Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In

Historic, 3-Star Hotels in East Rutherford

7 HOTELS IN AND AROUND EAST RUTHERFORDRanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
7 hotels nearby!
Hotel Marrakech main photo
Hotel Marrakech
6.2 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
6.8
Rated
From $84
$
Info
Categories
Historic
3 Star
Nightlife
Candy Hill Harlem main photo
Candy Hill Harlem
7.0 km from East Rutherford
Bed & Breakfast in New York NYUS flag
7.5
Good
From $27
$
Info
Categories
Historic
3 Star
Dog Friendly
Robert Treat Hotel main photo
Robert Treat Hotel
7.2 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in Newark NJUS flag
7.1
Good
From $134
$
Info
Summary of reviews
The Robert Treat Hotel in Newark, NJ, is widely appreciated for its prime location, making it a favorable choice for travelers attending concerts, business meetings or visiting New York City. The hotel’s proximity to Newark Penn Station allows for easy access to Manhattan and its location near the Prudential Center, NJPAC, various restaurants and shops adds to the convenience. Guests frequently highlight the complimentary shuttle service to and from the airport and train station, as well as the nearby park and on-site restaurant, enhancing their overall experience.

The in-house restaurant is particularly well-regarded for its delicious food and quality dishes with guests frequently commending the excellent flavors, clean interior and attentive staff. Additionally, many guests found the Wi-Fi to be reliable with a generally good connection and appreciated the gym's equipment and fitness facilities despite some maintenance issues.

However, the hotel doesn’t consistently meet expectations in a few areas. Breakfast options have been a notable disappointment with some guests redirected to nearby establishments at an additional cost. The rooms receive mixed reviews; while some guests describe them as clean and comfortable with nice views and sufficient amenities, others report issues with cigarette smoke, outdated decor, small sizes and maintenance shortcomings. Cleanliness also varies with inconsistencies ranging from exceptionally clean to complaints of dirty linens, mold and leftover debris.

The staff's service is similarly mixed. While many guests appreciate the friendliness and professionalism of certain team members, others encounter unprofessional and unhelpful behavior, which can detract from the overall experience. Parking, though secure and reasonably priced, occasionally presents challenges due to limited spots and extra fees.

For families, the hotel provides varying levels of comfort with some appreciating the spacious rooms and kid-friendly service, while others find the accommodations small and not entirely safe or family-friendly due to cleanliness and maintenance issues. The hotel’s location is favorable for those looking to experience the nightlife with easy access to entertainment venues and bars, although noise from the surroundings can be a concern.

In summary, the
Robert Treat Hotel has many strengths, particularly its excellent location, convenient dining and general amenities like free Wi-Fi and a gym. However, the hotel could benefit from improvements in areas such as breakfast service, room maintenance, cleanliness standards and staff professionalism to ensure a consistently positive guest experience.
Categories
3 Star
Historic
Honeymoon
Hotel 27 by LuxUrban main photo
Hotel 27 by LuxUrban
7.3 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
7.1
Good
From $202
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Hotel 27 by LuxUrban, strategically nestled on Madison Avenue in the heart of Midtown Manhattan, garners high praise for its prime location. Guests appreciate its proximity to key attractions including the Empire State Building, Times Square and the Flatiron Building, along with easy access to public transportation. This excellent placement allows for convenient exploration of Manhattan’s vibrant energy. The hotel's central location in the NoMad neighborhood with amenities such as a nearby supermarket and seamless connectivity, is frequently highlighted as a major advantage.

However, the hotel falls short in delivering a consistent breakfast experience. Despite advertisements suggesting breakfast inclusion, many guests report its absence, inconsistency or redirection to external restaurants that fail to honor the promise. When available, the breakfast is often described as basic and insufficient.

The rooms at
Hotel 27 by LuxUrban, while generally clean and functional, receive mixed reviews in terms of size and amenities. Many guests appreciate the cleanliness, comfortable beds and daily housekeeping service, although some rooms are noted for being small and having outdated facilities. The standard amenities, including a fridge, TV, microwave and air conditioning, sometimes face functionality issues. There’s a mix of responses regarding room decor with some describing it as basic or hostel-like. Noise issues and poor insulation further detract from the overall experience for some guests.

Cleanliness is another point where reviews vary. Many guests commend the hotel for its clean and well-maintained rooms, as well as friendly and helpful staff. Yet, some point out instances of less-than-perfect cleanliness, issues with some facilities and the occasional presence of bugs. The overall cleanliness is often praised, but there is room for improvement, especially regarding the thoroughness and consistency of the cleaning service.

