Accessible, Cheap Hotels in Butler

Night Hotel Broadway is praised primarily for its exceptional location on the Upper West Side of Manhattan, providing effortless access to Times Square and other popular destinations via the 96th Street subway station. Guests appreciate the convenience of nearby amenities such as Central Park, numerous dining options, cafes and retail shops, all contributing to a vibrant yet relatively tranquil atmosphere.

The spacious and comfortable rooms receive mixed reviews regarding their condition. While many guests appreciated the size, good views and cleanliness maintained through daily housekeeping, there were recurring complaints about outdated furnishings, dirty carpets and faulty fixtures. Some guests reported issues like cigarette and musty odors, cockroach sightings and inadequate renovation, indicating a need for substantial improvements.

Cleanliness overall also received varied feedback. Several guests noted the regular changing of bed sheets and towels and the cleanliness of bathrooms and common areas. However, problems such as stained carpets, unpleasant smells and lack of thorough cleaning in hallways and elevators were frequently mentioned. Improvement in maintenance and more rigorous cleaning protocols are necessary to meet guest expectations fully.

The staff at Night Hotel Broadway garnered generally positive reviews. Many guests found the staff friendly, helpful and professional with a few standout individuals like CeCe and Justin being specifically praised for their exceptional service. Despite a few instances of rude or indifferent interactions, the staff's overall performance significantly contributed to a pleasant guest experience.

Issues were noted with the hotel's Wi-Fi service with many guests finding it unreliable and slow, especially in the rooms. Positive feedback was minimal and mostly mentioned good connectivity close to the modem. This suggests that substantial improvements in internet service are needed.

Parking at Night Hotel Broadway received mixed reviews. While some appreciated the attached garage and reserved spots, many found the parking to be expensive and limited. The provided vouchers often did not cover the cost and the garage's location was sometimes inconvenient for guests.

For families, the hotel offers large beds and spacious rooms adequate for family stays with amenities like bathtubs useful for small children. Despite these positives, safety concerns and instances of smoking on adjacent floors were noted, indicating areas needing attention to better accommodate families.

Regarding bed comfort, feedback was mixed with many finding the beds comfortable and clean and others pointing out issues with outdated and sagging mattresses. The general sentiment was that while some beds met standard expectations, others needed better maintenance and updates.

Night Hotel Broadway is described as a basic three-star hotel ideal for budget-conscious travelers, offering reasonable value for money thanks to its strategic location and friendly service. While its facilities and amenities did not exceed basic three-star expectations, the hotel excels in offering accessibility, particularly given its proximity to transportation options. Recommendations for improvements focus on upgrading room conditions and amenities, enhancing cleanliness throughout the property and improving internet service. Overall, Night Hotel Broadway presents itself as a practical choice for visitors seeking affordability and convenience during their NYC stay.

HI New York City Hostel in Manhattan earns glowing reviews for its prime location, conveniently close to Central Park, multiple subway stations and key landmarks like Times Square and Riverside Park. The Upper West Side neighborhood adds to its charm, offering a range of dining, shopping and recreational options within a safe and vibrant atmosphere. Its accessibility to public transportation further strengthens its appeal for tourists seeking an efficient base for exploring New York City.

The hostel doesn't include complimentary breakfast but compensates with an on-site café that serves a varied and affordable menu, including popular options like chicken chipotle and Mexican deli sandwiches. Although there are some minor complaints about the lack of diverse food options and occasional issues with food quality, the well-equipped kitchen and nearby grocery stores provide ample alternatives. The dining options, including a pleasant garden and patio area, generally receive positive feedback for their convenience and quality.

Accommodation at HI New York City Hostel is described as clean and spacious with particular praise for the diligent maintenance of both private and communal spaces. Guests find the beds comfortable and the presence of spacious lockers adds a sense of security. However, occasional issues with ventilation, temperature control and minor cleanliness lapses are noted. Despite this, the overall value is deemed fair given the strategic location and amenities.

The hostel excels in cleanliness with constant upkeep of bathrooms, showers and common areas consistently highlighted in guest reviews. The staff's friendliness and helpfulness significantly contribute to the hostel’s appeal, despite occasional reports of unprofessionalism and inefficiency. Most guests find the staff to be accommodating and hospitable.

The free Wi-Fi is generally reliable and fast, although some areas, particularly the 4th floor and dorm rooms, experience connectivity issues. Nevertheless, it meets the basic needs of most guests.

