In dining areas, the restaurant and breakfast staff were singled out for their flexibility and willingness to accommodate special requests. The reception team also received accolades for their friendliness, prompt service and genuine efforts to make guests feel at home, often remembered by name and greeted cheerfully. The overall service was described as superb and the hospitality excellent.
The Scholar’s team was recognized for their remarkable professionalism and their impressive knowledge of the local area, aiding guests in navigating the city effortlessly. The consistently positive reviews underscore the exceptional experience provided by the attentive, upbeat and proficient staff, making "The Scholar" a standout choice for travelers seeking not just a stay, but a warm and memorable experience.
Wi-Fi
On the other hand, a number of guests faced challenges with the WiFi, reporting instances of limited internet connectivity, frequent interruptions and a weak signal, particularly in the rooms. Some were not satisfied with having to pay for WiFi or dealing with the complexity of the WiFi setup, describing the process as ridiculous and inconvenient. This led to mixed feelings, as initial problems were sometimes resolved with patience and intervention from the reception staff.
In summary, 'The Scholar' offers a generally positive WiFi experience for many guests, though some have encountered notable difficulties. The hotel's prompt resolution of issues has made a difference, but there remains room for improvement in ensuring consistent internet service across all areas.
Parking
A few travelers mention minor difficulties in finding a spot, indicating that it can be a bit tricky at times, but alternative parking solutions are available nearby. The presence of free parking on the university campus adjacent to the hotel also receives positive mention. Overall, the parking situation at The Scholar is seen as a significant advantage, especially given Edinburgh's usual challenges with parking spaces.
EV charging stations
Family
Despite some concerns about room sizes being a bit cramped for larger families, the hotel makes up for it with its great service and attention to family needs. The family rooms, although sometimes described as tight on space, were appreciated for their comfort and ability to accommodate family stays. Though the lighting and room size could be improved, the overall experience remains positive for family travelers.
The hotel’s location is praised for being quiet and convenient, which contributes to a safe and pleasant family environment. It’s noted for being particularly good value for money and many families recommend it to others. The option for children under 12 to stay free is a significant plus for larger families. While the absence of swimming pools or slides was a minor letdown for some, other features and the warm hospitality more than compensated.
Overall, The Scholar is highly recommended for a family stay in Scotland. Families appreciate the friendly service, the variety of amenities and the comfortable, welcoming atmosphere for both children and pets.
Golf
4 Star
Service is a standout feature, often described as impeccable, exceptional and fantastic, contributing to an absolutely top-notch experience. The newly renovated interior is modern and functional, adding to the luxury feel despite the less attractive exterior. While some guests mention that it’s not cheap, they consider it good value for the price, underscoring that the accommodations and services are worth the cost.
Overall, The Scholar delivers a four-star level of comfort with facilities like comfortable beds, large bathrooms and clean rooms, making it a very good choice for visitors seeking quality and reliability from their stay.
Honeymoon
Those celebrating their honeymoon will find the surroundings calm and conducive to relaxation, reinforcing the sense of peace and tranquility. The establishment goes the extra mile with its beautiful honeymoon suites and thoughtful honeymoon packages that add a special touch to the experience. Overall, The Scholar stands out as a perfect choice for staying in Edinburgh, particularly for couples and honeymooners looking for a quiet and romantic stay.
Luxury
The bedrooms invite with clean, spacious and luxury bedding, complemented by modern, contemporary design elements. The high standard of the hotel is further elevated by the excellent staff who cater to guests’ needs without being intrusive. This higher budget, four-star hotel offers luxurious views and the best in premium and brand-new amenities. Though it may be considered a luxurious university residence, The Scholar stands out with its modern charms and high-end features, making it a recommended choice for those willing to indulge in comfortable, stylish luxury.
Romantic
No, The Scholar doesn't have any pool.
No, a spa isn't available at The Scholar.
Yes, The Scholar welcomes dogs.
Yes, parking facilities are available at The Scholar.
No, The Scholar doesn't have a gym.
Location Show Map
More Options
