The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection

Dalkeith 55.89506400, -3.09641300 , The Melville Inn, (Show on Map)
8.8
Excellent


Please select your travel dates to see rates and availability
Check In
Check Out
1 room2 guests 1 room, 2 guests
Info
Summary of reviewsThe Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection is highly regarded for its strategic suburban location, providing easy access to Edinburgh via quick routes and efficient public transport, while offering a tranquil, scenic environment close to local amenities. The hotel’s modern and comfortably soundproofed accommodations are particularly suited for events, family visits and local attractions like Dalhousie Castle and Rosslyn Chapel, making it an excellent base for exploring the area.

One of the hotel’s standout features is its breakfast, frequently lauded for its excellence, variety, generous portions and accommodating staff. Guests enjoy a wide range of fresh, well-cooked options in a welcoming atmosphere. Though some suggest improvements in service speed and dining area brightness, the breakfast experience remains a significant highlight.

Dining at the adjacent Melville Inn is another point of praise. Guests appreciate the high-quality, flavorful food in a cozy and quiet restaurant setting. The staff’s friendliness and efficiency further enhance the dining experience. Although there are occasional logistical challenges, such as restricted hours and the need for reservations, the positive dining reviews emphasize the excellent food and inviting ambiance.

The rooms at The Melville Inn are consistently described as clean, modern and comfortable. Guests value the spaciousness and contemporary decor, while the well-maintained bathrooms and comfortable beds contribute to a restful stay. Despite minor issues like poor ventilation, the overwhelmingly positive feedback on room cleanliness and comfort reinforces the hotel’s appeal.

Cleanliness throughout the hotel is a strong point with guests frequently mentioning the spotless and well-maintained facilities. The hotel’s commitment to maintaining a high standard of hygiene contributes significantly to the pleasant atmosphere.

The staff at The Melville Inn receive high accolades for their friendliness, helpfulness and professionalism. Guests appreciate the warm welcome and attentive service from both the reception and restaurant teams, which considerably enhances the overall guest experience.

On the downside, Wi-Fi connectivity is an area needing improvement. Many guests report slow speeds, inconsistent connections and poor signal strength, which diminishes the convenience for those requiring reliable internet access.

The ample, free parking is another positive aspect with guests praising the ease and convenience of the spacious and readily available parking facilities.

For families, The Melville Inn is an excellent option. The spacious family rooms and attentive staff ensure a comfortable stay for guests of all ages. The hotel's proximity to local attractions and family-friendly amenities make it a preferred choice for family trips and gatherings.

Golf enthusiasts also favor the hotel for its proximity to various quality golf courses, offering excellent value and convenience for golf trips.

In summary, The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection excels in location, dining, cleanliness, staff service and family-friendly accommodations. While its Wi-Fi service needs enhancement, the overall experience remains highly positive, making it a recommended choice for visitors to Edinburgh and its surroundings.
Show more
Categories
Hotel with Parking
Located in Lasswade, this inn is well-known in the area. It is featured in this list of accommodations offering parking in Midlothian, ensuring ease of access for travellers with vehicles.

4-Star Hotel
This hotel features a connected pub and restaurant with a 24-hour front desk. The rooms are clean, spacious, and well-maintained, with smart TVs and comfortable beds. Guests appreciate the helpful staff, convenient parking, and excellent breakfast.

Hotel near Golf Courses

Family Friendly Hotel

Accessible Hotel

Room Types
Double or Twin Room - Disability Access The spacious twin/double room features air conditioning, a tea and coffee maker, as well as a private bathroom boasting a walk-in shower and a hairdryer. The twin/double room features a flat-screen TV, a wardrobe, a carpeted floor, as well as heating.

Family Room The family room features air conditioning, a tea and coffee maker, as well as a private bathroom boasting a walk-in shower and a hairdryer. The unit has 2 beds.

Double Room The double room provides air conditioning, a tea and coffee maker, as well as a private bathroom featuring a walk-in shower and a hairdryer. The unit offers 1 bed.

Standard Twin Room The twin room offers air conditioning, a tea and coffee maker, as well as a private bathroom featuring a walk-in shower and a hairdryer. The twin room features a flat-screen TV, a wardrobe, a carpeted floor and heating. The unit offers 2 beds.