The social atmosphere at HI New York City Hostel is another strong point, characterized by numerous planned evening activities such as karaoke nights, stand-up comedy shows and pub crawls. These events create a collegiate environment that encourages interaction and the formation of new friendships. The nearby dive bars offer additional nightlife options, complementing the hostel’s social activities.

Overall, HI New York City Hostel stands out for its excellent location, cleanliness, comfortable accommodations and engaging social programs. While there are some areas for improvement, such as air conditioning noise and occasional lapses in staff responsiveness, the hostel remains a highly recommended, budget-friendly option for travelers looking to explore New York City.

La Quinta by Wyndham New York City Central Park offers a commendable stay for travelers seeking a convenient and accessible location in Manhattan. Nestled in the heart of the Upper West Side, the hotel's proximity to Central Park and nearby subway stations makes it an ideal starting point for exploring the city's attractions, museums, and cultural landmarks. Guests particularly appreciate the peaceful and safe neighborhood, complemented by a variety of dining options.

Reviewers frequently highlight the friendly and attentive staff, with many guests praising specific team members for their exceptional service, particularly during breakfast. The breakfast itself, included in the room rate, is positively regarded for its variety and value, despite some limitations in options for special diets. The small breakfast area is offset by the warmth and courtesy of the staff, enhancing the overall morning experience.

While the rooms are notably small, they are generally maintained clean and equipped with basic amenities such as flat-screen TVs and comfortable beds. However, the dated decor and occasional maintenance issues detract from the comfort. These compact accommodations are suited for guests who plan to spend more time exploring the city.

Cleanliness across the hotel is a mixed bag, with some areas requiring refurbishment and upkeep. Despite this, the staff's diligence in addressing these shortfalls is appreciated by many. The WiFi service, although free, is reported to have inconsistencies depending on the room's location.

The hotel presents a family-friendly environment in terms of location, though room size and safety concerns may limit its appeal to certain family groups. The comfortable beds receive praise for ensuring a restful night's sleep, contributing positively to the overall experience.

Overall, La Quinta by Wyndham New York City Central Park is a reasonable choice for travelers prioritizing location and value. While it is a three-star hotel with some areas needing improvement, its excellent position and welcoming staff make it a practical and budget-friendly option for a short city break in New York City.

The West Side YMCA is a highly valued budget accommodation in the heart of Manhattan, catering to travelers seeking to explore New York City without breaking the bank. Renowned for its unbeatable location, the YMCA is just steps away from Central Park and within walking distance of major attractions such as Broadway, Lincoln Center and Times Square. The surrounding neighborhood is vibrant yet safe, filled with cafes, shops and entertainment venues. The convenience of nearby public transportation, especially the Columbus Circle Subway Station, makes it an ideal base for exploring the city's cultural and touristic hotspots.

Guests highlight the exceptional value for money provided by this location, which offers access to Midtown Manhattan at a fraction of the typical cost. The hostel's amenities, though basic, are regarded by many as adequate considering the central location. While the rooms are generally described as simple and sometimes outdated, the air conditioning and essential amenities like towels, soap and mini-fridges are appreciated. The beds receive mixed reviews with some guests finding them comfortable while others note issues with mattress quality and bedding.

A significant perk of staying at the West Side YMCA is the access to comprehensive fitness facilities. The enormous, well-equipped gym includes a full-size basketball court, spinning machines, course rooms, weight rooms, an indoor track, a sauna, a steam room and an amazing pool. These facilities are praised for their maintenance and variety, adding notable value to the guest experience. The pool area is particularly well-liked, offering a clean and pleasant environment for swimming with additional amenities such as changing rooms, lockers and a sauna.

Cleanliness in shared spaces and common areas, as well as the diligence of the cleaning staff, is frequently commended. However, the cleanliness of individual rooms receives mixed feedback with some guests reporting issues such as dirt, dust and occasional pests. Shared bathrooms generally fare better, being cleaned daily and well-maintained, though more thorough and frequent cleaning is suggested.

The staff's performance also receives mixed reviews with many guests praising their friendliness, knowledge and helpfulness, especially the cleaning staff. Nonetheless, there are reports of inconsistent customer service with some guests finding the front desk and reception staff rude or unhelpful.

Free Wi-Fi is another area with notable variation in guest experiences. While some laud the Wi-Fi's speed and reliability, others find it sporadic and difficult to access, particularly in their rooms.

