Pine Inn - Carmel
➔
➔
Please select your travel dates to see rates and availability
Info
Summary of reviewsPine Inn - Carmel, nestled in the heart of downtown Carmel, impresses with its unbeatable location. Situated on Ocean Avenue, guests can easily stroll to a plethora of nearby attractions including shops, restaurants, art galleries and wine tasting rooms. With the beach just a short walk away, its central location allows visitors to enjoy the scenic surroundings and the vibrant cultural scene without the need for transportation. Views from ocean-view rooms and the hotel’s historic charm further enhance its appeal, making Pine Inn a memorable part of the Carmel experience.
The breakfast experience at Pine Inn is generally well-received. Guests often rave about the excellent offerings at the on-site Il Fornaio restaurant, noting the fresh, tasty and well-presented meals. Especially praised are the weekday breakfasts that provide a satisfying start to the day when included in the room rate. However, the breakfast inclusion varies with the booking method, leading to some inconsistency and confusion among guests. Despite this, Il Fornaio is appreciated for both breakfast and dinner with guests enjoying the high-quality Italian fare and the convenience of dining on-site.
The rooms at Pine Inn are a blend of old-world charm and modern comfort. Many guests appreciate the beautiful furniture, art decor and spaciousness of certain rooms, often highlighting the cleanliness and well-maintained condition. Select ocean-view rooms offer picturesque vistas that make the stay even more special. However, the experience can be inconsistent with some rooms being described as small, cramped and outdated. The absence of certain modern conveniences such as air conditioning, microwaves or sufficient outlets, along with occasional noise disturbances, can detract from the overall comfort.
Cleanliness receives a mixed response, though many guests praise the hotel for its clean, fresh rooms and well-maintained facilities. However, specific issues like dirty floors, mold in bathrooms and stained carpets were pointed out by some guests, indicating areas needing improvement.
The staff at Pine Inn garner high praise for their friendly, helpful and accommodating nature. Guests frequently laud the team for their professionalism and welcoming attitude with many appreciating the personalized care and attention provided. Although there are occasional reports of inconsistency in service, the general sentiment is overwhelmingly positive.
Wi-Fi connectivity is a notable area of concern with many guests reporting slow speeds and intermittent connections. This aspect could make it difficult for visitors needing reliable internet access during their stay.
Parking at Pine Inn can be a challenge due to limited spaces in the on-property lot. While some guests appreciate the free parking, the insufficient availability often forces them to find alternative solutions on nearby streets or at a sister hotel.
For families, Pine Inn offers a charming and conveniently located option in Carmel, though it seems better suited for adults. The serene atmosphere and historic charm make it more appealing to those seeking a vintage aesthetic and a quieter experience.
The beds at Pine Inn generally receive positive feedback for their comfort, size and clean linens, though some guests have noted issues with bed stability, placement and bedding freshness.
Altogether, Pine Inn - Carmel offers an intriguing blend of historic charm and central convenience, making it a unique accommodation choice. While it excels in location, dining and staff friendliness, areas like room consistency, cleanliness, Wi-Fi and parking could benefit from some enhancements to fully align with the hotel's charm and historic character.
Categories
The breakfast experience at Pine Inn is generally well-received. Guests often rave about the excellent offerings at the on-site Il Fornaio restaurant, noting the fresh, tasty and well-presented meals. Especially praised are the weekday breakfasts that provide a satisfying start to the day when included in the room rate. However, the breakfast inclusion varies with the booking method, leading to some inconsistency and confusion among guests. Despite this, Il Fornaio is appreciated for both breakfast and dinner with guests enjoying the high-quality Italian fare and the convenience of dining on-site.
The rooms at Pine Inn are a blend of old-world charm and modern comfort. Many guests appreciate the beautiful furniture, art decor and spaciousness of certain rooms, often highlighting the cleanliness and well-maintained condition. Select ocean-view rooms offer picturesque vistas that make the stay even more special. However, the experience can be inconsistent with some rooms being described as small, cramped and outdated. The absence of certain modern conveniences such as air conditioning, microwaves or sufficient outlets, along with occasional noise disturbances, can detract from the overall comfort.