Guest Reviews
8.8
Excellent
Location
The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection boasts an enviable suburban location, ideal for those looking to explore Edinburgh and its surrounding areas without the hustle and bustle of city life. This well-connected hotel offers quick and convenient access to Edinburgh, situated just off the A1 and close to the city bypass. Guests appreciate the regular bus services with bus stops conveniently located nearby, providing a straightforward 40-minute journey into the city center.

The hotel's setting is described as beautiful and tranquil, perfect for those who enjoy peace and quiet while remaining within easy reach of the city. For those traveling by car, there is ample free parking, making it an excellent base for exploring both Edinburgh and the Lothians. The proximity to local amenities such as pubs, restaurants and shops, as well as attractions like Dalkeith Country Park and Dobbies Garden Centre, enhance its appeal.

Additionally, the property is praised for its modern, clean and comfortable accommodations, which include soundproofed rooms ensuring a restful stay. Many visitors find the location ideal for attending events or visiting family in the area, notably for weddings at local venues like Dalhousie Castle and trips to Rosslyn Chapel.

Overall, the Melville Inn's strategic location, combined with its excellent transport links and tranquil setting, make it a highly convenient and pleasant choice for travelers visiting Edinburgh and beyond.

Breakfast
At The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection, guests frequently praise the breakfast as a highlight of their stay. Words like "excellent," "superb," "fantastic," and "top-class" are commonly used to describe the morning offerings. The majority of guests note the wide variety of options available with some specifically mentioning well-cooked fresh items like poached eggs on toast, porridge and traditional Scottish breakfast fare.

Positive feedback also highlights the good value for money, generous portion sizes and the accommodating and friendly staff who ensure a pleasant dining experience. The atmosphere in the adjacent inn where breakfast is served seems to be a source of satisfaction, contributing to an inviting and relaxed start to the day.

However, there are occasional comments suggesting room for improvement, such as the desire for brighter dining areas, more diverse breakfast options including continental choices and more timely service. Despite these few areas for enhancement, the overall consensus is that the breakfast experience at The Melville Inn significantly contributes to a rewarding stay, providing a delicious and hearty start to the day in a welcoming environment.

Dinner
The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection offers an impressive dining experience with consistently positive feedback from guests. The restaurant adjacent to the hotel is a key highlight, providing a superb and luxurious dining atmosphere. Guests often mention the excellent quality of food with many appreciating the wide range of well-prepared and flavorful options available for both dinner and breakfast. The value for money is commendable, making it a favorite spot for delicious meals.

The restaurant ambiance is described as cozy and quiet, contributing to a pleasant dining experience, while the staff receive high praise for their helpfulness and friendliness. Diners particularly enjoy the hearty pub meals and the delightful Sunday roast. Some noted that the food was not only well-presented and tasty but also hot and cooked to a high standard.

A few logistical hiccups such as restricted hours, occasional closures and the need for pre-booking during busy times were mentioned, but they do not overshadow the overwhelmingly positive dining experiences shared by guests. The Melville Inn's attached pub, described as lovely and homely, further enhances the overall dining appeal with its great food and drink selection, making it a highly recommended feature of the stay.

In summary, The Melville Inn provides a delightful dining experience with excellent food, warm ambiance and attentive staff, solidifying its reputation as a great place to enjoy both breakfast and dinner.

Rooms
At The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection, guests consistently highlight the exceptional quality and comfort of the rooms. The accommodations are described as very clean, modern and spacious with many reviewers appreciating the contemporary decor and comfortable furnishings. Guests find the rooms to be well-equipped, often mentioning the appealing decor, modern amenities and efficient layout that meets their needs for a pleasant stay.

The rooms are noted for their cleanliness, often being described as spotless, fresh and immaculately maintained. Many reviewers express satisfaction with the comfort provided by the beds and the overall coziness of the rooms, making it easy for them to relax and get a good night's sleep. Spaciousness is another frequently mentioned positive aspect with both standard and family rooms offering ample space.

Several guests mention the well-designed bathrooms, which are described as spacious, modern and equipped with quality amenities. Despite some comments about poor ventilation and windows that do not open, the overall consensus is that the rooms are quiet, providing a peaceful environment for rest.

The hotel's facilities extend to the well-decorated public areas and ample parking, further enhancing the convenience of the stay. With consistent reviews praising the high standard of cleanliness, modernity and comfort, The Melville Inn offers a welcoming and reliable accommodation option.