Overall, the West Side YMCA stands out as a highly accessible, central and value-oriented choice for budget-conscious travelers who prioritize location. With its extensive fitness facilities, convenient location and overall safety, it presents a compelling option despite some trade-offs in room quality and service consistency.

Nap York Central Park Sleep Station stands out as an exceptional choice for travelers looking to immerse themselves in the heart of Manhattan. Its prime location between Central Park and Times Square offers easy access to iconic landmarks such as Broadway, the Museum of Modern Art and Columbus Circle. Despite its bustling surroundings, the hostel maintains a quiet and peaceful atmosphere, ideal for restful nights after a day's exploration. Convenient access to several subway stations adds to its appeal, making city navigation a breeze.

The hostel provides a variety of dining options. Guests appreciate the well-equipped kitchenette with a fridge and microwave, along with complimentary coffee, tea and water. Additionally, the central location offers proximity to numerous eateries, fast-food options and a market with excellent offerings, ensuring guests have a wide array of dining choices.

Rooms at Nap York are celebrated for their cleanliness and modern design. Private bathrooms, bed curtains and spacious lockers contribute significantly to guests' comfort and privacy. The welcoming ambiance, thoughtful room amenities and modern, consistently clean bathrooms enhance the overall experience. However, guests may encounter issues with limited natural light, temperature control and noise isolation.

Cleanliness is consistently praised with well-maintained rooms, bathrooms and common spaces. The friendly and helpful staff play a crucial role by promptly addressing cleaning requests and ensuring a tidy environment.

The staff's accommodating and friendly nature is a significant highlight with numerous commendations for their professionalism and attentiveness, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere. While there are occasional reports of staff unavailability or rude behavior, the general consensus is highly positive.

Wi-Fi receives mixed reviews; many guests find it reliable and strong, particularly with USB sockets and charging cables at beds. However, some experience weak and unstable connections, particularly in rooms, which can be frustrating.

The beds offer a blend of comfort and privacy, often exceeding the standards of many hotels. Equipped with blackout curtains, power outlets, shelves, lights and fans, they ensure an undisturbed sleep. However, some guests find the pillows flat and blankets thin and upper bunk access can be challenging.

Nap York's adult-only policy creates a tranquil environment, particularly appreciated by solo female travelers due to gender-segregated floors, including a floor dedicated exclusively to women. Although the lack of social areas and the somewhat dark ambiance might not appeal to everyone, the practical in-room amenities and clean organized spaces provide a focused and restful stay.

Overall, Nap York Central Park Sleep Station offers a clean, comfortable and centrally located accommodation with a range of privacy and convenience-enhancing features, ideal for short, focused stays in New York City.

Fairfield By Marriott New York Manhattan Times Square stands out as a well-placed hotel lauded for its prime location near Times Square, making it an ideal base for exploring New York City. Its proximity to key attractions like Central Park, Rockefeller Center and Broadway theaters, along with excellent access to public transportation, facilitates easy navigation around the city. The central positioning also ensures that restaurants, shops and nightlife venues are within comfortable walking distance, enhancing the convenience for guests.

Breakfast at the hotel receives a positive reception overall with a varied and plentiful selection including scrambled eggs, sausages, fruits, DIY waffles and Starbucks coffee. The friendly breakfast staff contribute to a pleasant dining experience, despite occasional crowding and the use of disposable utensils which some guests found less than ideal.

Guests find the rooms clean, comfortable and spacious considering the heart of Manhattan location. Comfortable beds and tidy setups are frequently praised, along with great views from higher floors. However, some guests noted small room sizes, outdated furnishings and external noise as minor drawbacks.

The hotel garners generally positive reviews for cleanliness with rooms and public areas well-maintained. The diligent housekeeping staff plays a significant role in maintaining a pleasant environment, though there are occasional mentions of inconsistencies in cleanliness, especially in hallways and carpets.

The staff at Fairfield By Marriott New York Manhattan Times Square are often highlighted as a standout feature, praised for their friendliness, professionalism and helpfulness. From the front desk to the breakfast crew, team members like Gregory, Thresa and Diomarys have been specifically commended for their excellent service.

WiFi access receives mixed feedback. While the connection is reliable and excellent in public areas, some guests report issues with connectivity and reliability in the rooms. The staff, however, are noted for their responsiveness in addressing these issues.

The hotel is recognized as family-friendly, providing a welcoming atmosphere and family-oriented amenities. Its location helps families easily access various attractions, making it convenient for family explorations. The comfortable beds also contribute to restful nights, enhancing the overall appeal for family stays.