Cleanliness receives a mixed response, though many guests praise the hotel for its clean, fresh rooms and well-maintained facilities. However, specific issues like dirty floors, mold in bathrooms and stained carpets were pointed out by some guests, indicating areas needing improvement.
The staff at Pine Inn garner high praise for their friendly, helpful and accommodating nature. Guests frequently laud the team for their professionalism and welcoming attitude with many appreciating the personalized care and attention provided. Although there are occasional reports of inconsistency in service, the general sentiment is overwhelmingly positive.
Wi-Fi connectivity is a notable area of concern with many guests reporting slow speeds and intermittent connections. This aspect could make it difficult for visitors needing reliable internet access during their stay.
Parking at Pine Inn can be a challenge due to limited spaces in the on-property lot. While some guests appreciate the free parking, the insufficient availability often forces them to find alternative solutions on nearby streets or at a sister hotel.
For families, Pine Inn offers a charming and conveniently located option in Carmel, though it seems better suited for adults. The serene atmosphere and historic charm make it more appealing to those seeking a vintage aesthetic and a quieter experience.
The beds at Pine Inn generally receive positive feedback for their comfort, size and clean linens, though some guests have noted issues with bed stability, placement and bedding freshness.
Altogether, Pine Inn - Carmel offers an intriguing blend of historic charm and central convenience, making it a unique accommodation choice. While it excels in location, dining and staff friendliness, areas like room consistency, cleanliness, Wi-Fi and parking could benefit from some enhancements to fully align with the hotel's charm and historic character.
Hotel near Golf Courses
Located in Carmel, this hotel is near various golf courses in the area, including those in Carmel Valley and Pebble Beach. Its central location provides easy access to golfing and other attractions.
Hotel near Nightlife Spots
The Pine Inn features Il Fornaio, home to Carmel's longest bar, offering great deals on cocktails, wines, and gourmet snacks during happy hour.
Hotel with Parking
The hotel provides free parking for its guests.
EV charging stations
Accessible Hotel
The Pine Inn provides ADA-compliant parking and ramps, accessible routes throughout public areas and guest rooms, and low-profile check-in desks and restaurant seating. ADA-compliant public restrooms include grab bars and knee/toe clearance. Accessible guest rooms feature grab bars, roll-in showers, accessible sinks, and 32-inch door widths. Visual and audible alarms, lighting for hearing-impaired guests (phone, doorbell, alarms), and Braille signage are available. An ADA-accessible room with two queen beds is designed with space for a standard portable hoist or Hoyer lift.
3-Star Hotel
Pine Inn - Carmel provides budget options. The hotel offers a charming and historically rich stay, best suited for visitors who value character and tradition.
Hotel with EV Charging Stations
Hotel for Honeymoon
Family Friendly Hotel
Business Hotel
Guest Reviews
Pine Inn in Carmel boasts a prime location, situated conveniently in the heart of downtown Carmel. Guests consistently praise its proximity to a variety of attractions, including numerous shops, restaurants, art galleries and wine tasting rooms. With the beach just a short walk away, the location makes it easy for visitors to explore the scenic surroundings and enjoy the town's vibrant cultural scene.
The hotel is centrally located, right on Ocean Avenue, making it an ideal spot for those looking to stroll around the town without the need for transportation. This accessibility has been a significant factor for many visitors, who appreciate being able to walk to dinner every night and the convenience of having everything—including the beach—within a few blocks from their accommodation. The views from ocean-view rooms and the hotel’s historic charm add to its appeal, making it not just a place to stay, but a part of the Carmel experience.
Overall, the Pine Inn offers a great location for anyone interested in fully experiencing the best of Carmel by the sea. Whether it’s for a short stay or an extended vacation, visitors appreciate the combination of comfort, historical ambiance and unbeatable accessibility to all Carmel has to offer.
Pine Inn - Carmel, an inviting and cozy hotel, offers a mixed experience when it comes to breakfast. Guests frequently highlight the excellent breakfasts served at Il Fornaio, often describing it as fresh, tasty and well-presented with options like scrambled eggs, potatoes and crispy bacon. Many appreciated the generous and satisfying morning meals, especially when they were included in the room rate.