Beds
The beds at The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection have received mixed reviews, but many guests found them to be quite comfortable. Numerous guests mentioned that the beds were large and cozy, contributing to a good night's sleep. Several reviews specifically noted the beds as very firm, which may appeal to those who prefer more supportive mattresses. Rooms were frequently highlighted as spacious and modern with consistently clean and well-maintained bedding.

However, some visitors found the beds too firm, describing them as hard or even rock hard, which could be less ideal for those who prefer softer sleeping surfaces. Despite this, phrases like "comfortable bed" and "comfy bed" appeared often, indicating that many guests were satisfied with their sleep experience. The beds in family rooms and wider twin beds received positive mentions for comfort. Pillows were occasionally noted as a bit firm, but overall, the emphasis remained on the beds' comfort and cleanliness. For those who prefer a firmer mattress, the beds at The Melville Inn might be particularly suitable.

Cleanliness
The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection consistently impresses guests with its high standards of cleanliness. The hotel is frequently described as spotless, immaculate and exceptionally clean, which contributes to a pleasant and inviting atmosphere. Multiple reviews highlight the modern and well-maintained facilities with clean and spacious rooms that are tastefully decorated. Guests appreciate the cleanliness of both the rooms and the bathrooms, often noting the fresh and comfortable conditions. The air conditioning and cozy bedding add to the overall comfort.

While the majority of reviews sing praises about the cleanliness, a few mention minor lapses, such as missed spots in the bathrooms and occasional stains. However, these instances seem to be exceptions rather than the rule, as the overwhelming sentiment remains positive. The hotel’s commitment to cleanliness is evident through the numerous mentions of it being one of the cleanest hotels guests have experienced.

Overall, the well-maintained, modern decor paired with the scrupulous cleaning standards make The Melville Inn a commendable choice for travelers seeking comfort and hygiene in their accommodation.

Staff
The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection consistently receives high praise for its exceptional staff, who are described as incredibly friendly, helpful and welcoming. Guests frequently highlight the warm and professional nature of the reception team, making check-in a smooth and pleasant experience. The restaurant staff also receive commendations for their efficiency and attentiveness, ensuring that diners feel well-cared for.

The staff's ability to provide excellent customer service is evident throughout various interactions, whether it's accommodating special requests, offering helpful directions or simply making guests feel at home. Guests note that the team is knowledgeable, polite and always eager to assist, creating a positive and inviting atmosphere.

The personal touch added by the staff, such as remembering special occasions or offering thoughtful gestures, significantly enhances the guest experience. Overall, the staff at The Melville Inn are a standout feature of the hotel, leaving a lasting impression of friendliness, professionalism and genuine hospitality.

Wi-Fi
The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection presents a mixed bag when it comes to its Wi-Fi offerings. While a few guests found the Wi-Fi to be reliable, these instances appear to be rare, as the majority highlighted significant issues with connectivity. Many visitors reported extremely slow Internet speeds, inconsistent connections and difficulties accessing the network. For those needing a stable connection, these disruptions proved to be a major inconvenience.

Several reviews pointed out that the Wi-Fi signal was patchy throughout the hotel with some areas suffering from weak or even non-existent coverage. The situation was compounded by poor mobile phone signal reception in rooms, which left some guests unable to receive the required access codes for Wi-Fi.

Although the provided Internet service is free, it often dropped out, requiring guests to repeatedly log back in. This inconsistency led to frustration, especially for those who needed a dependable connection for work or personal use. Additionally, some guests noted privacy concerns when sharing personal details to log onto the network.

Overall, while the Wi-Fi can sometimes be reliable, many guests found it lacking. Improvements in both stability and speed would greatly enhance the stay for future visitors.

Parking
The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection provides guests with an abundance of parking options that consistently garner praise in guest reviews. Visitors commend the ample, spacious and free parking that the hotel offers with many mentioning the ease of accessing and using the car park. The large, onsite parking facilities allow guests to park close to the hotel’s entrance without any height restrictions. This convenience adds to the overall positive experience with plentiful, safe and easy parking contributing to the overall appeal of the hotel. Whether arriving early or late, guests can always find a suitable spot, thanks to the vast number of available spaces.

Family
The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection emerges as a top choice for families seeking a comfortable and convenient getaway. Its spacious and well-designed family rooms, each equipped with multiple beds and sofa beds, offer ideal accommodation for families of varying sizes. Warm, cozy and remarkably quiet, the rooms provide a perfect retreat after a day of exploring.