For nightlife enthusiasts, the hotel's central location near Times Square offers easy access to a myriad of dining and entertainment options, though the area can be noisy and occasionally less safe at night.

Business travelers appreciate the hotel's central location and good value for money with essential amenities such as meeting rooms and a business center. The friendly and accommodating staff further enhance the business travel experience.

The hotel strives to cater to guests with disabilities, providing easy access to transportation and various accommodations to ensure a comfortable stay.

In summary, Fairfield By Marriott New York Manhattan Times Square delivers a well-rounded experience with its fantastic location, comfortable rooms, friendly staff and good amenities, making it a solid choice for tourists, families and business travelers alike.

The Gallivant Times Square garners substantial praise for its outstanding location, providing guests with unparalleled access to major New York City attractions such as Times Square, Broadway theaters, Central Park and Rockefeller Center. The hotel’s proximity to public transportation, iconic sites and vibrant nightlife makes it ideal for tourists, theater enthusiasts and those wanting to experience the lively city atmosphere.

The hotel’s rooms receive mixed feedback. Positively, some guests appreciated the pleasant decor, cleanliness upon arrival and spacious family accommodations. Housekeeping efforts were generally noted as friendly and efficient. Nevertheless, many guests felt the room sizes were smaller than expected with some encountering cleanliness issues and outdated or malfunctioning amenities. Reports of noise from both within and outside the hotel disturbed some stays, emphasizing the need for improved soundproofing and maintenance.

The staff at The Gallivant Times Square are mostly praised for their friendliness and helpfulness. Specific employees were noted for exceptional service, contributing positively to many guests' experiences. However, the front desk received mixed reviews with some guests finding the staff at check-in and customer service points unhelpful or rude.

In terms of amenities, the WiFi service drew significant complaints due to inconsistency and unreliable connections, detracting from the overall stay experience despite occasional positive mentions of helpful staff. The fitness facilities were another point of disappointment with many guests mentioning outdated equipment and closures for refurbishment.

For families, the hotel is seen as accommodating, particularly with spacious family rooms featuring enough beds for larger groups. Despite some maintenance issues, the convenience and location of the hotel contributed positively to family stays.

However, breakfast services have been a significant letdown. Guests frequently reported confusion and frustration over the unavailability of breakfast despite it being advertised, resulting in negative impacts on their overall satisfaction.

The vibrant nightlife around the hotel, while exciting for those seeking entertainment, has been noted as a disturbance for many guests due to loud music and vibrations from nearby clubs. Light sleepers might find this environment challenging without earplugs.

As for the beds, reviews are variable. Many guests found them comfortable and conducive to a good night’s sleep. Conversely, several reports flagged issues like broken or unstable beds and cleanliness concerns such as stained or dirty linens.

In summary, The Gallivant Times Square stands out for its unbeatable location and friendly staff. However, it faces significant challenges in maintaining consistent room quality, reliable amenities, clear communication regarding services and offering a peaceful environment amid its bustling setting. While the hotel offers a generally good quality/price ratio reflective of its four-star rating, many areas require improvement to meet the higher expectations of a four-star establishment.

The Paramount Times Square - A Generator Hotel offers a mixed experience, standing out for its enviable location and helpful staff but grappling with issues in room quality and amenities.

The hotel's prime positioning is frequently lauded by guests, providing easy access to Broadway shows, Times Square, Central Park and various shopping and dining options. This makes it an ideal choice for visitors who want to immerse themselves in the heart of New York City’s vibrant atmosphere. Proximity to public transportation further enhances its attractiveness.

Guests often mention the lack of breakfast options as a significant drawback with no restaurant or in-room amenities like coffee makers. However, nearby cafes and restaurants, such as Bond 45, offer convenient alternatives for morning meals.

Rooms at the Paramount Hotel receive mixed feedback. Positive reviews highlight cleanliness and comfortable beds, attributes maintained by diligent housekeeping staff. Early check-ins without additional charges are also appreciated. Conversely, the size of the rooms is a common complaint with many describing them as cramped and outdated. Issues with room amenities, such as nonworking AC units and faulty bathroom fixtures, further detract from the experience. The hotel's continued renovations and noise disturbances from the surroundings also pose challenges for a restful stay.

Cleanliness across common areas, particularly the lobby, garners consistent praise for being inviting and well-maintained. However, rooms show signs of wear and need for renovation with complaints about worn-out carpets, stained walls and inadequate maintenance being recurrent. Efforts by cleaning staff are noted but room conditions often fall short of expectations.