However, breakfast inclusions vary depending on the booking method, leading to some confusion. Those who book directly through the hotel typically enjoy complimentary breakfasts, while third-party bookings might miss out on this perk. The breakfast situation is further complicated by policies excluding complimentary breakfast on weekends and certain guests not receiving vouchers.
Despite these inconsistencies, weekday breakfasts are often praised and enjoyed in a charming dining setting. The unique breakfast service adds to the overall experience, although it’s noted that the offering is relatively limited at times with some guests expressing that it could be improved to match the hotel’s pricing.
Overall, Pine Inn provides a notable breakfast experience that delights many, especially on weekdays, but requires some attention to meet the expectations of all guests equally.
Pine Inn - Carmel offers a convenient dining experience with the on-site Il Fornaio restaurant widely praised by guests. The presence of Il Fornaio is considered a significant bonus, providing both excellent breakfast and dinner options. Many reviewers have highlighted the superb quality of the food, emphasizing the great Italian dishes available. The restaurant is also noted for its convenience, especially appreciated on late arrivals. Guests enjoy the added benefit of having a high-quality dining venue so close, making meals an easy and pleasant part of their stay. Despite some negative experiences, the overall sentiment towards the restaurant is very positive with frequent compliments on the delicious meals and the advantage of not having to travel far for fine dining.
Nestled in the charming town of Carmel, Pine Inn offers a variety of room experiences that travelers have noted for their distinct blend of old-world charm and modern comfort. Guests have complimented the beautiful furniture and art decor that exude an old charm, making the rooms cozy and charming. Cleanliness is a recurring theme with many reviewers praising the rooms for being clean, fresh and well-maintained.
The spaciousness of some rooms received positive remarks with several guests enjoying large, comfortable spaces complete with modern amenities and even jetted tubs. Ocean views from select rooms have also been a highlight, offering picturesque vistas that enhance the stay.
However, it's crucial to note that not all rooms offer the same level of comfort. Many rooms are reported to be quite small with some even described as tiny, cramped and dark. These smaller rooms can feel cluttered with limited space for luggage or personal items. The older building means some rooms lack modern conveniences such as air conditioning, microwaves, coffee makers or sufficient outlets.
Various rooms have been described as dated with worn carpets, old-fashioned bathrooms and tired furniture that reflect the historic nature of the property but may not meet everyone’s standards. Noise can also be an issue with some rooms experiencing disturbances from street noise, exhaust fans or even internal heating systems.
Despite the varied feedback on room conditions and amenities, the overall charm and cleanliness, along with some spectacular views, make Pine Inn a rather unique and nostalgic accommodation choice in Carmel. Whether you’re captivated by its historical ambiance or seeking a comfortable, clean room with a view, Pine Inn offers a memorable stay with a mix of pros and cons that reflect its classic character.
Visitors to Pine Inn in Carmel frequently highlight the comfort of the beds, describing them as comfortable, comfy and in many cases, super comfortable. Guests have positive feedback about the beds' large size, clean linens and luxury sheets and some reviews even mentioned the beds being outstanding or superb. Generally, the mattresses received good reviews for their comfort with people noting that the beds were very plush, supportive and conducive to a good night's sleep.
However, some guests had issues with the size and stability of the beds. A few found the beds to be too small, especially for double rooms or for two people. There were also mentions of beds being soft to the point of discomfort, unstable or creaky. Some guests thought the beds were placed in inconvenient positions, like up against the wall or were too tall, requiring step stools to access. Additionally, there were concerns about musty-smelling or uncomfortable bedding that affected the overall experience.
In summary, while the beds at Pine Inn in Carmel are often praised for their comfort and size, some aspects regarding their stability, placement and the freshness of the bedding may need attention.
Pine Inn in Carmel has a mixed record when it comes to cleanliness as indicated by guest reviews. Many guests were pleased with the standard of cleanliness in the rooms with descriptors such as clean, fresh, comfortable and functional being frequently used. High standards of cleanliness were noted and the facilities, including hallways and bathrooms, generally received positive remarks for being well-kept and well-maintained.
