Hotels, Apartments, Motels, Vacation Homes in Central Islip NY

Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex

Hotel in Central Islip NY

8.9

Excellent

From $173

$

Info Categories

Hotel with Parking

EV charging stations

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Indoor Pool

Hotel for Honeymoon

Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex

Hotel in Central Islip NY

8.3

Very Good

From $171

$

Info Summary of reviewsThe Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex is a favored choice among travelers, primarily due to its excellent location in the heart of Long Island. Guests laud the hotel's accessibility to the north shore and charming southern beaches, making it an ideal base for those exploring local attractions. The property provides a clean and welcoming atmosphere, complemented by comfortable indoor and outdoor seating that enhances relaxation. Spacious rooms, equipped with modern amenities, contribute to the hotel's appeal while maintaining a standard of cleanliness that most guests appreciate.

Though the breakfast experience presents mixed feedback, the overall quality is noted positively by some guests. However, there is some confusion regarding the breakfast policy that could be mitigated with improved communication about pricing and inclusion. The rooms are particularly praised for their comfort, cleanliness, and spacious design, featuring cozy beds and modern bathrooms that surpass typical hotel offerings. The professional staff demeanor adds to this positive experience.

Moreover, the hotel's staff consistently impress guests with their exceptional service. Known for their friendliness and efficiency, they play a key role in making visitors feel welcome and attended to during their stay. The combination of a prime location, clean environment, and outstanding staff service makes the Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex a recommended choice for travelers seeking comfortable accommodation with ease of access to Long Island's diverse attractions.
Show more Categories

Hotel with Parking

Hotel Taking Steps Towards Sustainability

3-Star Hotel

Dreamstay guest house

Apartment in Central Islip NY

$

Info Categories

Dog Friendly Apartment

Apartment with Free Wi-Fi

Apartment with Parking

Exceptional 2BR - Immaculate, Top Amenities & Care!

Apartment in Central Islip NY

9.5

Excellent

$

Info Categories

Apartment with Free Wi-Fi

Apartment with Parking

Exceptional 2BR Immaculate, Top Amenities and Care!

Apartment in Central Islip NY

$

Info Categories

Dog Friendly Apartment

Apartment with Free Wi-Fi

Apartment with Parking

195 more hotels nearby!

Newly Renovated One Bedroom Apartment with Backyard and Fire Pit 1.0 km from Central Islip

Apartment in Islip Terrace NY

$

Info Categories

Apartment with Parking

New York Abode with Pool and Patio, Near Times Square! 1.7 km from Central Islip

Apartment in Islip Terrace NY

$

Info Categories

Apartment with Swimming Pool

Private Pool

Bedroom 2.0 km from Central Islip

Apartment in Brentwood NY

10

Excellent

$

Info Categories

Dog Friendly Apartment

MacArthur House 2.8 km from Central Islip

Apartment in Hauppauge NY

10

Excellent

$

Info Categories

Apartment with Free Wi-Fi

Apartment with Parking

Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia 3.0 km from Central Islip

Hotel in Islandia NY

8.2

Very Good

From $146

$

Info Summary of reviewsThe Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia garners widespread praise, making it a favored choice for many travelers. Its prime location is frequently highlighted for convenience, being near amenities such as restaurants, gas stations and entertainment venues like Dave & Buster's. Additionally, its proximity to major highways like the Long Island Expressway and Route 495 makes it exceptionally accessible for those visiting local universities or exploring the area.

Guests compliment the hotel's breakfast, describing it as high-quality and varied, often outshining other comparable hotels. Terms like "awesome” and “plentiful” are commonly used, although occasional remarks suggest room for improvement in selection and presentation. Clean amenities, such as the pool and gym, further enhance the dining experience.

Accommodations at the hotel are considered both spacious and reasonably priced with cleanliness being a prominent theme. Reviews consistently note the rooms and bathrooms as clean and well-maintained. The hotel itself also receives commendations for its overall cleanliness and thoughtful design, despite some mentions of minor issues like stained carpets or occasional appliance malfunctions.

The staff at Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia stands out for their friendliness and helpfulness with numerous guests pointing out their exceptional service. Standout mentions like front desk attendant Bobby underscore the positive impact of the staff on guests’ experiences.

The pool area receives favorable remarks for its cleanliness and upkeep, though its small size and occasional closures are noted. Similarly, beds at the hotel are often described as comfortable, though a few guests have reported inconsistencies with bed sizes and pillow quality.