Staff service is a standout feature with many guests commending the friendliness, helpfulness and efficiency of the front desk, housekeeping and concierge teams. Despite occasional encounters with less helpful staff, the overall sentiment highlights the positive influence of the staff on the guest experience.

The WiFi service sees mixed reviews. While some guests enjoy fast and reliable internet, others experience weak or intermittent connections, particularly in their rooms. Consistency and reliability of the WiFi need improvement.

The gym at the hotel is generally well-received, described as clean and functional, despite being on the smaller side. However, periods of closure and maintenance issues, such as broken equipment, detract from the experience for some guests.

For families, the hotel’s central location is a significant advantage, making it easy to explore city attractions. Larger rooms and a friendly environment add to its family-friendly appeal, though the limited space in standard rooms may be a challenge for those with more members.

Nightlife enthusiasts value the hotel's proximity to Broadway, bars and restaurants, allowing for easy exploration of New York’s vibrant entertainment scene. However, the lively surroundings can bring about noise disturbances, which might affect light sleepers.

The beds receive mixed feedback with many guests finding them comfortable, while others note issues with bed size and mattress quality. This inconsistency in comfort may affect overall sleep quality.

In conclusion, while Paramount Times Square - A Generator Hotel’s exceptional location and dedicated staff are key strengths, improvements in room quality, amenities and maintenance are needed to elevate the overall guest experience to match its four-star reputation. The hotel remains a convenient and practical choice for those prioritizing location and access to Broadway shows and other city landmarks.

Situated in the heart of Times Square, Hotel Edison Times Square is lauded for its unbeatable location, perfect for those aiming to explore the vibrant core of New York City. The hotel's prime position places guests just steps away from Broadway theaters, Central Park and numerous iconic sights with easy access to subway stations. The immediate vicinity is bustling with dining options, shopping avenues and entertainment, making it an ideal base for sightseeing and experiencing the lively ambience of Times Square and its surroundings.

The hotel offers a grab-and-go breakfast experience that, while convenient for its quick and practical nature, garners mixed reviews due to limited variety and quality of food. Nevertheless, the inclusion of breakfast in the room rate is appreciated by many guests.

Dining at Hotel Edison is a notable highlight with on-site options such as Bond 45 and Friedman's receiving praise for their delicious offerings and pre-theater dinner options. The Rum House bar stands out for its remarkable mojitos and vibrant live entertainment. An art deco vibe and friendly staff further enhance the dining experience, despite occasional drawbacks like wait times and spotty service.

Rooms at Hotel Edison receive a blend of praise and criticism. Guests appreciate the clean, comfortable accommodations with some rooms being spacious by New York standards. Remodeled bathrooms, large comfortable beds and consistent housekeeping add to the positive feelings. However, the rooms are often described as small, outdated and in need of renovation with issues like noisy air conditioning, minimal amenities and occasional cleanliness lapses.

Cleanliness standards are generally high with many guests highlighting the freshness of linens and towels and the efficiency of the housekeeping team. Despite isolated complaints about dust, odors and outdated fixtures, the overall sense of safety and cleanliness contributes to a welcoming atmosphere.

The staff at Hotel Edison is predominantly praised for their friendliness and helpfulness, adding significantly to the guest experience. The reception, concierge, cleaning teams and restaurant staff at Bond 45 stand out for their professionalism and courteous behavior, despite occasional lapses in hospitality from front desk personnel.

WiFi connectivity presents a mixed experience with some guests finding it excellent and reliable, while others report intermittent and weak service, particularly in the rooms. The fitness center, on the other hand, is well-received for its well-equipped and accessible nature, providing a pleasant workout experience.

For those requiring parking, the valet service is appreciated for its convenience but noted for its expense and occasional delays. The hotel is also recognized for its family-friendly atmosphere, offering room configurations suitable for small families and on-site amenities that cater to children. Its central location allows easy access to city attractions, making it a solid choice for family stays.

Nightlife at Hotel Edison is vibrant with numerous nearby bars, live music venues and on-site nightly entertainment. The hotel's proximity to Broadway and various clubs and bars ensures guests can easily enjoy the lively nightlife scene, although noise may be an issue for lighter sleepers. Lastly, the comfort of the beds is a major plus with many guests finding them exceptionally comfortable and supportive, contributing to a restful stay.