However, several guests pointed out areas needing attention. Issues like dirty and unsanitary flooring, mold in bathrooms, dusty rooms and stained carpets were mentioned. Some guests encountered specific cleanliness problems, such as hair in the bathtub, rusted bathroom fixtures and even a dried-up tampon under the bed, highlighting a lack of thorough cleaning in certain instances.
In summary, while many reviews commend the Pine Inn for its clean and comfortable rooms, there is a consistent note of areas that require improvement, particularly in maintaining cleanliness standards throughout the hotel.
Pine Inn - Carmel boasts an impressively high level of guest satisfaction when it comes to its staff. The majority of the reviews highlight the wonderful, helpful and accommodating nature of the team. Guests often describe the staff as efficient, professional and exceptionally friendly, contributing significantly to a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Many guests mention the friendliness and responsiveness of the front desk and bell staff with several recognizing them for their courteous and attentive service.
The personalized care and exceptional professionalism provided by the staff are notable and many found the team's attitude to be both warm and welcoming. The concierge and front desk attendants, including standouts like Margarita, are frequently praised for going above and beyond in their roles. Phrases like "treated us like family" and "helped with our luggage" indicate a staff willing to assist guests with various needs.
However, it's worth noting that there are occasional mentions of inconsistencies. While a vast majority experienced exemplary service, there were a few isolated incidents where staff behavior did not meet guests’ expectations with terms such as "rude" and "unwelcoming" occasionally cropping up. Despite these few negative remarks, the overall sentiment points towards a dedicated and friendly team committed to enhancing the guest experience.
The Wi-Fi at Pine Inn - Carmel has been a consistent point of concern for guests. Many have reported issues ranging from very slow speeds to complete unavailability. The Wi-Fi signal in the rooms has been described as spotty and intermittent with some experiencing a total disconnect during their stay. While a few noted that the connection issues were resolved by the last day, others had to resort to using their phone hotspots to access the internet. Therefore, guests might face inconvenience if they require a reliable internet connection during their visit.
At Pine Inn - Carmel, parking emerges as a recurring topic among guests. Despite the convenience of having an on-property parking lot, the number of spaces is often described as inadequate for the volume of guests. Many reviews note that this limited parking situation can be challenging and arriving early is recommended to secure a spot.
The parking lot is not only oversubscribed but also operates on a first-come, first-served basis, leading to instances where guests were forced to seek alternative parking on nearby streets or at a sister hotel. While some guests appreciated the free parking offered, the benefit is offset by the difficulty of finding available spaces.
A few reviews mention the stress and complexity of the parking situation, suggesting that the hotel needs more spaces or a better system, possibly involving a reservation or payment for guaranteed spots. Despite this, some found occasional available spots and appreciated the complimentary parking inclusion. For those unable to park on-site, street parking becomes the necessary alternative, though it can add to the overall inconvenience.
Pine Inn - Carmel offers a unique blend of old-world charm and convenience, making it a standout destination in Carmel. The hotel's proximity to the beach, shops and various dining options provides ample opportunities for leisurely strolls and exploration, perfect for families looking to spend quality time together. Despite these advantages, the hotel appears to be more suitable for adults rather than children.
A few reviews highlighted that the Pine Inn might not be the best fit for young kids. Activity and noise from children were noted, which could disrupt the serene atmosphere that the hotel aims to provide. The accommodations are considered small, potentially limiting space for large families. Additionally, hot light bulbs present a safety concern for younger guests.
The historic nature and charm of Pine Inn appeal greatly to those appreciating vintage aesthetics and handicapped-friendly facilities, making it an excellent choice for business travelers and adults celebrating special occasions. So, while Pine Inn stands out for its location, charm and special accommodations, it appears better suited to adult guests rather than catering extensively to young children.
Pine Inn - Carmel presents a delightful blend of charming Victorian-style architecture and historical significance, appealing particularly to those who appreciate traditional, old-fashioned decor and quirky touches. Guests have praised its charm and wonderful ambiance, fitting well with its high standard of maintenance despite its age.