The staff consistently receive praise for their attentiveness to family guests, ensuring everyone feels welcome and well taken care of. Guests frequently highlight the hotel's suitability for family trips with its close proximity to family activities and spaces for children to play within the rooms. The location is notably convenient for those visiting Edinburgh, especially when traveling by car, making it an excellent base for family excursions.

Dining at The Melville Inn is satisfactory with options that cater to diverse dietary needs, including gluten-free choices. While there might be some initial confusion regarding dining arrangements, the quality of meals and variety on the menu more than compensate for this minor hiccup.

The hotel has proven to be particularly popular for family gatherings, weddings and reunions with multiple reviews emphasizing its role in making such events memorable and seamless. Though there isn't a wide array of specific activities for kids, parents find the environment relaxed and accommodating with ample space for children to play and enjoy themselves.

In summary, The Melville Inn is highly recommended for families seeking a spacious, comfortable and family-friendly hotel with excellent service and a location that enhances the overall travel experience.

Golf
The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection is frequently praised for its prime location, particularly by golf enthusiasts. The hotel offers good value for those planning to play at Musselburgh golf course and provides excellent access to several nearby golfing facilities. Guests find it perfect for golf trips, highlighting it as an ideal base due to the proximity to a number of quality golf courses. Its location makes it a suitable option for both golf-centered getaways and overnight stays for other events like the races. The combination of good value and convenient access to diverse golf courses makes this hotel a favorable choice for many visitors.

4 Star
The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection offers a stunning environment with gorgeous decor and luxurious bedding that truly provides a luxury feel. The rooms are not only spacious but also modern and stylishly decorated, creating a high-class atmosphere that rivals more expensive hotels. Reviews consistently highlight the amazing comfort and cleanliness of the accommodations with many guests experiencing superb service and excellent facilities.

Breakfast at The Melville Inn receives significant praise for its delicious offerings, adding to the overall positive experience. The hotel’s atmosphere is described as lovely with a friendly and pleasant environment that makes stays memorable. Guests appreciated the competitive pricing, noting the great value for money and comparing it favorably to other well-known budget hotel chains such as Premier Inn and Travelodge, but with significantly larger rooms.

Despite some minor issues like limited mobile signal inside the rooms and a desire for more storage drawers, the overall feedback is overwhelmingly positive. Many guests would highly recommend staying at The Melville Inn for its special ambiance and attention to detail, making it an ideal choice for travelers seeking comfort and style without breaking the bank.

Accessible
The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection appears to be a highly accessible hotel, receiving praise for its excellent facilities and thoughtful design to accommodate guests with disabilities. Guests consistently noted that the hotel features accessible rooms that are well-maintained and equipped with everything needed for those with mobility issues, including easily reachable wet rooms with walk-in showers and seats, raised toilets with easy-operate levers and sufficient space for wheelchair maneuverability.

The hotel also offers great disabled access throughout the property, including a large, free adjacent car park and convenient elevator services. It is highlighted for its easy access to local transport links with a bus stop nearby making it simple for guests to explore the surrounding area, including Edinburgh.

The hotel staff were attentive in meeting specific requests for accessible rooms; one guest mentioned their request for an accessible room for a family member on crutches was perfectly met. Additionally, the facilities for wheelchair access and the overall accessibility of the hotel are frequently described as second to none.

Amenities like the coffee and juice stations also received positive mentions for being easily accessible. There is a suggestion for the addition of a guest laundry room, which could enhance the stay for long-term visitors, but overall, guests found the accessibility features of the hotel to be very accommodating.

In summary, The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection is highly recommended for travelers with disabilities, offering a well-equipped, accessible and convenient stay.


No, The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection doesn't have any pool.

No, a spa isn't available at The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection.

No, The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection doesn't allow dogs.

Yes, parking facilities are available at The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection.

No, The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection doesn't have a gym.

Location Show Map
More Options
  • Inn in Dalkeith

  • 7.5 Good

  • From $117

  • Guest House in Dalkeith

  • 8.3 Very Good

  • From $87

  • Hotel in Bonnyrigg

  • 8.3 Very Good

  • From $222

  • Hotel in Penicuik

  • 9.1 Excellent

  • From $149



6,893,169

Hotels

60

Categories

49,805

Regions

209,065

Cities


×
×
Checkin
× Home About Press Categories Blog Hotel Awards Travelmyth GPT Contact Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Cookies Policy FAQ