Island Inn receives overwhelmingly positive reviews for its prime location, commendable accommodations, and excellent service. Its strategic position offers a harmonious balance of accessibility and tranquility, being close to Oak Bluffs and within walking distance of a beach and dining options. Guests appreciate this perfect blend of a central location with a peaceful setting, enhanced by the hotel's easy access to public transport and ample parking, making it an ideal spot for both exploration and relaxation.
The accommodations at Island Inn are consistently praised for their spaciousness, cleanliness, and the attention to detail evident in recent renovations. Families find the efficiency-style layout convenient, and the rooms are equipped with appliances that cater to dining in. Although some guests suggest further renovations could be beneficial, the current state of the rooms has impressed many, making the inn a preferred choice for those prioritizing cleanliness, space, and location.
Cleanliness is a standout feature, with guests lauding the meticulously maintained grounds and immaculate rooms. The pool area, although noted for needing more frequent cleaning, maintains a clean and inviting environment that adds to the overall appeal. The hotel's commitment to comfort, punctuated by amenities like tennis courts and well-stocked kitchens, ensures excellent value for money.
The staff at Island Inn enhances the guest experience significantly, with their friendliness and helpfulness consistently noted. Effective communication and an accommodating nature make them a fundamental part of making the inn feel like an ideal getaway. Specific mention of exceptional service by team members such as Kristen underscores the warmth and attention provided by the staff.
The pool area remains a delightful feature, offering a pleasant space for relaxation and enjoyment. Despite a few guests desiring a larger pool, its well-maintained setting, along with communal fire pits and surrounding gardens, creates an amiable atmosphere suitable for families seeking fun and relaxation.
While the beds at Island Inn receive mixed reviews, with many guests finding them comfortable, there is some room for improvement regarding bed size and support. Despite these points of improvement, the overall consensus is that Island Inn provides a welcoming, clean, and enjoyable stay with ample amenities and thoughtful service.
Harbor View Hotel is a luxurious and centrally located hotel in Edgartown on Martha's Vineyard, making it a perfect spot for tourists. The hotel's proximity to shopping and restaurants is much appreciated by visitors, as everything is within walking distance. Guests are in for a treat when it comes to breakfast and dinner with the restaurant offering a variety of upscale dishes that are exceptional in taste. The staff at Harbor View Hotel are some of the best in the industry with guests repeatedly praising their friendliness, professionalism and outstanding customer service. The hotel boasts a lovely saltwater heated pool surrounded by fire pits that add a cozy ambiance at night. Despite some minor setbacks with the rooms, most guests had a good experience with clean, comfortable and spacious rooms. Overall, guests recommend the Harbor View Hotel for a luxurious and enjoyable stay.