However, the hotel seems to struggle with certain modern amenities and infrastructure. Recurring issues such as problematic showers, plumbing concerns and nightly noise disturbances have been noted. Additionally, the absence of in-room tea or coffee facilities and the lack of an elevator are frequently mentioned shortcomings.
The hotel is rated a three-star experience, aligning with the mixed assessments ranging from average stays to more enthusiastic reviews praising its distinctive style. Some guests believe that the place could benefit from renovations to elevate its overall appeal. Check-in flexibility is another area highlighted with some dissatisfaction around the timing.
In summary, Pine Inn - Carmel offers a quaint and historically rich stay, best suited for visitors who value character and tradition over modern conveniences.
Pine Inn - Carmel offers mixed experiences for business travelers. Noteworthy is the professional and helpful staff that assists with smooth check-ins and other logistical needs. The hotel is quite suitable for business stays with the Wi-Fi described as usable, although some guests encountered issues with spotty connections. Despite the absence of room service and an elevator, the establishment manages to support business meetings effectively, providing a conducive environment for such events. The nice breakfast is an added bonus that can help start the workday on a good note. Overall, Pine Inn - Carmel presents a reasonable choice for business travelers with a few areas that could use improvement.
Pine Inn - Carmel presents challenges for guests with disabilities due to the lack of an elevator, making upper floors difficult to access. Stairs are steep and can be exhausting and no handrails are provided for added support. Additionally, there is insufficient lighting in the bathrooms and no handicapped bars, further complicating accessibility. Overall, the hotel is not recommended for those with physical limitations, as the accommodations do not cater well to guests needing mobility assistance.
Location Show Map
Location
The hotel is centrally located, right on Ocean Avenue, making it an ideal spot for those looking to stroll around the town without the need for transportation. This accessibility has been a significant factor for many visitors, who appreciate being able to walk to dinner every night and the convenience of having everything—including the beach—within a few blocks from their accommodation. The views from ocean-view rooms and the hotel’s historic charm add to its appeal, making it not just a place to stay, but a part of the Carmel experience.
Overall, the Pine Inn offers a great location for anyone interested in fully experiencing the best of Carmel by the sea. Whether it’s for a short stay or an extended vacation, visitors appreciate the combination of comfort, historical ambiance and unbeatable accessibility to all Carmel has to offer.
Breakfast
However, breakfast inclusions vary depending on the booking method, leading to some confusion. Those who book directly through the hotel typically enjoy complimentary breakfasts, while third-party bookings might miss out on this perk. The breakfast situation is further complicated by policies excluding complimentary breakfast on weekends and certain guests not receiving vouchers.
Despite these inconsistencies, weekday breakfasts are often praised and enjoyed in a charming dining setting. The unique breakfast service adds to the overall experience, although it’s noted that the offering is relatively limited at times with some guests expressing that it could be improved to match the hotel’s pricing.
Overall, Pine Inn provides a notable breakfast experience that delights many, especially on weekdays, but requires some attention to meet the expectations of all guests equally.
Dinner
Rooms
The spaciousness of some rooms received positive remarks with several guests enjoying large, comfortable spaces complete with modern amenities and even jetted tubs. Ocean views from select rooms have also been a highlight, offering picturesque vistas that enhance the stay.
However, it's crucial to note that not all rooms offer the same level of comfort. Many rooms are reported to be quite small with some even described as tiny, cramped and dark. These smaller rooms can feel cluttered with limited space for luggage or personal items. The older building means some rooms lack modern conveniences such as air conditioning, microwaves, coffee makers or sufficient outlets.
Various rooms have been described as dated with worn carpets, old-fashioned bathrooms and tired furniture that reflect the historic nature of the property but may not meet everyone’s standards. Noise can also be an issue with some rooms experiencing disturbances from street noise, exhaust fans or even internal heating systems.
Despite the varied feedback on room conditions and amenities, the overall charm and cleanliness, along with some spectacular views, make Pine Inn a rather unique and nostalgic accommodation choice in Carmel. Whether you’re captivated by its historical ambiance or seeking a comfortable, clean room with a view, Pine Inn offers a memorable stay with a mix of pros and cons that reflect its classic character.