On a positive note, the staff at
Hotel 27 by LuxUrban receives substantial acclaim. Guests often highlight the friendliness, professionalism and helpful nature of the reception team, contributing positively to the guest experience. The efforts of the staff to address concerns and provide excellent customer service are frequently acknowledged, enhancing the overall impression of the hotel.

The hotel's WiFi service, although free, receives mixed feedback with some guests experiencing connectivity issues or outages. Nevertheless, when functioning properly, the WiFi is considered adequate.

The beds are a strong point for the hotel, receiving numerous praises for their comfort. Guests often describe the mattresses as extremely comfortable, contributing to a restful atmosphere and enhancing the overall satisfaction of their stay.

As a three-star facility,
Hotel 27 by LuxUrban meets expectations for budget-conscious travelers seeking a central and affordable accommodation in New York City. It’s particularly ideal for short, no-frills stays with good value for money. While it may verge on the quality of a private hostel rather than a traditional hotel, its location and affordability make it a viable option for travelers looking to explore NYC without breaking the bank.
Categories
3 Star
Historic
Dog Friendly
Pod 39 main photo
Pod 39
7.4 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.4
Very Good
From $195
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Pod 39, situated in the heart of Manhattan, is highly praised for its prime location, making it an excellent base for exploring New York City's iconic landmarks. Guests appreciate its proximity to major attractions like Grand Central Station, Times Square and the Empire State Building. The neighborhood of Murray Hill offers a safe, quieter ambiance while still providing easy access to the bustling Midtown area. The presence of numerous restaurants, shops and public transport options nearby adds to its convenience. Additionally, the hotel’s amenities, such as a rooftop bar with spectacular views and cozy communal spaces, contribute positively to guests’ experiences.

Cleanliness is a standout feature at
Pod 39 with frequent commendations for the diligent housekeeping staff who ensure rooms are tidied daily and left spotless. This, combined with the hotel's modern and minimalistic decor, creates a fresh and contemporary atmosphere that guests find welcoming. The friendly and professional staff further enhance the experience by providing excellent customer service and attending to guests' needs promptly.

The rooms at
Pod 39, while extremely compact, are well-suited for solo travelers or short stays. Despite their small size, the rooms are functional, efficiently laid out and equipped with comfortable beds and necessary amenities. Cleanliness and daily maintenance are consistently mentioned as highlights. Some guests, however, noted occasional noise issues and wear in the decor. Nevertheless, the majority found the rooms to be a budget-friendly and well-maintained option.

Pod 39 offers a mixed breakfast and dining experience. The complimentary morning coffee and tea are well-received, though the breakfast options could benefit from more variety and healthier choices. Despite occasional closures and limited menus at the in-house restaurant, guests enjoy the rooftop bar’s ambiance and views, as well as the lively atmosphere of the ground floor café/bar. The surrounding neighborhood provides ample dining options, making it easy for guests to explore various cuisines nearby.

Wi-Fi experiences at
Pod 39 vary with some guests enjoying reliable and fast connections, while others report issues with slow and unstable service. Parking is another area with mixed feedback, as the hotel does not offer free parking and nearby options can be costly and limited. However, the midtown location allows easy access to metro stations, mitigating some parking concerns.

Nightlife around
Pod 39 is highlighted by its vibrant rooftop bar, which boasts stunning city views and creates a lively atmosphere for socializing. Guests also enjoy the cozy and fun common areas within the hotel, such as the basement and lobby bars and lounges equipped with ping pong and billiards tables.

Bed comfort is generally well-regarded with many guests praising the quality of the mattresses and pillows, contributing to a pleasant sleeping experience. Though some found the beds small or narrow for two people, the cleanliness and overall presentation were appreciated.

Overall,
Pod 39 stands out as a comfortable, mid-range hotel in a prime location, offering excellent value for money. Its blend of cleanliness, friendly staff, convenient amenities and strategic location makes it an appealing choice for travelers exploring New York City.
Categories
3 Star
Historic
Dog Friendly
SoHo Garden Hotel main photo
SoHo Garden Hotel
8.2 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
7.8
Good
From $61
$
Info
Categories
Historic
3 Star
Honeymoon
Lefferts Manor main photo
Lefferts Manor
12.9 km from East Rutherford
Bed & Breakfast in Brooklyn NYUS flag
8.0
Very Good
From $120
$
Info
Categories
Historic
3 Star
Free Wi-Fi
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-7 out of 7 hotels in and around East Rutherford
Save more on the App
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities
Historic, 3-Star Hotels, B&Bs in East Rutherford NJ