Overall, the Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia offers a generally positive experience, marked by a convenient location, commendable breakfast, clean facilities and a friendly, attentive staff.
Show more Categories

Hotel Taking Steps Towards Sustainability

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Indoor Pool

Accessible Hotel

Luxury mini mansion 3.1 km from Central Islip

Villas in East Islip NY

10

Excellent

$

Info Categories

Dog Friendly Villas

Villas with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool

Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island 3.2 km from Central Islip

Hotel in Bay Shore NY

$

Info Categories

Hotel with Free Wi-Fi

Hotel with Parking

Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island 3.2 km from Central Islip

Motel in Bay Shore NY

5.0

Rated

From $128

$

Info Categories

Motel with Rooms With Jacuzzi / Hot-tub

Cozy Nesting 3.2 km from Central Islip

Homestay in Bay Shore NY

9.6

Excellent

$

Info Categories

Homestay with Free Wi-Fi

Homestay with Parking

Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island by IHG 3.2 km from Central Islip

Hotel in Hauppauge NY

8.0

Very Good

From $141

$

Info Summary of reviewsThe Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island by IHG is favorably regarded by guests for its strategic location, particularly appealing to both leisure and business travelers. Situated in the heart of Long Island and in close proximity to major highways like the Long Island Expressway, it offers convenient access to local attractions and nearby business engagements. The ease of travel and spacious, secure parking enhance the guest experience, making it an ideal retreat in central Long Island.

Guests consistently commend the hotel for its breakfast offerings, which feature a broad array of options from traditional favorites to choices catering to different dietary needs. The breakfast experience is enriched by the friendly and courteous staff, contributing to a pleasant start to the day.

The rooms receive positive feedback for their cleanliness, modern decor following recent renovations, and generous size, which includes amenities such as a coffeemaker, fridge, and microwave. The beds are especially noted for their comfort, with guests appreciating the selection of soft and firm pillows. Although some isolated issues with cleanliness have been reported, these are exceptions. The attentive customer service further elevates the stay, as guests encounter a helpful and professional team dedicated to accommodating their needs.

Cleanliness is a strong point of the hotel, with both rooms and common areas being well-maintained, creating a cozy atmosphere. The hotel ensures a tranquil environment at night, and despite some minor maintenance issues, the overall impression remains positive.

The friendly and welcoming staff is frequently highlighted, with guests often mentioning the excellent service provided by individuals such as Otilia. Their positive interactions contribute significantly to the overall pleasant environment of the hotel.

Families particularly enjoy the indoor pool, which is clean, well-maintained, and kid-friendly, providing a great opportunity for children to have fun. Despite some feedback on water temperature, the pool remains a positive aspect and complements the overall guest experience.

In summary, the Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island by IHG provides a reliable and restful stay with its strategic location, comprehensive breakfast offerings, comfortable and clean rooms, and exceptionally friendly staff, ensuring a welcoming environment for all guests.
Show more Categories

Hotel near Golf Courses

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool Indoor Pool

Hotel with Gym

Rodeway Inn MacArthur Airport 3.4 km from Central Islip

Motel in Ronkonkoma NY

6.5

Rated

From $113

$

Info Summary of reviewsThe Rodeway Inn MacArthur Airport is well-regarded for its strategic location, particularly convenient for travelers due to its proximity to the MacArthur/Islip Airport and key amenities like gas stations and restaurants. Many guests appreciate the tranquil setting and the hotel’s combination of reasonable pricing and cleanliness, which contributes to good value for money.

Guests consistently applaud the staff for their friendliness and helpful service, highlighting a seamless check-in and check-out experience. The employees are described as polite and professional, enhancing overall guest satisfaction despite the hotel’s older infrastructure.

The rooms receive positive remarks for their cleanliness and spaciousness. Many guests appreciate the comfortable beds and well-maintained bathrooms, though some mention issues with smoke odors, noise, and room size. Cleanliness is generally a strong point, although some areas like carpets could benefit from attention.

While the absence of a breakfast offering is noted, impacting convenience for some, the overall experience at Rodeway Inn MacArthur Airport is described positively, with attentive service and a practical, accessible location contributing to a generally pleasant stay.
Show more Categories

Motel with Parking

Jake's 58 Casino Hotel - Adults Only 3.5 km from Central Islip

Hotel in Islandia NY

8.0

Very Good

From $174

$

Info Summary of reviewsJake's 58 Casino Hotel - Adults Only is highly commended for its prime location, offering convenient access to major highways and nearby attractions, such as local businesses, restaurants and stores. Guests appreciate the ease of check-in and check-out processes, combined with clean and comfortable rooms, creating a peaceful and satisfactory stay. The hotel's friendly staff further enhances the guest experience with their professionalism and helpfulness.