Beds
However, some guests had issues with the size and stability of the beds. A few found the beds to be too small, especially for double rooms or for two people. There were also mentions of beds being soft to the point of discomfort, unstable or creaky. Some guests thought the beds were placed in inconvenient positions, like up against the wall or were too tall, requiring step stools to access. Additionally, there were concerns about musty-smelling or uncomfortable bedding that affected the overall experience.
In summary, while the beds at Pine Inn in Carmel are often praised for their comfort and size, some aspects regarding their stability, placement and the freshness of the bedding may need attention.
Cleanliness
However, several guests pointed out areas needing attention. Issues like dirty and unsanitary flooring, mold in bathrooms, dusty rooms and stained carpets were mentioned. Some guests encountered specific cleanliness problems, such as hair in the bathtub, rusted bathroom fixtures and even a dried-up tampon under the bed, highlighting a lack of thorough cleaning in certain instances.
In summary, while many reviews commend the Pine Inn for its clean and comfortable rooms, there is a consistent note of areas that require improvement, particularly in maintaining cleanliness standards throughout the hotel.
Staff
The personalized care and exceptional professionalism provided by the staff are notable and many found the team's attitude to be both warm and welcoming. The concierge and front desk attendants, including standouts like Margarita, are frequently praised for going above and beyond in their roles. Phrases like "treated us like family" and "helped with our luggage" indicate a staff willing to assist guests with various needs.
However, it's worth noting that there are occasional mentions of inconsistencies. While a vast majority experienced exemplary service, there were a few isolated incidents where staff behavior did not meet guests’ expectations with terms such as "rude" and "unwelcoming" occasionally cropping up. Despite these few negative remarks, the overall sentiment points towards a dedicated and friendly team committed to enhancing the guest experience.
Wi-Fi
Parking
The parking lot is not only oversubscribed but also operates on a first-come, first-served basis, leading to instances where guests were forced to seek alternative parking on nearby streets or at a sister hotel. While some guests appreciated the free parking offered, the benefit is offset by the difficulty of finding available spaces.
A few reviews mention the stress and complexity of the parking situation, suggesting that the hotel needs more spaces or a better system, possibly involving a reservation or payment for guaranteed spots. Despite this, some found occasional available spots and appreciated the complimentary parking inclusion. For those unable to park on-site, street parking becomes the necessary alternative, though it can add to the overall inconvenience.
Family
A few reviews highlighted that the Pine Inn might not be the best fit for young kids. Activity and noise from children were noted, which could disrupt the serene atmosphere that the hotel aims to provide. The accommodations are considered small, potentially limiting space for large families. Additionally, hot light bulbs present a safety concern for younger guests.
The historic nature and charm of Pine Inn appeal greatly to those appreciating vintage aesthetics and handicapped-friendly facilities, making it an excellent choice for business travelers and adults celebrating special occasions. So, while Pine Inn stands out for its location, charm and special accommodations, it appears better suited to adult guests rather than catering extensively to young children.
3 Star
However, the hotel seems to struggle with certain modern amenities and infrastructure. Recurring issues such as problematic showers, plumbing concerns and nightly noise disturbances have been noted. Additionally, the absence of in-room tea or coffee facilities and the lack of an elevator are frequently mentioned shortcomings.
The hotel is rated a three-star experience, aligning with the mixed assessments ranging from average stays to more enthusiastic reviews praising its distinctive style. Some guests believe that the place could benefit from renovations to elevate its overall appeal. Check-in flexibility is another area highlighted with some dissatisfaction around the timing.
In summary, Pine Inn - Carmel offers a quaint and historically rich stay, best suited for visitors who value character and tradition over modern conveniences.
Business
Accessible
No, Pine Inn - Carmel doesn't have any pool.
No, a spa isn't available at Pine Inn - Carmel.
No, Pine Inn - Carmel doesn't allow dogs.
Yes, parking facilities are available at Pine Inn - Carmel.
No, Pine Inn - Carmel doesn't have a gym.
Location Show Map
More Options