Despite the excellent service and location, the breakfast options at the hotel receive criticism for their limited offerings and the absence of a complimentary or buffet breakfast. Dinner services are slightly more favorable with praises for the delicious meals and quick service at the on-site restaurant and bistro, although some guests find certain dishes overpriced and of mediocre quality.

Rooms at Jake's 58 Casino Hotel are generally described as clean and spacious with comfortable beds contributing to restful stays. However, some guests believe the rooms are dated, citing structural issues and a need for renovations. Smoking smells and thin walls were also minor negative points, but overall cleanliness and friendly staff were consistent positives.

The hotel's commitment to cleanliness extends to its casino and dining areas, contributing to an inviting atmosphere. Even so, there are occasional reports of minor maintenance issues and outdated decor which could benefit from upgrades.

Staff at Jake's 58 receive glowing reviews for their courteous and professional demeanor, making the check-in process smooth and enhancing overall guest satisfaction. While most interactions are positive, a few instances of perceived rudeness were noted.

In terms of comfort, guest experiences with the beds vary with some finding them cozy and others describing them as too soft, saggy or worn out. The accessibility of the hotel is good, though improvements in parking and elevator efficiency could further benefit those with mobility issues.

The casino at Jake's 58 is a highlight for many, providing entertainment with electronic games and maintaining a clean and well-kept environment. However, it can become crowded and the slow elevators may be a minor inconvenience.

Overall, Jake's 58 Casino Hotel - Adults Only is known for its outstanding location, professional staff and clean environment, though there are areas for improvement, particularly in breakfast offerings and room upgrades.
Show more Categories

Hotel near Golf Courses

Casino Hotel

Accessible Hotel

Hyatt Regency Long Island 3.6 km from Central Islip

Hotel in Hauppauge NY

7.8

Good

From $175

$

Info Summary of reviewsThe Hyatt Regency Long Island consistently earns praise for its strategic and convenient location, which offers visitors a peaceful, accessible base from which to explore the broader region. Guests particularly appreciate the hotel's beautiful views, easy access to local amenities, and well-maintained facilities, such as ample parking and clean, inviting spaces.

Breakfast at the hotel is widely appreciated for its variety and quality, featuring a buffet spread that includes pastries, fruits, cheeses, and more. Despite some comments on the high cost, the offering is generally well-received, with friendly staff enhancing the dining experience.

The spacious, well-appointed rooms are highlighted for their cleanliness and comfort, with guests expressing satisfaction over the inviting atmosphere and the superb service from housekeeping staff. Beds receive special acclaim for their comfort, although some minor updates to the rooms could improve guest experiences further.

The hotel staff, from front desk to cleaning personnel, are celebrated for their exceptional service and professionalism, with particular mentions of individuals going above and beyond to ensure a smooth and welcoming stay. This high level of customer service significantly contributes to the hotel's positive reputation.

The pool facilities at Hyatt Regency Long Island add to the appeal, offering a relaxing and enjoyable experience with both indoor and outdoor options. The pools are particularly noted for their pleasant conditions and ambiance, making them a favorite feature among visitors, including families with children.

Families visiting the hotel find it accommodating and friendly, highlighting its suitability for trips with children due to its welcoming atmosphere and convenient amenities. Despite some room configuration challenges for larger families, the hotel's responsiveness to requests, like extra beds, enhances its family-oriented appeal.

Overall, the Hyatt Regency Long Island provides a memorable and satisfying experience with its combination of strategic location, excellent service, comfortable accommodations, and appealing amenities.
Show more Categories

Hotel near Golf Courses

Family Friendly Hotel

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool Indoor Pool

Bay Shore Vacation Rental with Shared Yard! 3.7 km from Central Islip

Apartment in Bay Shore NY

10

Excellent

$

Info Categories

3-Star Apartment

Bay Shore Vacation Rental about 7 Mi to the Beach 3.7 km from Central Islip

Vacation Home in Bay Shore NY

9.0

Excellent

$

Info Categories

3-Star Vacation Home

Hotels in Central Islip NY